Concept
The Market Report Exception
Market reports and similar commercial publications
Market Reports and Commercial Publications
The Market Report Exception
A closing price printed in a newspaper was written by someone who will never testify. A party who offers that price to prove what a share was worth asks the factfinder to accept the writer's assertion, and an out-of-court statement offered for its truth is hearsay. The opponent can object that the publisher was never sworn and can never be cross-examined. Federal Rule of Evidence 803(17) answers that objection for one family of documents: "Market quotations, lists, directories, or other compilations that are generally relied on by the public or by persons in particular occupations."1 The rule belongs with the exceptions that apply regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness, so the proponent need not find the compiler or explain the compiler's absence.2
The text has three working parts, and the sections that follow take each in turn. The first is the kind of item offered: a quotation, list, directory, or similar compilation. The second is reliance. The compilation must be generally relied on, which looks to how it is used in the world and not to how it was made. The third is who does the relying, which may be the public at large or persons in a particular occupation, such as investors who read stock prices. A compilation that meets all three comes in for the truth of what it reports, and no one who gathered the figures has to testify.
Reliance is the part a proponent should be ready to prove. One secondary source states that the publication's reliability must be established, in the sense that professionals in the field view it as trustworthy, and that either party's expert, or judicial notice, can establish its authoritativeness.3
Hearsay is distrusted because the declarant is unsworn and cannot be cross-examined, so an exception has to put something equally protective in the declarant's place. For published compilations the substitute is structural. The source is usually disinterested: these compilations are made by people with no motive to lie.4 That same source usually has an incentive to be accurate, and falsity is likely to be detected by the people who rely on the data.5 Because the public uses the publication, errors are likely to be discouraged as well.6 Together, a disinterested source and public reliance justify the exception.7
That structure explains why the text says nothing about what the compiler personally knows. A newspaper's staff did not watch every trade on the exchange floor, and the rule does not require that anyone did. Nor does the text ask the questions courts put when they weigh the trustworthiness of findings, such as the extent to which a record supports them, whether they express policy judgment rather than factual adjudication, whether they rest on other bodies' findings that may be suspect, and, where they rest on expert opinion, whether the underlying facts or data are reasonably relied on by experts in the field.8 Rule 803(17) asks only about the kind of compilation and who relies on it.
Take a newspaper page of stock prices first.
The same reasoning reaches a directory. If residents and businesses generally consult a city directory to find addresses, the rule's text covers it, and a litigant may offer it for the facts it lists.9
A written price is not covered merely because it is objective and easy to check. The exception attaches to a publication with a disinterested source and an audience that relies on it.
Both scenes report the identical number, so the number cannot explain the different results. Every reason for trusting the printed quotation belongs to the publication, and none of them belongs to the slip.