Concept
Trial Court Discretion
Summaries
Trial Court Discretion
Rule 1006 says the court may admit a summary, chart, or calculation, and that single word leaves most decisions about summaries with the trial judge.1 The same rule requires the proponent to make the underlying originals available to the other parties at a reasonable time and place, and it adds that the court may order the proponent to produce them in court.2 Appellate courts honor that allocation. The admission of summary charts lies within the district court’s discretion, and the court’s decision will be upheld absent an abuse of discretion.3
That deference follows from the question the judge must answer. No precise test says when source materials are indigestible enough to summarize, so the district court weighs their volume and complexity, which bear an inverse relationship: as either increases, less is required of the other. The ultimate question is whether summarization will remove logistic or cognitive barriers to the jury’s discharge of its duties.4 An appellate court is poorly positioned to second-guess the trial judge’s on-the-spot answer, and one opinion, quoting an earlier decision, called it hard to imagine an issue on which a trial judge enjoys more discretion than whether summary exhibits will be helpful.5 The summaries in that decision show the question in practice. They spared the government from introducing, and the jury from sifting through, mortgage and sale records for each of twenty-one properties, and they made it easier to trace the appellants’ proceeds through an IOLTA account, which fit the purpose of Rule 1006.6
Disputes over charts reach the judge in concrete form. In one prosecution, the government explained that its exhibits were offered under Rule 1006 because they were “nonargumentative, basically neutral” and related to evidence that was not necessarily admitted but was voluminous or inconvenient for the court to consider, and that for this reason no limiting instruction was required. The prosecutor had pointed the court to case law distinguishing Rule 1006 summaries from those offered under Rule 611(a). Defense counsel answered that the charts, which compared nonindicted persons with indicted persons, were argumentative and were not offered just to compile evidence in a readable form for the jury. The court said it would do more research.7
The label the judge chooses matters. A Rule 1006 summary is admitted as evidence to prove the content of voluminous writings.8 Visual aids stood on different footing in the older approach: maps, models, diagrams, and photographs were viewed not as independent evidence but as illustrative evidence that helped a witness make a point, and they were allowed because some matters are more easily explained visually than orally.9
A judge earns deference by doing the work. In another case the district court required the government to modify its summaries to eliminate unnecessary and potentially prejudicial information and labels, expressly weighed “the usefulness versus the potential misuse of summaries of this nature,” and concluded that the jurors needed the charts to sort through “an extraordinarily complex document case.” The reviewing court said the district court had exercised its discretion “with meticulous care.”10 That weighing tracks what a court must ensure before admitting evidentiary presentations of this kind: a sufficient factual basis in independently established evidence in the record, and possible prejudice or confusion that does not outweigh their usefulness in clarifying the evidence.11
The decision may also arise in the middle of trial. One court recognized that an attorney may not realize until well into a trial that a summary chart would be beneficial, and admissible under Rule 1006, because the documents already admitted were too voluminous for the jury to examine conveniently.12 Rule 1006 permits a summary whether or not the originals have been introduced, so a chart can arrive after the underlying documents are already in evidence.13
Even a wrong ruling does not always require reversal. Where a sufficient objection was made, the appellate court reviews for abuse of discretion, and Buck states the harmlessness standard: an evidentiary error can be excused if it was harmless, and a nonconstitutional trial error is harmless unless it had a substantial and injurious effect or influence in determining the jury’s verdict.14 A challenger must therefore show more than that a summary came in. The challenger must show that it affected the verdict.
Preservation matters as much as harmlessness. The defendant, Bray, argued on appeal that the forms behind the government’s summaries were not made available to him in a timely manner, a complaint that goes to the availability of the originals the rule requires. He had not raised that objection in the district court, so he had to establish plain error.15 The court of appeals assumed for argument that the disclosure was late and still found no plain error. At the government’s suggestion, the trial court had offered the defense a chance to reopen its proofs to challenge the foundation for the exhibits, and counsel declined; that opportunity was enough to mitigate any prejudice from untimely disclosure. Bray did not contend that the summaries misstated the forms, and he did not explain how timely disclosure would have made a difference.16 A defendant who raises a problem at trial gets a ruling reviewed for abuse of discretion; a defendant who raises it first on appeal must show plain error.17