Concept
Related Property Exceptions
Records of documents that affect an interest in property
Related Property Exceptions
Rule 803(14) answers one narrow question: what did a recorded property instrument say, and was it signed and delivered? It admits the record of a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property, but only when the record is offered to prove the original's content, signing, and delivery, the record is kept in a public office, and a statute authorizes recording documents of that kind in that office.1 Other questions gather around the same piece of paper. Can a statement written inside a deed be believed? Does an old document earn trust from its age? Can a government agency's file or a company's ledger come in? The Rules answer each through a separate exception with its own conditions.
A single land dispute can involve a recorded deed, a letter found in an attic, a county assessor's file, and a lender's payment ledger. A student who sees the words document and land in an exam stem may reach for Rule 803(14) at once, even when the offered item has nothing to do with a recording system. The neighboring exceptions rest on different sources of reliability: one reaches statements written inside a property document, one rests on age, and two cover the records of public offices and of businesses. Satisfying Rule 803(14) does nothing toward satisfying any of them, and the reverse is equally true.
The sorting question is the one that drove the conditions above: what is the proponent trying to prove with this paper, and where does the paper come from? If the answer is what a recorded instrument said and that it was signed and delivered, and the copy sits in a recording office, test Rule 803(14). If the answer is the truth of something written inside the document, the document's age, or the ordinary operations of an office or business, the analysis moves to a neighbor. The first neighbor picks up exactly where Rule 803(14) stops.
Statements Inside Documents
Rule 803(15) covers the layer that Rule 803(14) leaves alone. It admits a statement contained in a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property, if the matter stated was relevant to the document's purpose, unless later dealings with the property are inconsistent with the truth of the statement or the purport of the document.2 A deed typically recites facts beside its operative words: it names the grantor, says how the grantor came to hold the land, and identifies the parcel. This exception lets a litigant prove information of that kind, such as descriptions of the grantors, for its truth.3 Like every exception in Rule 803, it applies whether or not the person who made the statement is available to testify.4
A recorded deed offered to prove that a recital inside it is true contains two separate out-of-court assertions. The recorder's copy asserts that the original said what the copy shows, and Rule 803(14) handles that assertion, but by its terms it reaches only the original's content, signing, and delivery.5 The recital is the signer's own assertion, such as how the grantor came to own the land. Proving that a deed contains a sentence does not prove the sentence true, so the recital needs a basis of its own, and Rule 803(15) supplies one when its two requirements are met.
The first requirement is that the matter stated be relevant to the document's purpose. People who sign a deed are fixing their rights in property, and both sides have reason to get the basic facts right, because a mistake about who is conveying, or how that person came to hold the land, would threaten the title the deed exists to transfer. A recital about the grantor's identity or heirship therefore bears on whether the deed can do its job. A passing remark with no bearing on the conveyance, such as a comment about a neighbor's conduct, carries no comparable assurance, because nobody's rights turned on whether it was correct.
The second requirement checks the first. A recital earns trust because the parties relied on it when they fixed their rights, and that trust lasts only while their later conduct continues to fit it. If people afterward deal with the property in a way that cannot be squared with the recital, the support that made it credible is gone. The rule names two things later dealings can contradict: the truth of the statement and the purport of the document, meaning what the document on its face claims to accomplish.6 The rule limits admission, so a relevant statement comes in unless later dealings contradict it.
Later conduct that contradicts the recital produces the opposite result.
The two exceptions work in sequence on a layered offer, and a proponent can run the sequence as a short checklist.
An exam stem that stresses the word recorded invites the first shortcut: treating the recorded copy as proof of everything written in the deed, which skips the second layer entirely. The opposite shortcut admits any relevant recital without looking for later conduct that contradicts it. A document may also have a further route that rests on age instead of the property setting. Rule 803(16) covers statements in documents prepared before January 1, 1998, and the next subsection takes it up.7
Ancient Documents
Rule 803(16) draws on a different source of reliability from the property exceptions. It admits a statement in a document that was prepared before January 1, 1998, and whose authenticity is established.9 The rule has two conditions: a date, which the face of the document usually reveals, and authenticity, which the proponent must establish. When both are met, the statement comes in for the truth of what it asserts, and, as with every exception in Rule 803, the hearsay rule does not require that the person who made the statement be available to testify.10
Age can stand in for cross-examination because of the circumstances in which old documents were written. A letter, map, or deed from decades ago was produced for the purposes of its own day, and its author could not have known that a boundary quarrel in the present would make its contents valuable. The same passage of time removes the alternatives, because the author and anyone who watched the events are usually gone and the paper is often the only evidence left. A fixed cutoff date gives litigants a line they can check from the document itself.
