Concept
The Debtor-Location Rule
Perfection of security interests in multiple state transactions (§ 9-301)
The Debtor-Location Rule
Every multistate perfection problem starts with where the debtor is located. Under UCC 9-301(1), while a debtor is located in a jurisdiction, that jurisdiction's local law governs three things about a security interest in collateral: perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and priority.1 In other words, one jurisdiction's law tells the secured party how to perfect, what perfection (or its absence) accomplishes, and how the interest ranks against competing claims.
The opening words, "except as otherwise provided in this section," make this a default rule. Each later subsection is a carve-out, so the method for any problem is the same: start with the debtor's location, then ask whether the collateral or the kind of security interest falls into a category the section pulls away from that location.
The word "while" ties the governing law to the debtor's location at a given time. If the debtor is located in State A, State A's law governs; if the debtor later moves, the rule points to wherever the debtor is then located. The sections on relocation work out what happens to a perfection obtained under the old law.
Subsection (2) is the first carve-out. For a possessory security interest, the law of the jurisdiction where the collateral is located governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and priority.2 It uses the same three-part scope as subsection (1) but a different connecting factor, and it also applies only "while" the collateral is in that jurisdiction. Suppose a debtor located in State A leaves a diamond ring with a lender in State B as security. Because the lender holds the ring, subsection (2) sends the three questions to State B's law, even though subsection (1) would otherwise have pointed to State A.
The default can be applied only once the debtor's location is known. The sections that follow therefore work out where individuals, unregistered organizations, registered organizations, and foreign debtors are located, and then take up the exceptions, beginning with possessory security interests.