Concept
Basis for the Exception
Public records and reports
Public Records and Reports
Basis for the Exception
A government record is a hearsay problem before it is anything else. A building inspector's report, a clerk's ledger, and an agency's accident file are all out-of-court written assertions by officials. A party who offers one for its truth asks the factfinder to rely on a declarant it cannot see or cross-examine. Rule 803(8) removes that objection for a record or statement of a public office that satisfies the rule's conditions.1 It removes the objection whether or not the official is available, so the proponent never has to produce the official or explain an absence.2
The rule works in two steps, and the steps divide the burdens. Subsection (A) asks what the record sets out. It recognizes three kinds of content: the office's own activities,3 a matter observed while under a legal duty to report,4 and factual findings from a legally authorized investigation.5 The second and third kinds carry limits in criminal cases, which later sections take up. Subsection (B) then asks whether the opponent has shown that the source of information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness.6 The proponent must fit the record into a clause of (A), and the opponent must prove a reason for distrust.
The rule favors admission. Public records are presumed reliable, and the last provision of Rule 803(8) lets the judge exclude a record only if the opponent establishes that the sources of information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness. Rule 803(6) contains a parallel clause for business records.8
Older opinions quote the version of the rule that predates the restyling, and its lettering differs. That version listed the office's activities as (A), matters observed under a duty to report as (B), and, in civil actions and against the Government in criminal cases, investigative findings as (C). It closed with the words “unless the sources of information or other circumstances indicate lack of trustworthiness.”9 The current (A)(i), (A)(ii), and (A)(iii) cover the same three kinds, and the trustworthiness condition now sits in its own subsection, (B).10 The change matters beyond tidiness. Under the old text the proviso was tacked onto the end of a sentence that described all three kinds, and it was unclear whether the proviso governed all three or only the last.11 Setting the condition apart in its own subsection avoids that ambiguity.
Three grounds support the exception, and each answers a separate worry about relying on an absent declarant. The first is honesty and care. Courts assume that public officials generally discharge their duties faithfully and honestly, and the special trustworthiness of an official statement lies in the declarant's duty and the high probability that the duty to report accurately was performed.12 The second is memory. The volume of public business makes it unlikely that an official remembers the contents of most documents in her charge, so the written statement is usually more reliable than her recollection would be.13 The same reasoning explains why the declarant's unavailability is not required.14 The third is reliance. Members of the public, employees of the agency that created the record, and other government departments depend on public documents.15
English courts add a fourth safeguard and require that an official statement be one kept for the use and information of the public, because public inspection might expose inaccuracies and lead to their correction, or deter them in the first place. American courts have not adopted that limit. Inspection offers at most a modest extra assurance, and insisting on it would exclude many documents reliable enough to admit.16 Practical convenience also explains the exception's popularity. A certified copy proves the record, the foundation is simple, and no custodian need testify, so Rule 803(8) is an attractive route whenever it is available.17
Because the assurance comes from official duty, Rule 803(8) does not borrow the regularity conditions that carry the business-records exception. Rule 803(6) requires a record made at or near the time by someone with knowledge, kept in the course of a regularly conducted activity, and made as a regular practice of that activity. A custodian or other qualified witness, or a certification, must show each condition.18 Rule 803(8) requires none of this. A public record need not be created as part of a regular, systematic routine.19 A government geologist's one-time entry describing the composition, texture, and color of volcanic ash is therefore admissible even if the geologist wrote it well after the observations. The public duty of those who prepare public records makes the entry presumptively reliable.20 The foundation is lighter as well, because the record must be shown to be that of a duly authorized public office.21
The public-records and business-records exceptions overlap where a record describes an agency's own internal workings. Employment and personnel records kept by a government office are no more and no less accurate than the same records kept by a private employer, and the rule admits them in civil and criminal cases.22 That overlap invites the most common student error, which is treating anything a government office holds as a public record. Suppose a state requires motorists to complete an accident report and send it to the motor-vehicle department, and a party later offers the motorist's written narrative to prove how the crash happened. The department's receipt does not turn the narrative into an official record. A legal requirement to file does not make the filer a public declarant, and a motorist completing a required report can scarcely be regarded as acting under an official or professional duty.23 The department's own log showing when it received the report would be different, because that records the office's activity. Only the motorist's account of the crash fails to qualify under Rule 803(8). The line between a record and the outsiders' statements inside it returns later in this chapter.