Concept
Analyzing a Hearsay Problem
What is hearsay
Analyzing a Hearsay Problem
Rule 801(c) turns every hearsay objection into three questions about the evidence, and Rule 802 adds a fourth about the rules. Hearsay is a statement that the declarant does not make while testifying at the current trial or hearing and that a party offers to prove the truth of the matter asserted in the statement.1 A statement is a person's oral assertion, written assertion, or nonverbal conduct the person intended as an assertion, and the declarant is the person who made it.2 Those definitions yield the first three questions. Rule 802 supplies the fourth by excluding hearsay unless a federal statute, the Federal Rules of Evidence, or other rules prescribed by the Supreme Court provide otherwise.3 The earlier sections took the definition apart one element at a time. This section puts the elements back together as a method that works on any fact pattern, then adds two cautions that decide many exam questions.
The order matters because the questions do different work. The first three test the definition, and a no at any of them ends the inquiry, because the evidence is then not hearsay and the objection fails. The fourth question arises only after three yeses, and it asks something else: whether the circumstances around the statement justify admitting it without cross-examination of the declarant. Each exception specifies requirements that the rules treat as sufficient guarantees of trustworthiness for that purpose.4 Blurring the two produces the commonest errors. One student reasons that a trustworthy statement cannot be hearsay, which imports a feature of the exceptions into the definition. Another reaches for an exception before checking the definition and concedes a hearsay problem that never existed.
The third question produces most of the surprises. Hearsay does not reach every out-of-court statement, only those offered to prove the truth of what they assert, so when the mere making of the statement is the relevant fact, hearsay is not involved.5 To test this, set the fact the words assert beside the fact the proponent needs the jury to find.
The first step reaches beyond words. Conduct counts as a statement only when the person intended it as an assertion. A defendant who wants people to believe her hamburgers are safe and posts a picture of herself and her daughter eating them has made a statement that the meat is safe, because the picture intends to assert that.6 Conduct without that intent, and anything produced without a person asserting it, leaves the analysis at step one.
Five groups of provisions can answer the fourth question. Rule 801(d) removes a testifying declarant's prior statements and an opposing party's statements from the hearsay category by definition, even though they otherwise fit it.7 Rule 803 holds exceptions that apply whether or not the declarant is available, Rule 804 holds exceptions that require the declarant to be unavailable, and Rule 807, the residual exception, reaches reliable hearsay that fits no categorical exception.8 So much hearsay is admissible under one of these provisions that finding hearsay opens the analysis instead of closing it.9 An answer that stops at the label leaves the real question unanswered. Later readings teach each provision in turn.
A worked problem shows the method at the pace an essay answer demands.
The friend's account of the conversation is ordinary testimony, so the analysis runs on Trucker's own words. Those words are an oral assertion by a person, which answers the first question. She spoke to a friend and not while testifying at the current trial, which answers the second. The words assert that the steering failed, and the plaintiff needs the jury to find that it failed, so the plaintiff offers them for their truth, which answers the third. The statement is hearsay. At the fourth question, the provision for an employee's statement offered against an employer does not reach it, because Trucker was not working for XYZ when she spoke. Nothing suggests she was upset, and she spoke a week after the accident rather than during it or immediately afterward, so neither the excited utterance exception nor the present sense impression exception fits. No exemption or exception applies, and Rule 802 excludes the statement.10
Change one fact and the result reverses. Suppose Trucker had told a bystander at the scene, while still working for XYZ and making a delivery, that the steering wheel would not respond. The first three answers stay the same, since the remark is still an out-of-court assertion offered for its truth. The fourth answer changes, because the remark concerns a matter within her employment and was made while the employment lasted. The rules then define it as not hearsay when offered against XYZ.11 The timing of her employment, and nothing about her words, separates the excluded statement from the admitted one. Even the admitted version has cleared only the hearsay objection, which leads to the first caution.
Hearsay status and admissibility are different questions, and the error runs in both directions. Relevance comes first: the court asks whether the evidence helps prove a consequential fact, and only if it does must the court consider whether the hearsay rule or some other rule bars it.12 Reliability does not substitute for the definition either. Reliable hearsay still needs an exemption or an exception, and when no categorical exception fits, it needs the residual exception.13
In the other direction, a statement that is not hearsay, or that fits an exemption or exception, has cleared only the hearsay objection. It must still be relevant, rest on the declarant's personal knowledge, be properly authenticated, and satisfy the original writing rule when a writing's contents are being proved.14 The Advisory Committee phrased the Rule 803 exceptions as nonapplication of the hearsay rule, rather than as positive grounds of admissibility, so that other possible grounds for exclusion would stay in play.15 A criminal case adds a constitutional layer. When the prosecution offers a hearsay statement against the accused, the declarant is unavailable, the statement is testimonial, and the accused never had a chance to cross-examine the declarant, the Confrontation Clause makes the evidence inadmissible even though a hearsay exception applies.16
The second caution concerns a statement that repeats another statement. Each speaker is a declarant, and each layer needs its own analysis. A witness who testifies that Jill told her that Jane said she saw a blue car run a red light supplies one witness and two declarants, with Jill's statement as the outer layer and Jane's as the inner one. Documents work the same way. A written report that records what a bystander said involves two declarants, the bystander and the person who wrote the report, and the report is useful only if both the bystander's words and the writer's account of them are accurate. A court might admit the whole report by finding a present sense impression for the bystander's words and the business records exception for the report, but if the court rejects either one, the entire report must be excluded.17 The practical step is to count the declarants first, run the four questions once for each, and remember that a route to admission for the outer layer says nothing about the inner one.