Concept
Reputation as Hearsay
Reputation concerning character
Character Reputation as Hearsay
Reputation as Hearsay
Rule 803(21) reaches "a reputation among a person's associates or in the community concerning the person's character."1 The rule is short because the problem it solves is narrow. Reputation testimony sounds ordinary, yet it collides with the hearsay rule whenever a party offers it to prove that the person really has the reputed trait.
A reputation witness does not report what the witness saw. A witness who says a neighbor is known around town as honest is describing what the community says about the neighbor, a generalized account of many out-of-court statements. The hearsay rule forbids evidence of out-of-court assertions offered to prove the facts asserted in them. A statement that is not an assertion, or is not offered to prove the facts asserted, is not hearsay.2 The first question for any reputation testimony, then, is what it is offered to prove.
Offered to prove that the neighbor is in fact honest, the testimony works only if the town is right. The people whose talk makes up the reputation are absent from the courtroom, and no one can test what they said. That is hearsay, and without an exception the court excludes it.3
Modern evidence law lets a party prove a pertinent character trait, either to show conduct in conformity with it or to impeach a witness, by reputation or by opinion. Proof by reputation raises the hearsay issue, and the law has traditionally resolved that issue with an exception that readily admits the evidence. Rule 803(21) carries the tradition forward, and it speaks only to the hearsay problem.4 Whether the trait may be proved at all is a separate question.
The same testimony needs no exception when the inference does not run through the community's accuracy. Where reputation is itself the fact to be proved, the testimony is not offered to prove the truth of what the community said, and the hearsay rule does not apply.5 A slander plaintiff, for example, must show injury to reputation as an element of damages. Testimony that the plaintiff's reputation in town was poor before the slander asks the jury what the community thought, not whether the community was right.
Reputation also escapes the hearsay problem when a party offers it to show what a person knew. A defendant who claims self-defense may offer the alleged victim's reputation for violence, but only if the defendant knew of that reputation before the litigated incident.6 The evidence explains the defendant's fear and does not ask the jury to find that the victim was violent. Knowledge does not work backward, so awareness gained during or after the event cannot have shaped what the defendant feared at the time.7 Change the purpose and the analysis changes with it. If a party offered the same reputation to show that the victim was violent, the testimony would depend on the community's accuracy, and the hearsay problem would return and call for Rule 803(21).