Concept
Three Kinds of Records
Public records and reports
Three Kinds of Records
Rule 803(8)(A) admits a public office’s record when it sets out one of three things: the office’s activities; a matter observed while under a legal duty to report; or, in a civil case or against the government in a criminal case, factual findings from a legally authorized investigation.1 The three clauses answer one question differently: how did the official come to know what the record says? An activity record draws on the office’s own internal operations, such as payroll, personnel, inventories, and disbursements.2 An observation record draws on what a public official personally saw while under a duty to observe and to report.3 An investigative finding draws on an inquiry and states what the agency concluded from it, often without any firsthand knowledge on the investigator’s part.4 Those different sources explain why the clauses carry different qualifications and, in criminal cases, different limits.
One document can contain all three kinds. Take the accident report of an Ohio State Highway Patrol sergeant, offered in a civil suit over an intersection collision. The sergeant reached the scene about six minutes after the crash.5 That he investigated the accident is an office activity. The position of the wreckage and the condition of the vehicles are matters he saw. His conclusion that the Valiant ran the red light is a factual finding, built partly on what he saw and partly on what the truckdriver, Joseph Slabach, told him.6 Because a single exhibit can fit several clauses, the most widely followed approach classifies each statement offered and does not try to label the whole report. Even statement by statement, some items stay ambiguous.7
The categories also overlap, and courts do not always say which one they are applying. In In the Matter of Oil Spill by the Amoco Cadiz Off the Coast of France, 954 F.2d 1279 (7th Cir. 1992), the Seventh Circuit noted that some of the reports before it fit under what are now both clauses (A)(i) and (A)(ii).8 In a civil case the overlap costs nothing. The question is whether there are substantial indications that the report is untrustworthy, and if there are none, the report comes in without any need to settle on a subdivision.9 In a criminal case the label can decide the outcome. Records of office activities are admissible in civil and criminal cases and may be introduced by or against any party, while the other two clauses carry criminal-case restrictions.10 A party can argue that a chemist’s report is merely a record of office activity, but a federal court of appeals rejected that argument for such a report. The court found it was prepared under clause (A)(ii) or, more likely, clause (A)(iii), and it treated the chemist as law-enforcement personnel.11
Office Activities
Clause (A)(i) is the oldest and most straightforward kind of public record: the office’s record of its own activities.12 It memorializes that an agency or official has done some act. A jail’s booking record can show that the jail placed a person in custody on a particular date, and an agency’s ‘received’ stamp can show that a claim was filed on a certain date.13 Court transcripts prove the testimony given, a marshal’s return proves service of process, and a Treasury Department progress sheet proves the processing and mailing of numbered government checks.14 In each instance, the act itself is the fact being proved.
A record of the office’s own work carries more than the reliability common to public records generally. A Treasury record of receipts and disbursements, for example, also has the assurances of accuracy that characterize business records, which courts routinely admit.15 Courts read the category with some breadth. In Eastern Air Lines, Inc. v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., 532 F.2d 957 (5th Cir. 1976), a Department of Commerce report of the Department’s informal policy of inducing airplane manufacturers to give priority to defense orders was construed as an activity of the office. The party offered it to explain the delay of other orders in a contract action on those orders.16 The policy was the agency’s own conduct, so the report described the office itself and not facts gathered somewhere else.
The clause is correspondingly modest in what it proves. A booking record shows when the jail took custody; it does not show that the person committed the offense for which he was arrested. A received stamp shows when the claim arrived; it does not show that the claim is true. What the record establishes is the act, and a party who needs more than the act must find another clause to carry it.
The usual mistake is to treat an agency file as a single record and to admit all of it for its truth because part of it describes the office’s work. Ask instead, statement by statement, whether the item merely records something the office did. If it does, clause (A)(i) is enough, and the opponent can resist only by showing under subsection (B) that the source of information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness.17 If the item reports what an official saw or concluded, another clause must carry it.
