Concept
Sales of Receivables
Subject matter of Article 9 (§ 9-109)
Sales of Receivables
A sale of receivables looks like the opposite of a secured loan, and Article 9 covers it anyway. Section 9-109(a)(3) applies the Article to "a sale of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes."1 In each of these four sales the buyer becomes the outright owner of the asset, the seller keeps no interest in it, and nothing stands behind the transfer as security for an obligation.2 The statute reaches true sales, not only loans dressed up as sales.
The Article makes room for these sales by deeming the buyer's interest a security interest, even though the buyer owns the asset. The buyer is then a "secured party," and the seller is a debtor.3 Suppose ABC, Inc. sells its accounts to Frank Factor. The parties call the transfer a sale and never mention a security interest. Article 9 governs anyway: ABC is the debtor, Frank is the secured party, and the deal is a secured transaction.4 A student who sees the word sale and finds no debt may conclude that Article 9 is out of the picture. For these four assets that conclusion is wrong. Once the buyer holds secured-party status, the Article's perfection and priority rules apply to it, and the cost of that status appears below.
The same roles follow the receivable wherever it goes. When A sells equipment to B on ten days' credit, B's obligation is an account. If A sells that account to C, A is the debtor and C is the secured party. When A lends B $1,000,000 and sells C a $100,000 participation, C owns the right to receive $100,000 of what B owes. That right is a payment intangible, so A is again the debtor and C the secured party.5 Sales of payment intangibles cover, among other things, the participations that large banks grant to smaller banks.6
The four-item list is recent. The 1972 Code covered only "any sale of accounts or chattel paper." Under that rule, a sale of commercial loans or credit card receivables would not have been covered, because it would have been a sale of general intangibles. The 1999 revision defined accounts to include credit card receivables and added payment intangibles and promissory notes to the list, which brings almost all securitization within Article 9.7 When you read an older case, check whether the court applied the pre-1999 rules or the current ones.
Coverage of sales makes sense once you see how receivables are financed. A classic factor pays the owner of an account perhaps 85 to 95 cents on the dollar, collects the full amount, and keeps the spread as the equivalent of interest. In the classic bargain the factor has no recourse against the seller, so the factor bears the credit risk that the account debtor will not pay.8 A lender who advances money against the same accounts takes a note and a security interest, and the borrower must make up any shortfall from other assets. The borrower keeps the credit risk.9 Real deals fall between these poles. In one factoring agreement, the client promised to give prompt notice of customer disputes and to settle them at its own expense, and it became liable for all the unpaid factored accounts if it failed to settle a dispute.10 Whether such a deal is a sale or a loan is a hard question. Article 9 supplies no test for answering it, and the characterization rests on all the facts and circumstances.11
The drafters therefore declined to make scope turn on the answer. Comment 4 reports that covering sales of accounts and chattel paper has generally avoided the difficult problem of separating transactions in which a receivable secures an obligation from those in which it was sold outright, because in many commercial financing transactions the distinction is blurred.12 Labels cannot do the sorting either. Courts in Pennsylvania and elsewhere refuse to be controlled by the names parties give their relationship.13
The list is exact. Article 9 does not apply to the sale of a business's customer lists.14 Certain sales and assignments of the listed receivables are also excluded entirely, and later sections take up those exclusions.15 One rule stretches the Article in the other direction: it applies to a security interest in an obligation that is itself secured by collateral, even when the transaction that created that collateral lies outside Article 9. The later section on security in secured obligations develops the point.16
Coverage carries consequences for the buyer. An assignee under a transaction governed by Article 9 generally takes subject to the account debtor's defenses and claims, which puts it in the shoes of its assignor.17 A buyer of accounts takes the same position. The buyer's interest also falls under the Article's enforcement rules, which apply only to security interests within its scope. A right in property created outside Article 9 is not governed by Part 6.18
The consequence that matters most on exams is perfection. A buyer of accounts or chattel paper that fails to take the proper action risks losing to a later buyer or creditor who obtains an interest superior to its own.19 The most common rival is the bankruptcy trustee. As of the petition date, federal law gives the trustee the rights of a lien creditor, and under § 9-317 a lien creditor has priority over an unperfected security interest.20 The same exposure arises between buyers. If A sells its accounts to B, B does not perfect, and A then sells the same accounts to C, who does, B has run the risk just described. Because B failed to perfect, C can obtain an interest superior to B's.21 Later chapters supply the full priority rules.
What counts as perfecting depends on the asset. A buyer of a payment intangible or promissory note is perfected automatically under § 9-309, because the drafters concluded that filing was unnecessary for these financing transactions.22 Accounts are different. Automatic perfection applies to accounts only if they are not a significant part of the seller's accounts, so a buyer taking a large body of receivables should file. A buyer of chattel paper must file or take possession.23 Even for notes, automatic perfection leaves a gap. Buyers of a promissory note in the ordinary course take free of the security interest, and a secured party that also takes possession protects itself against holders in due course, because no one can become a holder in due course while the secured party holds the note.24
The sale-or-loan question matters at one point after all. Automatic perfection applies only if the transaction is a sale of the intangible or note. A grant of a security interest or a mere assignment for security is within Article 9 but gets no automatic perfection, and the line between the two lies mostly in how much recourse the transferee has against the transferor.25 Recourse is irrelevant to whether Article 9 applies, but it decides whether the buyer must file.