Concept
Reputation as Hearsay
Reputation concerning personal or family history
Reputation About Family History
Reputation as Hearsay
Family history is hard to prove by ordinary means. Questions about who was born to whom, who married whom, and who is related to whom often surface decades after the events, when the people with firsthand knowledge have died and the paper records are missing or incomplete. Litigants in that position fall back on what the family and the community said over the years, and Rule 803(19) admits that kind of proof: a reputation among a person's family, associates, or community concerning birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, death, relationship, or similar facts of personal or family history.1 Why reputation needs an exception at all depends on what a reputation is, and that begins with how it reaches the courtroom.
A reputation witness reports no single conversation. The witness summarizes what many people have said and are saying. One person says a child belongs to a particular family, another repeats it, the talk hardens into the settled belief of the family or the town, and a witness finally relays that belief to the jury. Every link in the chain is a statement made outside the courtroom, so reputation offered to prove the reputed fact is hearsay that relays other hearsay.
Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of what it asserts. The rule excludes it because the speaker was not under oath and cannot be cross-examined. Reputation magnifies that danger because its speakers are anonymous: the witness cannot say who first made the claim, how that person knew, or whether that person had reason to shade the truth. The testimony is worth only as much as the honesty and knowledge of speakers no one can identify or question.
The first question on any reputation problem is therefore what the reputation is offered to prove. Sometimes the reputation is itself the fact in issue. In a defamation suit, for example, the plaintiff's standing in the community is what the damages inquiry measures, and testimony about it asks no one to believe what the community said. Nothing is offered for its truth, so the hearsay rule never comes into play. The same is true when reputation is offered only to show that someone had notice of the reputed facts, because the testimony then proves only that the talk circulated.
In both nonhearsay uses the reputation is the fact to be proved. In the marriage example the reputation stands in for a different fact, the marriage itself, and that substitution creates the hearsay problem.
The law has long accepted reputation despite that problem. In the late 1600s, when the general doctrine excluding hearsay began to take form, jurors were already using reputation, directly or through witnesses, so firmly in certain areas that exceptions for reputation in those areas were soon recognized.2 Rule 803(19) carries that principle into the Federal Rules for facts of personal and family history.
An exception does not make reputation reliable by oath or cross-examination; it relies on a different assurance. The matter must be one of general interest, so that there is a high probability it underwent general scrutiny as the community reputation formed.3 When the navigability of a river was at issue, for example, newspaper accounts and histories describing its use in the nineteenth century were admissible to prove its reputation for navigability at that time.4 The subjects Rule 803(19) lists fit that rationale, since births, marriages, and deaths are the kind of matters families and neighborhoods discuss at length. The idea is not confined to family history either: statute or local law sometimes admits reputation to prove matters such as ownership of property or financial standing.5 Within the Federal Rules, Rule 803(19) is one of several exceptions in Rule 803 that allow reputation evidence.6
Reputation draws its reliability from general scrutiny, not from a record. Other routes to family-history proof, covered below, draw on different assurances. When a court is asked to credit findings, for instance, it weighs such factors as whether safeguards were applied and observed, whether there is a record on which the findings are based, and whether the findings express policy judgment rather than factual adjudication.7