Matters Observed Under Duty
Clause (A)(ii) preserves what a public official saw. It reaches a record that sets out a matter observed while under a legal duty to report.19 The clause covers facts the official personally observed and was under a duty both to observe and to report, so the declarant must be a public official with personal knowledge.20 The two-duty structure has a legislative source. As the Supreme Court sent the rule to Congress, the clause covered only ‘matters observed pursuant to duty imposed by law.’ During House floor debate, concern was expressed that the clause might let the prosecution introduce a police officer’s report against the accused without producing the officer for cross-examination. The provision was amended to add the duty to report and to exclude, in criminal cases, matters observed by police officers and other law-enforcement personnel, and Congress enacted it as amended.21
Weather records are the classic example. The National Weather Service’s rainfall records qualify, and so does a meteorological official’s report of the weather at a given place and time, because the official’s job is to observe and record it.22 A building inspector’s report of leaking water in a building she inspected fits the same pattern.23 So do a safety inspector’s citation detailing safety violations, an induction officer’s observation that an inductee refused the required oath, and an INS officer’s report that he deported a particular individual.24 Cargo survey reports prepared for the Agency for International Development belong here too.25
Both duties limit what comes in. An official may see a great deal that the job never asked her to observe or record, and the clause does not carry those observations.
The clause also excludes what laypeople tell an official. A matter that a lay person observed and then reported to the official falls outside it, because the lay person has personal knowledge but no duty to report, while the official has the duty but no personal knowledge of the event.26
In a criminal case the clause adds a further exclusion for a matter observed by law-enforcement personnel. The officer must testify instead, as the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment also requires.27 A report that rests on what the official was told, as opposed to what the official saw, has to find its footing, if anywhere, in clause (A)(iii), which reaches investigative conclusions.
Investigative Findings
Clause (A)(iii) preserves what an agency concluded after looking into an event. In a civil case, or against the government in a criminal case, it admits factual findings from a legally authorized investigation.30 The examples are conclusions: Equal Employment Opportunity Commission findings of employment discrimination based on race and gender, Centers for Disease Control studies on toxic shock syndrome, Consumer Products Safety Commission reports on power tool accidents, and a Coast Guard Hearing Examiner’s finding about which of two crewmembers started a shipboard fight.31 A housing agency’s report, after investigation, that a particular project was operating under unsanitary conditions belongs here too.32 Private parties use such findings. In Cohen v. I.I.T., 524 F.2d 818 (7th Cir. 1975), a teacher supported a private sex-discrimination claim by introducing an H.E.W. finding to that effect, and findings can be used defensively as well.33
This is the broadest of the three kinds, because the investigator need not have perceived the matter. Investigative reports embody the results of an inquiry, so they are often not the product of the declarant’s firsthand knowledge, which most hearsay exceptions require.34 The idea is that the investigator is a government expert, able to assess the trustworthiness of a statement and decide whether to rely on it in her investigation.35 Unlike the other official-record exceptions, and unlike the business-records exception, this clause reaches statements by an outsider that the investigator adopts and builds her report on.36 The sergeant’s red-light conclusion shows the point. It rests partly on what truckdriver Slabach said, and clause (A)(iii) speaks of a legally authorized investigation in which the sergeant is supposed to figure out what happened, including by talking to witnesses.37 The hearsay character of the information the investigator used does not drop out of the analysis, however. The nature and trustworthiness of that information bear on whether the report comes in.38
In that case, the court held that the finding that the Valiant ran the red light is a ‘factual finding’ within clause (A)(iii).39 The court answered against a divided background. The House Judiciary Committee had adopted a narrow interpretation of ‘factual findings,’ the Senate disagreed, and the Conference Committee adopted the House’s version of the rule, although both versions used the term.40 The text itself holds some tension. The findings must be of a ‘factual’ sort and must issue from an ‘investigation,’ yet a finding is a conclusion, and ‘factual’ and ‘findings’ pull against each other.41 The next section takes up that tension.
Two limits keep the clause from reaching everything an agency produces. The statement must be the conclusion of a governmental agency, as opposed to a mere accumulation of information, and it must not be an interim or preliminary document.42 A pile of collected complaints states no one’s judgment, and a working paper may be revised or abandoned before the agency commits to it.
The opening words of the clause also build in a limit for criminal cases. Findings come in during a civil case, and in a criminal case only against the government, so an accused may offer an agency’s investigative findings but the prosecution may not offer them against the accused.43 The limitation exists because of ‘the almost certain collision with confrontation rights which would result’ from using investigative reports against the accused.44 A later section develops that limit.
In a civil case, the check on the clause’s breadth is subsection (B). The record comes in unless the opponent shows that the source of information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness.45