Concept
Reputation in a Community
Reputation concerning boundaries or general history
Reputation in a Community
Rule 803(20) starts with a group. It admits "[a] reputation in a community" about land boundaries and customs that affect the land, and, for general history, a reputation about events important to "that community, state, or nation."1 A reputation is what a group of people commonly believes and says about some matter. The exception admits that shared belief, so the witness reports what the community says, not what the witness privately thinks.
The word "community" screens out the single source. A witness who repeats one relative's remark has described one person's out-of-court statement. No community belief has been shown, so that statement needs a different hearsay exception or it stays out.
The farmer qualifies because her testimony shows where her knowledge comes from: she has been inside the community's talk. A proponent should establish that kind of connection, so that the judge can tell a reputation from a private opinion presented as consensus. A witness who says "I have always thought the line ran along the creek" offers a personal belief. A witness who says "everyone here says so" but cannot show any contact with that talk offers a bare conclusion.
The relevant community also changes with the subject, and the rule's wording shows how. For boundaries "of land in the community" and customs that affect the land, the group is the people of the locality where the land lies.2 For general historical events, the rule reaches a reputation in "that community, state, or nation," so the group can be as wide as the event's importance. The test is the same at both ends of the scale. The belief must be held by a community, not by the parties and a few friends.
Rule 803(21) uses the same device for a different subject. It admits reputation among associates or in the community when offered to establish character.3 Both exceptions treat a group's belief as the thing to be proved, and in each the witness must be able to speak for the group.