Concept
Hearsay Is Only One Hurdle
Reputation concerning character
Hearsay Is Only One Hurdle
Rule 803(21) answers one objection to reputation testimony and leaves every other objection standing. The rule excepts from the hearsay bar "a reputation among a person's associates or in the community concerning the person's character."1 Every word of that sentence describes the source and subject of a statement. Nothing in it says whether character may be proved in the case at hand, which party may offer the proof, or what the proof may be used to show. Rule 803 lists statements "not excluded by the rule against hearsay," and that is all a place on the list accomplishes.2
Character proof arrives with its own rules. Evidence of a pertinent trait comes in to show conduct in conformity with the trait and to impeach credibility, and a party may prove the trait by reputation or by opinion. Reputation proof raises a hearsay issue, and Rule 803(21), which deals only with the hearsay aspect, resolves it.3 The exception therefore supports the character rules without expanding them. It admits reputation testimony those rules already allow, and it admits nothing they would keep out.
The two inquiries stay apart because they guard against different dangers. The hearsay question asks whether a witness may relay what the community says even though the community is not in court. The character question asks whether this party may put the person's reputation before the jury at all. The limit on the prosecution protects against conviction for one offense because other offenses, or misconduct that is not a crime, are reputed to lie at the defendant's door.4 That danger does not turn on whether the community is right. An accurate bad reputation invites the same unfairness as an inaccurate one, and no hearsay exception can remove it.
An accused's proof of good reputation clears both hurdles at once.
One opinion states the asymmetry plainly: no one would open the doors initially to the prosecution, and no one would close them to the defense.5
The prosecution stands on the other side of that line. Suppose the government, in its case in chief (the stage at which it first presents its own evidence), calls a witness to report that the defendant is generally regarded in the community as a bad person. Rule 803(21) removes the hearsay objection, and the evidence is still excluded. The rule of evidence denies the prosecution the right to show, generally or by specific details, that a defendant bears a bad general estimate in the community.6 It is designed to restrain proof to the limits of the charge and to prevent conviction for one offense because perhaps others, or misconduct not amounting to crime, have been perpetrated or are reputed generally to lie at the defendant's door.7 Hearsay doctrine has no answer to that concern, and the exception was not written to supply one.
The party need not be a prosecutor for the exception to fall short.
The failure can also run the other way. An accused who may properly offer good reputation still loses the hearsay objection if the witness merely repeats what one neighbor once said. One speaker's remark is not a reputation among associates or in the community, so it falls outside the exception.8 In that case the character question was answered and the hearsay question was not. In the civil case the hearsay question was answered and the character question was not. A bar-style answer is complete only when it reports both results.