Concept
Conditions for Admission
Records of documents that affect an interest in property
Conditions for Admission
Rule 803(14) does not admit every recorded paper that touches land. It admits the record of a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property only if three further conditions are met.1 The record must be offered to prove the content of the original document, along with its signing and delivery; the record must be kept in a public office; and a statute must authorize recording documents of that kind in that office.2 The rule joins the three with "and," which makes them cumulative: a record that satisfies two of them remains open to the hearsay objection.
The conditions guard three different gaps in the record's reliability. The first confines the record to proving the document itself, not the land or the transaction behind it. The second places the copy with a government custodian instead of a private holder. The third requires that local law have set up a recording system covering this kind of document in this office, so that the filing is a legally recognized act and not an accident of custody.3 A proponent tests the conditions in the order the rule lists them, and a failure at any step ends the case for admission under this exception, however strong the others are. The first condition fixes what the record may be used to prove.
Content, Signing, and Delivery
Rule 803(14)(A) limits what a recorded copy may be used to prove: the content of the original recorded document, along with its signing and its delivery by each person who purports to have signed it.4 Each of the three is a fact about the instrument, not about the land. Content means the words of the document: the parties it names, the parcel it describes, the interest it creates, and the terms attached to that interest. Signing means that the named signers put their signatures on the original. Delivery means that they handed the instrument over as a completed act. A litigant whose original has been lost can therefore use the recorded copy to show the detailed information the original contained.5 Nothing in the condition asks whether anyone involved is available to testify, because every Rule 803 exception applies regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness.6
The first two items follow from how a recording system works. The office keeps a copy of what was filed, so the copy reproduces the words and the signatures the original carried. Delivery needs a separate explanation, because a signature does not finish a conveyance. A deed that was written and signed but never handed over generally transfers nothing, since the transfer depends on the grantor's act of placing the instrument in the grantee's hands. A proponent who could show only that a deed was drafted and signed would not have shown that it operated as a deed. Listing delivery lets the record carry proof of the last act that turns a drafted paper into a working instrument.
The rule's wording also controls how far the proof reaches. It speaks of each person who "purports to have signed" the document, which ties the proof to the face of the instrument.7 The record shows the document as it presents itself, signed and delivered by the people it names. Admission puts that showing before the factfinder and leaves the opponent free to offer contrary evidence about the transaction.
The list also marks what the record does not prove. A recorded deed shows that a document said certain things and was executed and delivered. It does not show that the grantor owned the land on the day of signing or that the conveyance was valid. Those are questions about the land and the law of property, and the exception's list of three stops short of them. Reading the list to reach ownership or validity would credit the recording system with a verification the rule never describes.
The same limit applies to sentences written inside the document.
Proving what a document says and proving that what it says is true are different tasks. Rule 803(15) separately governs a statement contained in a document that affects an interest in property, when the matter stated was relevant to the document's purpose and later dealings with the property are not inconsistent with it.8 That exception has its own conditions and is taken up under Related Property Exceptions. The point here is only that Rule 803(14) does not reach recitals on its own.
Kept in a Public Office
Rule 803(14)(B) supplies the second condition: the record of the property document must be kept in a public office.10 A county recorder or register of deeds is the standard example, because that office exists to receive and hold a community's land documents. The condition looks to custody. A record held by a government custodian meets it, while a copy held by a private business or an individual does not, however accurate that copy may be.
The reasoning behind the general public-records exception explains why custody carries so much weight. Official written statements are trustworthy because the official has a duty to make an accurate report and the duty is very probably performed.11 A recording office works under that kind of duty. A private holder, such as a lender or a title company, keeps files for its own purposes and carries no comparable official obligation.
The rule asks only where the record is kept, so it does not require proof that anyone may browse the office's files. Public inspection may add a modest assurance of accuracy, since people who rely on the records can notice and correct errors. Courts applying the neighboring public-records exception treat it as a supporting reason and not as a prerequisite, because a strict inspection requirement would exclude many reliable documents.12
Private custody calls for a different foundation. The business-records exception covers a record kept in the course of a regularly conducted activity of a business or organization. It requires a showing that the record was made at or near the time by someone with knowledge, that making it was a regular practice of the activity, and that these facts are established by a custodian's testimony or a qualifying certification; the opponent may still show a lack of trustworthiness.13 That route depends on the private organization's own routine, which the proponent must prove. Rule 803(14)(B) rests on the fact that the record sits in a government office, so the proponent need not prove a private routine when the custody condition is met.
The mortgage's content, signing, and delivery are the same in both offers, so the identity of the custodian moves the answer. An exam stem that stresses the word "recorded" invites the shortcut of treating any copy of a recorded document as covered. The word describes the document's history, while the condition looks to where the record being offered is kept. Even a record kept in a public office must still satisfy the last condition, which asks whether a statute authorizes recording documents of that kind in that office.
Statute Authorizing Recording
The third condition, in Rule 803(14)(C), asks whether a statute authorizes recording documents of that kind in that office.15 The sentence has two halves, and each does its own work. The statute must cover the kind of document offered, such as a deed, a mortgage, or an easement, and it must cover recording that kind of document in the particular office where the record is kept. The authorizing statute is ordinarily local, typically a state recording act, because the exception operates only where local statutes have set up a recording system that includes title documents of this sort.16
A statute is required because physical custody, standing alone, tells a court very little. A government office can end up holding a paper for many reasons: an owner may have left it at the counter, an agency may have asked for it in connection with an unrelated program, or a clerk may have filed it by mistake. None of those histories shows that the paper arrived through a process the law recognizes. A recording statute supplies the missing link. It identifies the documents the office is to receive and the office that is to receive them, so the file exists because the law called for it. The two halves of the condition track that logic: the kind-of-document half confirms that the system was meant to receive this type of instrument, and the office half confirms that the filing took place where the system operates.
The condition asks about authority to record, and two nearby questions are easy to substitute for it. The first is whether the office happened to accept the paper. A clerk's acceptance is a fact about what the office did, while the condition asks what the law authorized the office to do, so an office that took a paper it had no statutory power to record gains nothing from having taken it. The second is whether the document is valid. A deed with a defect in how it was executed can still be a document of a kind the recording act covers, and the condition looks only at the kind. Whether the deed actually conveyed anything is a question about the land and the law of property, which this exception never answers, as the earlier discussion of content, signing, and delivery showed.
The office half of the condition has its own trap. An exam stem that says the copy came from a government office has settled the public-office condition and nothing more, because a public office and an office the statute designates for recording are different things.
The assessor example shows why the public-office condition and the statutory condition cannot be folded into one. Rule 803(14) joins its conditions with the word "and," so they are cumulative: a record that satisfies the first two conditions still fails if no statute authorizes recording that kind of document in that office.17 A proponent in that position must look to a different exception or another way of proving the document, each of which carries its own foundation. The question for the court under this condition is whether a recording act exists and reaches both this document and this office.