Concept
Elements of the Exception
Market reports and similar commercial publications
Elements of the Exception
Rule 803(17) is a single sentence, and a proponent who offers a price table or a directory entry must fit the item inside it. The rule reaches “[m]arket quotations, lists, directories, or other compilations that are generally relied on by the public or by persons in particular occupations.”1 That sentence puts three questions to any document offered under it. Is the item the kind of thing the rule names? Is it a published, written compilation of relatively objective facts? Does the public, or a particular occupation, generally rely on it? An opponent can contest each question separately, so the proponent needs an answer to all three.
The three questions are not equally visible in the rule's wording. The first comes straight from the list of nouns: a quotation, list, or directory either falls within the named categories or resembles them. The second is drawn from what the named examples share. Each is prepared for use by others, and each reports facts, such as a closing price or a street address, that anyone can check against the world. The third is the only condition the rule states outright, and it looks past the document to the people who use it. Together, the first two questions describe a compilation that a disinterested source produces and circulates; the third asks whether an audience depends on it. A disinterested source and public reliance together justify the exception,2 because they supply market discipline in place of cross-examination.
Because the questions screen different features, one document can pass one and fail another, and the hard cases are the ones where that happens. A stock table clears all three. A printed, circulated table that reports opinion strains the second question; a table of plain facts that no one in particular reads strains the third. The sections below take the questions in turn, beginning with the kinds of item the rule names.
Compilations Covered
The first question asks whether the offered item is the kind of thing the rule names, and the rule answers in its own words: “[m]arket quotations, lists, directories, or other compilations.”3 A quotation reports a price at a given moment, a list sets out items in an organized series, and a directory matches names to addresses or telephone numbers. The closing phrase, other compilations, extends the category to similar gatherings of information. Courts and commentators fill these labels with a recognizable set of examples: stock and commodity quotations in a newspaper, price lists in a catalogue, weather reports, city and telephone directories, and the mortality tables that insurers use to price coverage.4 Each is something a person consults to learn a fact, and that reference function runs through every example.
The reference function explains why the law trusts these items without an oath. A catalogue prints its prices for any customer who opens it, a directory lists residents for anyone who needs to find one, and a mortality table serves the whole industry that prices policies from it. Compilers who write for an anonymous audience have no stake in any lawsuit and no reason to shade a figure.5 The audience adds a second safeguard. People who consult a work every day notice a wrong figure, and a publisher who wants to keep its readers must keep the figures right.6
The list is not confined to newspapers and telephone books. Census statistics, commodity market reports, and price and inflation indexes also qualify, and the publisher may be a government agency or a private business, since the exception looks to what the work does and not to who produced it.7 Specialty periodicals aimed at a single trade fall within the phrase “other compilations” as well. McMillen Feeds v. Harlow, which involved growth statistics for turkeys published in the trade periodical Turkey World, is the usual illustration of how far the category extends.8 A party offering those statistics to show typical growth rates relies on a publication written for turkey growers as a group. Its readers would be the first to notice a bad number, and they have no stake in the dispute at hand. A life insurer's mortality table, offered to prove life expectancy at a given age, qualifies for the same reason: the industry prices policies from it, and nobody compiled it for the lawsuit.
The spreadsheet might hold the same numbers as a published used-equipment guide, yet the guide would qualify and the spreadsheet would not. The usual exam error is to match the word “compilation” to any collection of data. The named examples control how that word is read. What they share is a reference work prepared for general use, and physical format does not matter, as the section on electronic compilations shows. A printed catalogue, a trade periodical, and a commercial website can all qualify; a litigant's private tabulation cannot. The next two questions sharpen the point, one by asking what such a compilation reports, the other by asking who relies on it.
Published Objective Content
Rule 803(17) describes its subject as “[m]arket quotations, lists, directories, or other compilations that are generally relied on by the public or by persons in particular occupations.”10 The sentence uses neither the word published nor the word objective. Those characteristics come from how the exception is described and from what its named examples share, so they are best understood as features common to the stock table, the price list, the directory, and the actuarial table, not as statutory language. The usual description is that the compilation is published in written form, circulated for use by others, and concerned with relatively straightforward objective facts.11 Each feature does separate work, and the reason for each follows from what the exception offers in place of cross-examination.
