Concept
Beech Aircraft v. Rainey
Completeness rule
Beech Aircraft v. Rainey
Beech Aircraft Corp. v. Rainey, 488 U.S. 153 (1988), shows the completeness principle working on a concrete record. The defense used portions of a letter, the trial judge refused to let the letter's author bring out the rest, and the Supreme Court held that refusal an abuse of discretion.1 The Court reached that result without deciding whether Rule 106 applied. The gap between what the case shows and what it holds is the point to master.
The text of the rule frames the problem. Once a party introduces all or part of a statement, an adverse party may require the introduction, at that time, of any other part, or any other statement, that in fairness ought to be considered at the same time, and may do so over a hearsay objection.2 The version of Rule 106 quoted in Beech Aircraft was narrower. It spoke of “a writing or recorded statement or part thereof” and of material that “ought in fairness to be considered contemporaneously with it.”3
Rainey's case rested on the theory that a power failure caused the accident. His letter to Morgan, read in its entirety, was fully consistent with that theory. Its thrust was to challenge Morgan's own theory that the crash came from a stall when the pilots turned sharply right and pitched up to avoid another plane. Rainey argued that Morgan's hypothesis contradicted the eyewitnesses, the physical findings in the wreckage, and the likely actions of the two pilots. The letter also conceded some things. Rainey discussed problems his wife had met the morning of the accident, which led her to try to cancel the flight, and he agreed that her airplane had violated pattern integrity by turning left prematurely.4
The defense put portions of the letter before the jury. When Rainey's own counsel then tried to present additional information about it, in what was cross-examination of Rainey by his counsel, the court sustained defense counsel's objection.5 Counsel could not counteract the prejudicial impression the jury had received, and the impression stood uncorrected.6
The Court treated the correction as the reaffirmation of the obvious. When one party has used a portion of a document, and misunderstanding or distortion can be averted only by presenting another portion, the material needed for completeness is ipso facto relevant and therefore admissible under Rules 401 and 402.7 The Court agreed with the unanimous holding of the Court of Appeals en banc that the District Court erred in refusing to let Rainey present a more complete picture of what he had written to Morgan. It called the refusal a clear abuse of discretion.8
The relevance route works because of what the defense had done. Once portions of the letter were before the jury, the letter's overall message was something the jury would weigh. The passages showing that the letter argued for power failure and attacked Morgan's stall theory bore directly on that message, so no separate completeness rule was needed to admit them. The same reasoning marks the boundary of what comes in. Completing material earns admission to the extent that it answers the distortion the fragment created.
The holding is narrower than that reasoning might suggest. Much of the controversy in the case had centered on whether Rule 106 applies, but the Court found it unnecessary to decide. The concerns underlying the rule were clearly relevant, yet the general rules of relevancy permitted a ready resolution, so the Court went no further in exploring the scope and meaning of Rule 106.9 The holding is correspondingly tied to “the facts of this litigation.”10 A student who cites the case for a reading of the rule's text, such as whether it reaches oral statements or overrides a hearsay objection, asks the opinion a question it expressly left open. The quoted older wording also differs from the current rule, which covers any statement and permits completion over a hearsay objection. The opinion's reasoning about distortion carries forward, but its quoted language does not.11
The ruling was not unanimous at the Supreme Court. Chief Justice Rehnquist, joined by Justice O'Connor, filed an opinion dissenting from this part of the Court's opinion.12
Examiners like to rebuild this fact pattern with new names and the current rule. Here is one such version.
Run the problem through the Court's reasoning. Standing alone, the two passages point toward the pilots' conduct rather than a loss of power, and the letter's conclusion is the material that answers them. Under today's text the hearsay objection fails, because the rule permits completion over it. The scope objection fails as well, because the rule lets the adverse party require completion at that time.14 The Beech Aircraft route arrives at the same place through relevance. Once Rockwood has put the passages before the jury, the conclusion that answers them is relevant because it averts the distortion. Sustaining the objections would repeat the error that the Supreme Court called a clear abuse of discretion.