Concept
Physical and Sensory Condition
Statements of mental, emotional, or physical condition
Physical and Sensory Condition
Rule 803(3) reaches the body as well as the mind. It admits a statement of the declarant's then-existing emotional, sensory, or physical condition, and it names mental feeling, pain, and bodily health as examples.1 A person who says "my chest is tight right now" or "my vision is blurring" describes a bodily condition as it exists while the words are spoken. A witness who heard those words may repeat them, and the jury may treat them as proof of that condition.
The physical branch rests on the reasoning behind the mental one. A statement that explicitly describes what the declarant feels, such as "I hate him," looks like hearsay when offered to prove the feeling, yet it falls within a longstanding exception for statements describing the declarant's state of mind.2 Rule 803(3) carries that exception over to sensory and physical condition, and the word then-existing ties both branches to the moment of speaking.3 The rule also asks for less ceremony than the word declaration might suggest, since a declaration, in the dictionary sense, is a formal statement, proclamation, or announcement.4 The rule's text requires only a "statement" of the declarant's condition, so a muttered remark in a driveway can qualify.
The usual justification is practical. A person who reports a pain or a dizziness describes something perceived at that instant, so memory has had no time to fade, and an outcry of pain leaves little room to shape the words for a lawsuit. The words are also often the best evidence available, because a bystander can see a wince but cannot measure a headache. What remains is the risk that the speaker exaggerates or invents a sensation no one else can check.
The rule's text sets two limits, and each marks the point where the declarant stops describing the body and starts narrating the past. First, the condition must be then-existing, so a statement about a symptom the declarant had last week reports a remembered condition and fails that requirement. Second, the rule excludes a statement of memory or belief offered to prove the fact remembered or believed, subject to a will exception that does not matter here.5 A statement that a collision or a fall caused the injury, offered to prove the collision or the fall, is therefore out. Both limits keep out statements whose reliability depends on memory, and the memory-or-belief limit receives its own treatment later in the chapter.
The two remarks share a declarant and a subject, and they differ in the time to which the words refer. The word pain appears in both, but the exception follows the time of the condition described, so the vocabulary of pain does not rescue a sentence about last week.
Rule 803(4) covers ground that Rule 803(3) leaves open, in a different setting. It admits a statement that is made for, and is reasonably pertinent to, medical diagnosis or treatment, and that describes medical history; past or present symptoms or sensations; their inception; or their general cause.6 The usual explanation is that a patient seeking care has reason to describe symptoms accurately, because the treatment depends on the description. The listener and the purpose change the analysis while the words stay the same. "Last week I had terrible chest pains" falls outside Rule 803(3) when said over the fence to a neighbor, yet it can come in under Rule 803(4) when said to an emergency physician in order to obtain treatment. This section uses Rule 803(4) only to mark the edge of Rule 803(3), and the requirements of that rule deserve separate treatment.
Even inside Rule 803(4), a statement about the cause of a condition qualifies only if it involves topics reasonably related to diagnosis or treatment.7 "I was in a car collision" tells the doctor which injuries to look for. "The other car ran the red light" assigns fault and changes nothing about how the injury is treated, so a statement of fault generally falls outside both exceptions, whether the listener is a neighbor or a nurse.