Publication and circulation put the compilation in front of many readers instead of one. A figure that sits in a single office is checked by no one, while a figure printed for a general audience is exposed to every reader who knows the facts it reports, such as the customer who pays a catalogue price or the resident whose address appears in a directory. The publisher has reason to care about that exposure, since the audience's continued trust is what the publication sells. The source may be a public agency or a private business; either way it usually has an incentive to be accurate, and people who rely on the data are likely to detect falsity.12
Objective content matters for a related but distinct reason. Readers can catch an error only when they can compare the printed entry with something observable. A closing price is what the exchange recorded, an address is where a person lives, and a temperature is what the instrument showed. When a compilation reports prices, names, addresses, weather, or actuarial figures, that comparison is available, so a wrong entry draws complaints and the publisher feels the cost. A valuation, a forecast, or a subjective rating offers no such anchor. Readers may lean on it heavily without that reliance telling anyone whether it is right. A prediction that wheat prices will double can be tested only after the fact, and even then a bad forecast looks like an error of judgment rather than a misprint. Material of that kind is harder to bring within the exception, and the word relatively in the usual description marks a matter of degree, which the later section on close cases takes up.
An exam question on this point usually holds the publication and the audience constant and varies only the content, so the analysis has to look past the format of the document to what it asserts.
The two items share a publisher, a format, and an audience, which isolates content as the variable that decided the result. The excavator spreadsheet in the previous section fails from the opposite direction. Its figures are factual, but it was never published or circulated, so no readership exists to check it. A document must satisfy both features, and an opponent can defeat the exception by showing that either one is missing.
Written material for this purpose includes electronic material, because Rule 101(b)(6) provides that a reference to written material includes material in electronic form.13 A commodity price table on a commercial website therefore stands in the same position as a printed one, and the section on electronic compilations works through the details of applying the exception online.
General Reliance
The condition the rule states outright is general reliance: the compilation must be “generally relied on by the public or by persons in particular occupations.”15 The earlier questions ask whether a document looks like a reference tool. This one asks whether people actually use it as one, and the reason is the reason the exception exists. When people stake real decisions on a compilation by buying, lending, insuring, or planning, an inaccurate entry costs someone money. The person who loses has reason to complain and, if the errors continue, to stop using the publication. A compiler who depends on that audience therefore has strong reason to get the figures right, and falsity is likely to be detected by those who rely on the data.16 Public use discourages errors,17 but a document that no one relies on generates none of that pressure, however tidy it looks, and nothing replaces the cross-examination the absent compiler will never face. Reliance is therefore a working condition of the exception, not a formality.
The rule recognizes two audiences, joined by the word or. The first is the public at large, which consults newspaper stock quotations and city and telephone directories in everyday dealings.18 The second is persons in a particular occupation, who rely on specialized compilations the general public never opens, such as growth statistics in a turkey-raising periodical, the mortality tables insurers use to price coverage, or a trade periodical's report of commodity prices.19 An occupational audience counts for the same reason the public one does. A specialist readership is smaller, but it consists of the people best placed to notice a wrong figure and most hurt by it, so a trade publication can be disciplined by its readers just as a newspaper is disciplined by the public. And because the two audiences are alternatives, a proponent offering turkey growth figures need not show that the general public cares about turkeys. Showing that people in the turkey business do is enough.
McMillen Feeds v. Harlow involved growth statistics for turkeys published in Turkey World, and it is cited as an illustration of the specialty periodicals the exception can reach.20 A proponent offering such statistics would show who consults the periodical and for what, pointing to the growers and feed dealers who routinely rely on the published figures. Those facts make the periodical a compilation relied on by persons in a particular occupation, and the proponent must place them before the court.
The proponent invokes the exception, so the proponent must supply the facts that bring the compilation within it, and reliance is one of those facts. In practice that means evidence about who uses the compilation and for what. A witness from the trade, such as a grower or a dealer, can describe how people in the business consult the periodical for the figures at issue, and that witness need not be the compiler, because the condition looks to the audience that uses the work and not to the people who produced it. For a newspaper's stock table or a telephone book, the use is so familiar that a brief showing may suffice. The rule's text prescribes no particular form of proof; it requires that the record actually describe the reliance.
Both the newsletter and the turkey statistics are printed and report figures, so the audience is what separates them. The turkey statistics come with an identifiable body of users who consult them, while the newsletter comes with a subscriber list and nothing more. The deficiency an exam answer should name is the missing proof of reliance. A proponent who produced a trade witness describing how people in the business use the newsletter would be addressing the exact condition the rule imposes.
A related instinct deserves resistance: treating one litigant's use of a list as enough. The rule speaks of reliance by the public or by persons in particular occupations, and the pressure for accuracy comes from a readership, so a single party's private use of a compilation shows nothing about whether a readership exists.