Concept
Rule 1002 and Its Purpose
Requirement of original
The Original Writing Rule
Rule 1002 and Its Purpose
Rule 1002 requires an original writing, recording, or photograph to prove its content unless these rules or a federal statute provides otherwise.1 The sentence carries three limits. The rule reaches only three kinds of recorded items. It applies only when a party is trying to prove what one of those items says or shows. And it yields to any other rule or federal statute that provides otherwise. The burden falls on the proponent, the party offering the evidence. A proponent who wants the factfinder to learn the terms of a document must put the document before the court unless the Rules supply a substitute.
The familiar name for the requirement, the best evidence rule, promises more than the rule delivers. Parties are generally free to prove a proposition with whatever relevant evidence they choose, subject to the exclusionary rules, and self-interested parties usually weigh cost against persuasiveness when they choose.2 No general requirement exists that a party produce the best or most probative evidence of a proposition, though parties often find it advantageous to do so.3 What survives under the label is a single requirement: production of an original writing, recording, or photograph. It is enforced against the proponent of any secondary evidence, meaning testimony or an exhibit that presents a version of the original's contents.4 Courts say the same thing in their own terms. One court observed that the "Rule" itself is applicable only to the proof of the contents of a writing.5 The court in Seiler v. Lucasfilm, Ltd. traced the doctrine to about 1700 and explained that it demands not the best evidence in every case but production of an original document instead of a copy, which is why many commentators call it the original document rule.6
The purposes behind the rule explain why it attaches to content and not to events. When the contents of a writing are at issue, oral testimony about its terms is more likely to be wrong than oral testimony about events or other situations. Human memory is seldom able to recite the precise terms of a writing, and when those terms are disputed, only the writing or a true copy provides reliable evidence.7 Two further concerns complete the list: the importance of precise terms in legal relations, and the hazards of inaccurate or incomplete duplication.8
Fraud prevention was long thought to be the purpose, but Wigmore showed that the explanation fails. The rule excludes secondary evidence even when its proponent acts in the utmost good faith. And if fraud were the foundation, the rule would reach objects as well as writings, which it does not.9 Some writers add that the rule protects against misleading selection from a comprehensive set of writings the opponent cannot reach. That concern is better treated as an aspect of the rule of completeness, now the subject of Federal Rule 106.10
These concerns do not weigh equally today, and the difference shows where the rule still matters. Accurate modern reproduction has removed most of the worry that a copy contains accidental inaccuracies or omissions, so insisting on an original instead of a duplicate seldom improves factfinding.11 Rule 1003 reflects that change. A duplicate is admissible to the same extent as the original unless a genuine question is raised about the original's authenticity or the circumstances make it unfair to admit the duplicate.12 Rule 1004 provides a second relaxation: it excuses production of the original in listed circumstances, one of which is that all the originals are lost or destroyed, and not by the proponent acting in bad faith.13 Memory has not improved, however. The principal modern impact of the rule is to exclude oral testimony about the contents of a recorded item, as with the employer's recollection of the letter, and not to exclude duplicates.14 The rule keeps its original aim of accurate factfinding while giving litigants and judges more flexibility in light of modern technology.15
Modern discovery has also reduced the need for a strict original requirement. Compelled disclosure of exhibits and pretrial conferences let each side examine original documents or secondary evidence before trial instead of at it.16 The rule survives because discovery is neither uniform across jurisdictions nor complete. Obtaining documents outside the jurisdiction may cost substantial time and money, an unanticipated document may not practically be discoverable, and criminal cases carry built-in limits on discovery.17 Further expansion of discovery may eventually make the rule obsolete in civil cases, but for now it remains a continuing and important requirement.18
Rule 1002's closing clause, which yields to whatever these rules or a federal statute provide, points beyond Rules 1003 and 1004. Rules 1005, 1006, and 1007 address related issues involving public records, summaries, and admissions of a party-opponent.19 The rest of this chapter follows the order of questions the rule poses. Is the item a writing, recording, or photograph? Is its content being proved? What counts as the original? Does a duplicate or an excuse take the original's place?
Even a clear violation of the rule does not guarantee reversal. The rule exists to secure the most reliable information about the contents of a writing, recording, or photograph. Before a technical violation will be held reversible error, counsel must at least be able to assert a good-faith dispute about the item's existence or content, and without that assertion the error is clearly harmless.20 Suppose Lindqvist never contested the letter's wording at trial and cannot now say it read differently. A retrial is unlikely merely because the employer testified without the letter in court.