Concept
Vital Statistics and Absent Records
Public records and reports
Vital Statistics and Absent Records
Two exceptions close out the public-records family, and they run in opposite directions. Rule 803(9) admits what a record of a birth, death, or marriage says. Rule 803(10) admits what an empty file says: that a diligent search found no record and, sometimes, that the matter never happened.
Both build on Rule 803(8), which admits "a record or statement of a public office" that meets its conditions.1 Clause (A)(ii) of that rule reaches a matter observed while under a legal duty to report.2 The people who report births, deaths, and marriages, however, are physicians, ministers, coroners, undertakers, and the like, and many of them are not public officers.3 Rule 803(9) closes that gap by locating the legal duty in the act of reporting. Rule 803(10) pairs with Rule 803(8) as Rule 803(7) pairs with Rule 803(6). Rule 803(6) admits a record "kept in the course of a regularly conducted activity of a business, organization, occupation, or calling,"4 and Rule 803(7) admits the lack of an entry where one would normally be made. In both pairs the inference is the same: an office or business that routinely records events of a kind will have recorded this one, so a search that finds nothing is evidence that the event did not occur.
Vital Statistics Records
Rule 803(9) admits "a record of a birth, death, or marriage, if reported to a public office in accordance with a legal duty."5 Its subject is what the profession calls vital statistics: public records of births, marriages, deaths, and similar matters that a statute requires a city, state, or other government unit to keep.6
The legal-duty language solves a problem that the ordinary public-records tradition creates. That tradition looks for an official duty on the part of the person who made the report. Enforced strictly, it would keep out a minister's return on a marriage license showing that the ceremony took place, and an attending physician's report of the fact and date of a birth or death.7 Courts therefore relaxed the requirement for general statistics. Where a minister, physician, or similar reporter had a professional duty to report, though not necessarily an official one, courts generally admitted the record to prove the truth of the reporter's statement. An alternative approach treats the reporter as an official for purposes of making the report.8 Rule 803(9) writes the relaxed approach into its text. Many of the people the law requires to file these reports are not public officers, but when they file the reports the rule names, they perform a publicly imposed duty.9
Applying the rule takes two questions in order. Did law require this person to report this event? Did the person report it to a public office? Local law largely supplies the answer to the first, defining who must report and what the report must contain. It does not supply the answer on trustworthiness, which the federal rule governs.10 A physician who files a birth record with the state health department, as the law requires, satisfies both questions even though the physician is no public official. The record comes in to prove the fact and date of the birth.11 The foundation is lighter than for business records, because no custodian need testify. The proponent offers a certified copy under Rule 902(4).12
Other exceptions may reach other sources of family history. Rule 803(11), for example, covers statements of birth, marriage, death, and similar facts of personal or family history in a regularly kept record of a religious organization, and it has conditions of its own.13 The duty requirement also has a limit. A report that the law merely requires does not become a public report for that reason alone. A motorist who completes a mandatory accident report can scarcely be regarded as acting in a temporary official capacity or under a professional duty.14
One kind of entry needs more care: what a death certificate says about why the person died. Routine entries, such as the place and date of death and the immediate cause (drowning or a gunshot wound, for example), are seldom questioned.15 Entries on the remote cause, such as suicide, accident, or homicide, usually rest on information obtained from other persons. They raise the questions that investigative reports generally raise, and courts have divided on admitting them.16 Such an entry is also hearsay within hearsay. The certifier's report is one layer and what others told the certifier is another, and Rule 805 admits the combination only if each part conforms with an exception.17 The certifier's legal duty can account for the first layer. It says nothing about the second.
For conclusions of this kind, the sounder course applies Rule 803(8), which handles the issues more carefully. That means applying the restrictions on police and investigative reports offered against an accused in clauses (A)(ii) and (A)(iii), together with tests such as the preparer's expertise and motivation and the sources of information used.18 Clause (A)(iii) admits factual findings from a legally authorized investigation only "in a civil case or against the government in a criminal case."19
A certificate can therefore split. The filing duty carries the routine facts of a birth, death, or marriage, and the stricter public-records analysis governs the contested conclusions about cause.
