Concept
Real Property Interests
Excluded transactions (§ 9-109)
Real Property Interests
Section 9-109(d) lists the transactions that Article 9 does not cover, and one entry removes interests in real property.1 Article 9 governs security interests in personal property and fixtures, so a bank that lends against a farmer's cattle is within it.2 A bank that lends against the farm itself is not, because land is neither personal property nor a fixture.3
The line is harder to hold than it looks, because a contract that creates an interest in real estate is still a contract. The obligation that a mortgage, a lease, or a contract for deed imposes on the obligor is the obligee's personal property.4 A lender can therefore take collateral that sounds like real estate but is really a stream of payments. Article 9 and real property law divide this ground almost cleanly, and the exceptions mark the places where the division blurs.5 This unit takes the core exclusion first, then the exceptions for fixtures and mixed collateral, and last the rule that lets a lender take a mortgagee's right to payment as collateral.
Mortgages and Real Estate Leases
Article 9 applies to every transaction that creates a security interest in personal property, and a security interest is an interest in personal property or fixtures that secures payment or performance of an obligation.6 The real property exclusion marks where that reach stops. Section 9-109(d)(11) removes “the creation or transfer of an interest in or lien on real property, including a lease or rents thereunder,” except to the extent that provision is made for four matters taken up in the next section.7 When the collateral is neither personal property nor fixtures, Article 9 does not apply, even if the parties have created what looks like a security interest.8
The exclusion's paradigm cases are the real estate mortgage and the land sale contract, along with other forms of security in realty.9 Suppose Bank lends to A, A signs a promissory note, and A secures the loan with a mortgage on A's land. The note is a promise to pay money, but the transaction in which A gives Bank the note and the mortgage is a real estate financing, and Article 9 does not govern it.10
Leases and rents are named in the exclusion because of how Article 9 would otherwise classify them. A landlord's right to be paid rent is a right to payment, and without the exclusion it would be an account.11 Suppose A leases land to B and then grants C an interest in the rent payments to secure a debt A owes C. The lease between A and B is outside Article 9, and so is A's grant to C.12
A different exclusion also mentions landlords, and the two should not be confused. Subsection (d)(1) removes a landlord's lien, other than an agricultural lien,13 as one of the nonconsensual liens created by statute or common law that Article 9 leaves alone, except for priority against an Article 9 security interest.14 A landlord's lien arises by operation of law. A lender's interest in rents arises by the owner's grant, and the real property exclusion covers that grant.
Crops mark the line from the other side. Under Sections 2-107 and 9-102(a)(44), crops are goods and not realty, so a lender who wants a security interest in crops must comply with Article 9.15 Oil, gas, and minerals before extraction fall outside Article 9, but once extraction occurs, real estate security interests in them generally terminate and Article 9 takes over.16
Each result follows from what the lender took, not from where the collateral sits. A stem that mentions a farm or a building invites the quick answer that Article 9 is out, and a stem that mentions a growing crop invites the opposite mistake of treating everything on the land as real property. Start with the collateral instead. A lien on land, or an interest in a lease and its rents, sends the transaction to real property law; crops and other goods keep it in Article 9. The exclusion decides which body of law governs, and a mortgage outside Article 9 is no less a mortgage for that.
Fixtures and Mixed Collateral
The exclusion carries four exceptions, introduced by the words “except to the extent that provision is made for.” They return to Article 9 liens on real property in Sections 9-203 and 9-308,18 fixtures in Section 9-334,19 fixture filings in Sections 9-501, 9-502, 9-512, 9-516, and 9-519,20 and security agreements covering personal and real property in Section 9-604.21 Each exception admits only the provisions it names. The first applies when a lender takes a mortgagee's right to payment, and the next section covers it. The other three apply where personal property and land meet in a single transaction.
A boiler bolted into a factory shows why these exceptions exist. The boiler began as goods that a lender could finance, and it may have become a fixture once installed. Section 9-334 keeps the financing lender inside Article 9: an Article 9 security interest may be created in goods that are fixtures, and it may continue in goods that become fixtures.22 The lender keeps its Article 9 interest after the installers leave. Rival claims to the boiler, such as those of the factory's mortgagee, are a matter of priority, taken up elsewhere in the course.
The fixture-filing exception works with the fixture rule. A lender who protects an interest in fixtures gives notice of it by a fixture filing, and the exception keeps the rules for that filing in Article 9.23 Compare the mortgage-note rule in the next section, where an interest that rides along with a payment right needs no filing in the real estate records at all.24
The last exception covers a lender whose collateral spans both sides of the line, such as a mortgage on a plant plus a security interest in the equipment inside it. That lender holds lien interests in both real and personal property. Section 9-604 handles security agreements covering both, and Article 9 keeps certain enforcement rights for such a secured party.25 The mechanics belong with enforcement. For scope, the exception shows that Article 9 reaches into real estate wherever one lender's collateral is mixed.
The exceptions are narrow by design. A security interest in fixtures is within Article 9, but the mortgage lien on the land itself stays with real property law.
Security Interests in Mortgage Notes
The exclusion leaves open the case of a lender who takes the debt that land secures rather than the land itself. Section 9-109(b) answers it: “The application of this article to a security interest in a secured obligation is not affected by the fact that the obligation is itself secured by a transaction or interest to which this article does not apply.”27 The familiar secured obligation is a promissory note backed by a mortgage. When a lender takes the right to be paid, Article 9 governs the lender's interest even though real estate backs the debt.
The reason is that a mortgage is still a contract at bottom. The obligation the mortgagor owes the mortgagee is the mortgagee's personal property, so a lender who takes the mortgagee's rights under the mortgage is reaching for a contract right and not for the land.28 That attempt is subject to Article 9.29
Article 9 also supplies the steps, and the mortgage rides along. Attachment of a security interest in the note attaches the interest to the mortgage as well, under Section 9-203(g). Perfection of a security interest in collateral also perfects a security interest in a supporting obligation for the collateral, and the mortgage is such an obligation, so the lender files nothing in the real estate records.30 The same discussion adds that the drafters rejected cases such as In re Maryville Savings & Loan Corp., 743 F.2d 413 (6th Cir. 1984).31
Carrying the mortgage along settles who holds the interest, and it leaves the land where it was. A secured party who wants to enforce its rights as assignee of the mortgage against the real estate must do so under real property law.32
The line therefore runs between mortgagee and mortgagor. A mortgagee who offers the note and mortgage as collateral for its own borrowing is dealing in a payment right, and Article 9 governs. A mortgagor who offers an interest in the land is dealing in real property, and the exclusion applies.33 The text of the exclusion names rents but does not name a mortgagee's right to payment, and subsection (b) supplies the rest: an obligation secured by an excluded interest remains an obligation Article 9 can reach.