Concept
Distinguishing Party Admissions
Statements against interest
Distinguishing Party Admissions
Students often blend two rules that are both loosely called admissions against interest. Rule 804(b)(3) admits a statement against interest when the declarant is unavailable as a witness, and it does not require the declarant to be a party to the lawsuit.1 The rule on an opposing party's own statements works differently. An opposing party's statement, traditionally called an admission, is anything a party to the lawsuit has ever said, so long as it is relevant against that party at trial.2
Under the Federal Rules, such a statement is not hearsay when it is offered against the party and falls into one of five groups: the party's own statement; a statement the party has adopted or manifested a belief in; a statement by someone the party authorized to speak; a statement by the party's agent about a matter within the agency or employment, made while the relationship lasted; or a statement by a coconspirator during and in furtherance of the conspiracy.3 A statement in one of those groups needs no exception to get in. It comes in only because an opponent offers it, so a litigant cannot use this route to offer his own earlier words.4
The party rule also drops three conditions that the exception imposes. A party's admission need not have been against interest when made; it may have been self-serving at that moment. The party need not be unavailable, and seldom is. And the party need not have had personal knowledge of the fact admitted.5 The exception, by contrast, asks whether a reasonable person in the declarant's position would have made the statement only if believing it true, because when made it was so contrary to the declarant's proprietary or pecuniary interest, or so likely to invalidate the declarant's claim against someone else or to expose the declarant to civil or criminal liability.6 In return for those added conditions, the exception reaches nonparties, and it does not matter which side offers the statement.7
The comparison fits in one chart.8
| Point of comparison | Opposing party's statement | Statement against interest |
|---|---|---|
| Who spoke | The party, or someone whose words are attributed to the party (authorized speaker, agent, coconspirator) | Anyone, including a nonparty |
| Availability | Declarant may be available | Declarant must be unavailable |
| Against interest when made | Not required; the statement may have been self-serving | Required, judged when the statement was made |
| Personal knowledge | Not required | Required |
| Who offers, and against whom | An opponent, against the party | Either side, against any party |
Because the party rule has no interest requirement, there is no occasion to ask whether a party's statement was against interest. When an opponent offers a party's statement, test it by the rules for party admissions, not by the rules for declarations against interest.9 Running the exception's analysis on a party's words invites the error of demanding unavailability that the party rule never asks for. The first question on any fact pattern that puts a damaging statement in front of you is therefore who said it, and who is offering it against whom.
The exception does its work for people outside the lawsuit.
The exception also supplies one of the main alternative routes for damaging statements made by a party's predecessor, because the Federal Rules do not recognize admissions by persons in privity with a party.10
A statement made to a private confidant rather than to law enforcement carries added weight for penal-interest statements, and it generally avoids Confrontation Clause trouble. Later units develop both points.11