Concept
Wage Assignments
Excluded transactions (§ 9-109)
Wage Assignments
Article 9 reaches broadly: it applies to all transactions that create a security interest in personal property.1 Section 9-109(d)(3) carves out one category anyway. It excludes "an assignment of a claim for wages, salary, or other compensation of an employee."2
The right being assigned is the employee's claim against an employer for pay. "Other compensation" is broad enough to reach pay beyond base wages, such as a bonus. The phrase "of an employee" limits the exclusion to pay that someone earns as an employee.
Consent does not explain this exclusion. A landlord's lien or a repairer's lien arises without the debtor's agreement, but a wage assignment is typically a bargain the employee strikes, often to secure repayment of a loan. Article 9 steps aside for a different reason: other federal and state statutes already regulate these assignments, and the assignments raise important social issues that other law addresses.3 State or federal law may limit a contractual assignment of wages or prohibit it outright.4
The exclusion has two effects. First, whether an employee may assign pay at all is a question for that other law. Second, even when the assignment is allowed, Article 9 does not prescribe the rules for obtaining an interest in the pay.5 A lender with a permitted assignment therefore does not look to Article 9's attachment and perfection rules to complete it.
The standard illustration is a salary assignment. A agrees to assign 10% of A's monthly salary to B for one year to pay a debt A owes B. Other law governs whether A may make that assignment. Even if other law allows it, Article 9 does not govern the transaction between A and B.6
Excluded does not mean void. The exclusion decides which body of law answers the question; it does not decide the answer. Taking the transaction out of Article 9 means that other law determines whether an interest in the pay may arise to secure payment or performance of an obligation.7 A creditor whose assignment satisfies that law has whatever that law gives, and Article 9's rules play no part.
The words "of an employee" do the sorting, so the first question on any fact pattern is whose right to payment is being assigned and what produced it. A borrower who assigns money owed to the borrower invites a quick match to the wage exclusion. The match fails whenever the right is not an employee's pay.
The first borrower holds a claim for an employee's compensation, which is exactly what subsection (d)(3) names. Other law therefore decides whether the assignment is allowed and how the lender obtains an interest. The second borrower holds an account, a right to be paid by third parties for goods or services, and Article 9 governs a security interest in accounts.8 The word "compensation" does not settle the matter. The exclusion speaks of an employee's compensation, and a repair business's claim against its customers does not become an employee's pay because workers did the repairs.