Concept
Reading Rule 803(4)
Statements for purposes of medical diagnosis and treatment
Medical Diagnosis and Treatment Statements
Reading Rule 803(4)
Rule 803(4) has two parts joined by the word “and,” so a statement must satisfy both. Part (A) requires that the statement be made for, and be reasonably pertinent to, medical diagnosis or treatment.1 Part (B) requires that the statement describe medical history, past or present symptoms or sensations, their inception, or their general cause.2 Part (A) asks why the person spoke. Part (B) asks what the person said.
The rule rests on an assumption about patients: the desire for proper diagnosis or treatment outweighs any motive to falsify.3 People have a compelling self-interest in speaking truthfully to those who provide medical services, and that interest supplies the reliability that justifies the exception.4 The self-interest exists only when the speaker is trying to get care, which explains why part (A) asks about purpose.
Rule 803(4) belongs to the group of exceptions that apply regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness.5 The proponent need not show that the patient is dead, absent, or unwilling to testify. The patient's interest in an accurate report arose when the statement was made, and it looks the same whether or not the patient later takes the stand.
The exception also reaches further than the exception for statements of mental, emotional, or physical condition in Rule 803(3). It covers past medical history as well as current symptoms. It also extends to descriptions of what caused the patient's problem, so long as those descriptions are reasonably pertinent to diagnosis or treatment.6 Because the rule reaches so far, its two limits do most of the work. The sections that follow take them apart one at a time.
Exam writers favor this pair because the words are identical and only the purpose differs. A statement does not qualify merely because its subject is medical. It must pass both questions: why it was made, and what it describes. Whether the lunch-table account fits some other exception is a separate matter.