Absence of a Public Record
Rule 803(10) admits testimony, or a certification under Rule 902, that a diligent search failed to disclose a public record or statement.22 The proponent offers it to prove one of two things: that the record or statement does not exist, or that a matter did not occur or exist. The second purpose is available only if a public office regularly kept a record or statement for a matter of that kind.23
The exception is needed because an empty file speaks only by implication. A register of the permits an agency issued asserts, by what it leaves out, that no other permit was issued, and the searcher's report that the register is silent is itself an out-of-court statement. Rule 803(7) is the mirror image of the business-records exception, allowing evidence that information is lacking in a place where it would normally be recorded. One could argue that such an omission is not hearsay at all, but the exception moots that controversy.24 Rule 803(10) carries the same device into public records. The certification option adds a practical benefit: the searcher need not come to court to say that a search came up empty.
The two purposes demand different things of the office, and the difference tracks the strength of the inference. An empty search proves that a record does not exist, which suits a case where the filing's existence is itself the disputed fact, and it requires nothing about the office's habits. Using the same search to prove that an event never happened adds a step, because silence means something only if the office would have recorded the event. The requirement that a public office regularly kept a record of matters of that kind supplies the missing premise.25 The word "diligent" guards the earlier step, since an empty result says nothing if the searcher looked in the wrong office or under the wrong name.26
A certification is a written statement that the court receives without calling the person who signed it. An affidavit certified in accordance with Rule 902(1), (2), or (3) is admissible to prove that a record or statement is absent, or that a matter did not occur or exist when a public office regularly made and preserved a record of it. Rule 902(4) comes into play only when a copy of the public record is itself annexed to the affidavit.27 The contrast with vital statistics follows from the subject: a certified copy proves a record that exists, and an affidavit proves one that does not. Live testimony remains available to a proponent who prefers it, because the rule admits testimony and certification alike.28
Criminal prosecutions made the certification route contentious. Prosecutors rely on proof of absence when they must show, for example, that a defendant lacked official permission to reenter the country. The Supreme Court's Confrontation Clause decisions on forensic reports began with Melendez-Diaz v. Massachusetts, 557 U.S. 305 (2009), and continued in Bullcoming (2011) and Williams (2012).29 Some courts concluded that a certificate of a missing record, offered against the accused, raised the same confrontation problem, and the Ninth Circuit so held in United States v. Orozco-Acosta, 607 F.3d 1156 (9th Cir. 2010). The 2013 amendment answered by adding the notice-and-demand procedure of subsection (B). The constitutional doctrine has its own treatment; the rule's procedural answer is what matters here.
Subsection (B) conditions a prosecutor's use of a certification on two events. The prosecutor must give written notice of the intent to offer it at least 14 days before trial, and the defendant must not object in writing within 7 days of receiving the notice, unless the court sets a different time for the notice or the objection.30 Most defendants have no quarrel with an empty file, so the procedure spares everyone a trip by a witness nobody needs. The notice tells the defendant early that the government plans to rely on a certificate. The written objection lets the defendant insist on live testimony, and its deadline tells the prosecutor before trial whether to line up a witness. The defendant who stays silent accepts the certificate, and the defendant who objects gets the witness.
The objection changes the form of the government's proof and leaves the government's ability to prove the absence intact. Only the certificate drops out, because the rule also admits testimony by a person who carried out the search.33 The opposite error treats a defendant's silence as a waiver of everything. Silence satisfies subsection (B) alone. Subsection (A) still applies, so a certificate offered to prove that a matter did not occur fails if the office kept no regular record of matters of that kind, however quiet the defendant has been. The notice step also belongs only to a prosecutor offering a certification in a criminal case, and a party in a civil case can offer a certification under Rule 902 without it.34