Concept
Related Exceptions
Learned treatises
Related Exceptions
Rule 803(18) is a demanding gate. A statement in a treatise, periodical, or pamphlet comes in only if an expert was confronted with it on cross-examination or relied on it on direct,1 and only if the publication is established as a reliable authority. Once admitted, the statement is read to the jury and never received as an exhibit.2 A lawyer holding a printed or compiled source that cannot pass that gate has two neighboring routes to consider, and each rests on a different assurance of trustworthiness.
The first route is Rule 803(17), which covers market quotations, lists, directories, and similar compilations. The second is the residual exception, now Rule 807, a fallback for trustworthy statements that no specific exception covers. Both involve published or compiled material, so students are tempted to treat either as a substitute for Rule 803(18) when its foundation fails. That temptation misleads. The treatise rule turns on an expert and a showing of reliable authority. The neighbors rely on other guarantees and carry their own conditions, so the sponsorship and reliability requirements taught above do not follow a document into them automatically.
Read each neighbor as a contrast with the treatise rule. The contrast shows which conditions belong to the kind of statement offered and which belong only to the treatise rule.
Market Reports and Directories
Rule 803(17) reaches "market quotations, lists, directories, or other compilations that are generally relied on by the public or by persons in particular occupations."3 Published stock prices, commodity prices, weather reports, and telephone directories are the standard examples.4 Each is a written statement made outside the courtroom. A party who offers a price table to prove what wheat cost on a given day, or a directory to prove that a number was listed under a name, therefore offers hearsay and needs an exception. Rule 803(17) supplies one, and like the treatise rule it yields substantive evidence: statements in these publications may be used for their truth.5
Two reasons support the exception, and neither is the treatise rule's reason. First, the people who compile prices and listings have no motive to lie about them.6 No outcome in a particular lawsuit gives a compiler a reason to shade an entry. Second, the public uses these compilations, and that use discourages errors.7 The compiler's motivation for accuracy is high because public acceptance depends on reliability.8 A table that proves wrong loses the readers it serves, and that discipline works without anyone vetting the particular entry offered in court.
Three characteristics mark the category, and each ties back to those reasons.9
- The compilation is published in written form and circulated for use by others.
- The general public, or persons in a particular occupation, rely on it.
- It pertains to relatively straightforward objective facts.
Circulation exposes every entry to readers who would notice a mistake. Reliance creates the accuracy incentive, because a compilation nobody uses has no users to punish an error. The third characteristic does the most to separate this rule from the treatise rule. A price or a listing is a fact that readers can check against their own dealings, and it needs no professional judgment to read.
That difference in subject matter explains the difference in procedure. The treatise rule requires a testifying expert who was confronted with the passage or relied on it, a showing that the work is a reliable authority, and a reading of the passage rather than receipt of the book as an exhibit.10 Those safeguards suit technical writing, but a closing price in a table needs no interpreter. The text of Rule 803(17) accordingly names no expert sponsor and no read-only limit.11 The proponent still carries one burden: to show that the compilation is the kind that the public or an occupation generally relies on. A tally assembled for the lawsuit, or a price list that no one in the trade uses, lacks that reliance, and the showing does the work for this rule that sponsorship and reliable-authority proof do for the other.
The usual error is to see the word "published" and reach for the wrong rule in one direction or the other. A student who sends every printed source through Rule 803(18) will demand an expert for a telephone directory. A student who calls a medical journal a "compilation generally relied on by physicians" is trying to skip the treatise rule's conditions, and the attempt fails because the compilation category covers straightforward objective fact, which a scientific claim is not.12 A single publication can hold both kinds of content, so ask what the offered entry actually says: a listing or price anyone can read, or a professional conclusion that needs interpretation.
Residual Exception
A safety code or similar compilation that fails, or is never offered, under Rule 803(18) may sometimes qualify under the residual exception. That catch-all began as Rule 803(24) and has since been transferred to Rule 807.14 Older decisions still cite the former number, so a case that mentions 803(24) is describing what an answer today should call Rule 807. The catch-all exists because no list of specific exceptions can anticipate every trustworthy source. A compilation prepared by professionals for use in their field may match no listed category, and a rule that admitted only listed categories would exclude a statement as dependable as the ones the list admits.
The exception as it read under the old number reached a statement not specifically covered by another exception but having "equivalent circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness." The court could admit it only after determining four things:15
- The statement is offered as evidence of a material fact.
- The statement is more probative on the point than any other evidence the proponent can procure through reasonable efforts.
- The general purposes of the rules and the interests of justice will best be served by admitting it.
- The proponent has told the adverse party, sufficiently in advance of trial, that the statement will be offered, and has given its particulars, including the name and address of the declarant.
The rule has been amended and renumbered since that wording was in force, so the current text of Rule 807 controls on precise phrasing.16 The conditions are easiest to hold as three ideas: trustworthiness, need, and fair notice. Trustworthiness takes the place of the assurance a specific exception would have supplied. The judge has no category to rely on and must find the reliability in the statement itself. Need comes from the comparison with other evidence. If the proponent could reasonably obtain better proof, the case for relaxing the hearsay rule is weak, and the exception would otherwise let a party avoid calling a witness who could simply be called. Notice protects the opponent, who faces a statement that fits no predictable category and so cannot know what to prepare against. Advance notice with the declarant's particulars gives the opponent a fair chance to investigate the source before trial.
Safety codes fit the first two ideas well. In Johnson v. William C. Ellis & Sons Iron Works, the Fifth Circuit indicated that safety codes may be admitted under the residual exception "because they are inherently trustworthy and because of the expense and difficulty involved in assembling at trial those who have compiled such codes."17 The first clause speaks to trustworthiness, since professionals write the code for use in their field. The second speaks to need, since the compilers are many and scattered, and calling them to the stand would cost a great deal for little gain.
A proponent has a practical reason to try this second door. A statement admitted under Rule 803(18) may be read into evidence but not received as an exhibit, so the book stays out of the jury room.18 The old residual text quoted above contains no matching limit and no expert-sponsorship condition.19 That difference invites the argument the plaintiff Alexander made on appeal: the trial court's failure to admit a safety code as an exhibit was reversible error. The appellate court accepted that safety codes have traditionally been treated under Rule 803(18) but may also come in under the residual exception, then Rule 803(24). It found the notice condition satisfied, because the Code was listed as an exhibit in the pretrial order. Johnson had come out the other way because the proponent there failed to comply with the prior-notice requirement.20
The court still refused to reverse, and it gave two reasons. Alexander had not urged admission under Rule 803(24) at trial. And no substantial right of hers was affected, because the relevant sections of the Code had already been read and shown to the jury.21 The first reason follows from the structure of the rule. The exception applies only if the court determines that its conditions are met, and a judge never asked to invoke it has made no finding that the code is more probative than other evidence or that the interests of justice favor admission. A ground raised for the first time on appeal gives the trial court no chance to make those findings and gives the opponent no chance to resist them. The second reason is practical: the jury had already received the content of the Code, so the missing exhibit changed nothing the jurors knew.
The sequence for an exam answer follows from these cases. Analyze a treatise, periodical, pamphlet, or code first under Rule 803(18), and raise the residual exception in the alternative, with its own conditions. The residual exception does not excuse the foundation Rule 803(18) demands. A proponent who invokes Rule 803(18) still needs a sponsoring expert and a showing of reliability, and a proponent who invokes the residual exception needs trustworthiness, need, and notice. A stem fact about a pretrial-order listing speaks to notice, and a stem fact about what counsel argued at trial speaks to preservation. Neither fact alone makes the statement admissible.