Concept
Neighboring Reputation Exceptions
Reputation concerning character
Neighboring Reputation Exceptions
Reputation testimony looks the same whichever exception rescues it: a witness tells the court what a group of people say. Rule 803 contains three exceptions for that kind of testimony, and the subject of the talk sorts them. Rule 803(21) admits "a reputation among a person's associates or in the community concerning the person's character."1 Rule 803(19) admits reputation about a person's family facts, and Rule 803(20) admits reputation about land and about general history.2 All three sit in Rule 803, so none depends on showing that the declarants, the people whose talk makes up the reputation, are unavailable.3
The earlier sections of this chapter assumed that the reputation at issue was a reputation for a trait such as honesty or peacefulness. A reputation on any other subject falls outside the words of Rule 803(21). The first question for any reputation problem is therefore what the community is saying, and only then whether the witness is placed to report it. The three rules answer that question differently:
| Exception | The reputation concerns | Whose talk counts | Timing condition in the text |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rule 803(19) | birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, death, relationship by blood, adoption, or marriage, or similar facts of personal or family history | the person's family by blood, adoption, or marriage; the person's associates; the community | none stated |
| Rule 803(20) | boundaries of land in the community, customs that affect the land, general historical events important to the community, state, or nation | a community | reputation must arise before the controversy |
| Rule 803(21) | the person's character | the person's associates or the community | none stated |
An offer that fits none of these subjects has no reputation exception behind it, however well the witness knows the community. Each exception also clears only the hearsay objection. For reputation about character, the character-evidence rules still decide whether the proof may be offered at all.
Personal or Family History
Rule 803(19) is the closest relative of the character exception. It admits reputation "among a person's family by blood, adoption, or marriage," and also reputation "among a person's associates or in the community," when the reputation concerns "birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, death, relationship by blood, adoption, or marriage, or similar facts of personal or family history."4 Rule 803(21) shares two of those sources, associates and community, but reaches only a reputation "concerning the person's character."5 The two rules share a form and differ in subject.
Because the form is shared, it cannot tell you which rule applies. A witness who says it was commonly understood that one person was another's child relays the out-of-court assertions of many speakers, offered for their truth, and none of them can be cross-examined. A character witness raises the same problem. The sorting turns on subject matter. A trait of the person, such as honesty, belongs to Rule 803(21), and a fact of family history, such as birth, marriage, ancestry, or kinship, belongs to Rule 803(19). The family-history rule draws on three sources: the family, the community, and associates familiar with the reputation about the persons whose relationship is in question.6 The family is the one source the character rule does not name.
Walter's lack of firsthand knowledge does not matter. A witness who reports this reputation must have personal knowledge of the reputation, meaning real exposure to the family's talk, but need not have personal knowledge of the relationship itself.7 The testimony is secondhand by design, so a rule demanding that the witness have seen the birth would exclude the very proof the exception admits. The foundation is the same kind a character witness needs, because it asks how close the witness stands to the talk and not to the underlying events. A stranger who has never heard the family discuss the matter has no reputation to report.
The witness's own connection to the family does not decide which rule applies; the subject of the reputation does. Testimony that a family fact is commonly understood is also not offered to show a disposition, so the character-evidence rules behind Rule 803(21) do not come into play. On an exam, ask what the community is saying, and then ask whether the witness has heard it.
Boundaries and General History
Rule 803(20) admits "a reputation in a community—arising before the controversy—concerning boundaries of land in the community or customs that affect the land, or concerning general historical events important to that community, state, or nation."9 The same sorting question applies. Talk about where one farm ends and the next begins, about a local custom affecting the use of land, or about an event in the history of the town, state, or nation belongs to Rule 803(20). Talk about whether a person is honest or peaceable belongs to Rule 803(21).
The group whose talk counts differs among the rules. Rule 803(20) names a community alone, Rule 803(19) adds the person's family and associates, and Rule 803(21) reaches the person's associates or the community.10 Timing is the difference that decides exam problems. Only Rule 803(20) contains the phrase "arising before the controversy," and neither Rule 803(19) nor Rule 803(21) has anything like it.
The phrase modifies the reputation itself, ahead of the point where the rule turns to land or to history. The evident worry is that opinion forming after a dispute began may have been shaped by the dispute. Where a boundary is the very point in contest, each side has a stake in what the neighbors say, and talk that took shape after the suit was filed may have come from the litigation, from the parties' own conversations or from an effort to shore up a position. A reputation already settled before anyone had reason to contest the line formed when no one had a motive to tilt it. A witness who first heard the talk after the suit began can still report a reputation that existed long before, because the condition looks to when the community's view arose and not to when the witness learned of it.
Rule 803(21) contains no timing clause. Its text asks for a reputation among the person's associates or in the community concerning the person's character, and it asks for nothing more.11 The two texts should be held apart, and neither should be read into the other. An answer that rejects a character reputation because it did not predate the controversy has carried the boundary rule's condition to the wrong exception. An answer that admits boundary talk formed after the suit has left that condition behind in the right one. Whatever limits apply to a character reputation come from the three conditions in its own text, reputation, associates or community, and character, and from the character-evidence rules that decide whether the proof may be offered at all.