Age lends reliability only to a document that is what it appears to be, which is why authenticity is written into the exception itself. A forged or misdated paper carries none of the assurance that distant origin supplies. The secondary explanation of the rule describes the qualifying document as one prepared in 1997 or earlier and found in a place where it would likely have been kept, such as among a family's papers.11
Age is the entire basis of Rule 803(16), and recording plays no part in it. A deed or letter that was never filed with any office can qualify so long as it predates 1998 and is shown to be authentic. Rule 803(14) is the mirror image: it depends on the public recording system, with its public office and its authorizing statute, and the age of the document is irrelevant to it.12 The two exceptions also reach different things. Rule 803(14) proves what a recorded property document said and that it was signed and delivered, while Rule 803(16) admits a statement inside a document for its truth and is not confined to property documents.
Do not read this exception as a test of how many years old a document is. Its text sets a fixed date, and that text controls.13 A document prepared on or after January 1, 1998 never qualifies, however many decades pass, while a document prepared in 1997 qualifies today and will keep qualifying. An exam stem that calls a document more than twenty years old invites the shortcut of treating it as ancient, but the only question is whether it was prepared before 1998. The stem that dwells on recording sets the mirror-image trap, because recording supports Rule 803(14) and contributes nothing to Rule 803(16).
Public and Business Records
When a government office holds a copy of a document, the general public-records exception, Rule 803(8), is the natural candidate to test first. It admits a record or statement of a public office if it sets out the office's activities; a matter observed while under a legal duty to report, though not, in a criminal case, a matter observed by law-enforcement personnel; or, in a civil case or against the government in a criminal case, factual findings from a legally authorized investigation. The opponent can still keep the record out by showing that the source of information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness.15
The exception exists because requiring public officials to appear and testify about their records would disrupt public business and would almost certainly create a class of official witnesses. Given the volume of work in a public office, the official's written statement will usually be more reliable than the official's memory, and for the same reasons the declarant's unavailability need not be shown.16 Each category in the rule ties to the office's own conduct or its own authorized inquiry, so the rule's coverage gives out at the edge of what the office itself did or saw.
A recorder's office sits at that edge. When a deed arrives, the office receives it, notes when it came in, and places a copy in the public file, and those steps are the office's own activities. Nothing about receiving and filing puts the staff in a position to see who signed the deed or whether it was delivered. A recorder's file offered to prove signing and delivery therefore sets out nothing the office did or observed on those points, and Rule 803(8) does not carry them. Rule 803(14) fills the gap. It authorizes the record to prove the original's content, its signing, and its delivery by each person who purports to have signed it, but only when the record is kept in a public office and a statute authorizes recording documents of that kind there.17
An exam stem that offers one recorder's file for two different points shows how the two exceptions divide the work.
The same file serves both offers, and the proposition being proved selects the exception. Rule 803(14)'s conditions are what allow the record to reach beyond what the office itself saw, so a proponent cannot skip them by pointing to the office's general duty to keep records.
The two exceptions also differ in what the opponent may do. Rule 803(8) ends with a trustworthiness clause, so even a record that sets out an office's activity or findings stays out if the opponent shows that the source of the information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness.18 Such a screen suits an exception that reaches records of many kinds, including findings built on information from outside sources. Rule 803(14) lists its three conditions and contains no comparable clause.19
Rule 803(6) is a different route again, and it serves private holders. It reaches a record of an act, event, condition, opinion, or diagnosis, and the proponent must satisfy its conditions on their own.20 A lender or title company that keeps its own copy of a recorded mortgage holds a record that is not kept in a public office, so Rule 803(14)(B) offers it nothing.21 The division follows custody: a record held by a government recorder can qualify under Rule 803(14) without any showing about a private routine, while a copy in private files must come in, if at all, under Rule 803(6).
An exam stem that stresses a government office tempts a student to answer under Rule 803(8) for every purpose. Ask first what the record is offered to prove. The office's own activity points to Rule 803(8), the original's content, signing, and delivery point to Rule 803(14), and a private organization's own file points to Rule 803(6).