Concept
What the Exception Does
Records of documents that affect an interest in property
Recorded Property Documents
What the Exception Does
Rule 803(14) lets a litigant prove what a property document said by offering the public record of it. The rule excepts from the hearsay bar the record of a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property, once its conditions are met.1 Deeds, mortgages, and easements are the typical examples, and a recording office keeps a copy of each in a public file.
The need arises years after the transaction. A party in a boundary or title dispute must show what the document said, that the named people signed it, and that they delivered it. The original may have burned, or it may sit in an adversary's files. The signers and the notary may be dead, out of reach, or unable to recall one routine closing from decades earlier.
Without an exception, that party is stuck. A recorded copy is an out-of-court assertion that the original said what the copy says, so offering it to prove that content draws a hearsay objection. Live witnesses to the transaction are often gone. Rule 803(14) clears the way: when the record is offered to prove the content of the original, along with its signing and delivery, and the rule's conditions are satisfied, the hearsay rule does not exclude it.2 The sections that follow take those conditions one at a time.
Like every exception in Rule 803, this one applies whether or not the declarant is available as a witness.3 The proponent therefore need not show that a signer or clerk has died or cannot be found, and a signer sitting in the courtroom changes nothing.
The official-records exception shows why the law accepts a written record in place of a live witness. Calling public officials to testify about their records would disrupt public business and create a class of official witnesses. Given the volume of work in a public office, the written entry will usually be more reliable than the official's memory. For the same reasons, the declarant need not be unavailable.4 The same logic fits a recorder's file. A recorder who handles a steady flow of instruments cannot be expected to recall one deed from decades ago, and the file holds the document itself.
The exception covers the record of the document, not everything the document says. A recital inside a deed, such as a statement about earlier ownership, raises a second hearsay question that Rule 803(15) answers separately. That rule admits a statement in a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property if the matter stated was relevant to the document's purpose, unless later dealings with the property are inconsistent with the truth of the statement or the purport of the document.5 A later section returns to it.
The exception speaks only to the rule against hearsay. If the opponent has another objection to the copy, such as doubt that it is what the proponent says it is, the exception does not answer it, and the proponent must meet that objection separately.