Concept
Why UCC Conflicts Persist
General Rules (§ 1-301, et seq.)
UCC Choice-of-Law Rules
Why UCC Conflicts Persist
Every state has enacted some form of the Uniform Commercial Code, and the Code aims for substantial uniformity in the law governing the commercial transactions it covers. That fact suggests that a court in any state would read the same text and reach the same result, so that choice of law could never matter. Uniform adoption does not eliminate every conflict, though, and the Code therefore includes provisions that attempt to govern the conflicts that remain.1 Three features of the Code's history keep those conflicts alive:
- Some states enacted the Code with changes to particular provisions, so two states' versions can differ on the very point that decides a case.
- The Code has been revised from time to time, and states have not adopted each revision at the same time, so at any moment some states hold the revised text and others hold the earlier one.
- A transaction with an international side will likely include a party from a nation where the UCC is not in force, so the competing source of law may not be a Code at all.
Each gap forces a judge to decide something before applying any UCC rule: whose law governs. A court never applies "the UCC" in the abstract. It applies the Code as enacted by a particular jurisdiction, and when choice-of-law rules call for another jurisdiction's law, the forum's Article 3 may not apply even though the instrument before the court satisfies every one of its requirements.2 In Western Auto Supply v. Craig, a note was executed in Alabama to a payee whose principal place of business was in Missouri, and the note provided that Missouri law would govern it. The court determined that the agreement was effective.3
Because these questions arise so often in commercial disputes, the Code's choice-of-law provisions are probably the most heavily litigated statutory choice-of-law provisions in the United States.4 The Code's answer is statutory direction, an uncommon but increasing phenomenon in conflict of laws: instead of leaving every question to a court's general conflicts analysis, the Code contains specific choice-of-law instructions.5 The central provision, § 1-301, answers one question: whose law governs a UCC transaction that touches more than one state or nation. It does so in three parts, and later sections take them in this order:
- Subsection (a) lets the parties pick the governing law. When a transaction bears a reasonable relation to the forum state (the statute's "this state") and also to another state or nation, the parties may agree that the law of either one governs their rights and duties.6
- Subsection (b) supplies the default when the parties made no effective choice. The forum's UCC "applies to transactions bearing an appropriate relation to this state," subject to the exceptions in subsection (c).7
- Subsection (c) preserves specific UCC provisions that carry their own governing-law instructions. For the matters those provisions cover, they, and not the general rules, supply the answer.8
One warning about old and new versions will save confusion later. The 2001 revision of the Code gave parties unlimited freedom to choose the governing law, unlike its pre-2001 predecessor, whose rules you will still see cited by their old number, § 1-105.9 The states refused to follow. With the exception of the Virgin Islands, even jurisdictions that adopted revised Article 1 either declined the proposed § 1-301 or replaced its language with that of old § 1-105. In 2008 the ALI substituted the substance of former § 1-105 for its own proposal, and it appears the 2001 text will not be enacted in any state.10 The reasonable-relation limit on party choice in subsection (a) therefore remains the operative rule, and a later section tells how the 2001 proposal rose and failed.