Concept
Applying Rule 412
Past sexual conduct of a victim
Applying Rule 412
Rule 412(a) opens with a flat prohibition: the sexual-history evidence it describes is “not admissible in a civil or criminal proceeding involving alleged sexual misconduct.”1 The exceptions make sense only against that default, so the date-rape problem below runs each piece of proposed testimony through the bar first and the exceptions second.
Leslie returns to her sorority after midnight from a luau at a fraternity house. She tells her roommate and a few friends that she met a man named Fred there; that she had met him several times the previous summer, when she was a lifeguard at a pool where he taught swimming; and that she accepted his offer of a ride home. She says he took her to a lonely spot and made advances, that at first she “didn’t mind,” but that he “got completely out of hand” and raped her. At a clinic, bruises are found on her legs and forearms, and semen is found in her vagina.2
Fred is charged with rape and pleads not guilty. His defense is consent: he describes the encounter in a way that, if believed, shows Leslie as a voluntary and even enthusiastic participant. The rule reaches Leslie’s “other sexual behavior,” meaning her past acts, and Fred’s account of the charged event is not that, so it needs no exception.3 Fred then offers three more items: his own testimony that he and Leslie had consensual sex once during the previous summer; Greg’s testimony that Leslie is “sexually very active” and “known as an easy mark”; and Thomas’s testimony that he had sex with Leslie earlier that same night. The prosecutor objects that all three are irrelevant and barred by the rape shield.
The prosecutor’s two objections raise two questions, and winning the first does not answer the second. On relevance, Fred can argue that an earlier encounter with him, a reputation for promiscuity, and a sexual encounter hours before the charged event each make it more likely that Leslie said yes. Rule 412 does not care. It keeps the defendant from introducing evidence of the victim’s past sexual behavior even when that evidence has some logical relevance to consent.4 Rule 404(a)(2) lets a defendant open the door to a bad character trait of the victim, and Rule 412 takes one such trait, the old “character for chastity,” off the table. Only an exception written into Rule 412 can put it back. The rule also governs every item that follows, because this is a criminal proceeding involving alleged sexual misconduct, even though Fred insists that what happened was consensual.
Step two does the most work here: the purpose behind an offer, not the words of the testimony, decides which exception, if any, is in play. The three items follow in the order Fred offers them.
Fred’s Summer Encounter
Fred’s testimony that he and Leslie had consensual sex once the previous summer describes a specific instance of her sexual behavior, so the bar covers it until an exception lifts it. Rule 412(b)(1)(B) supplies the exception. The court may admit “evidence of specific instances of a victim’s sexual behavior with respect to the person accused of the sexual misconduct, if offered by the defendant to prove consent or if offered by the prosecutor.”7 Fred’s offer satisfies each element: it is a specific instance, the other participant is the accused himself, and Fred offers it to prove consent. The same clause lets the prosecutor offer such evidence. Consent is the defendant’s stated purpose under the clause, so an offer made for some other purpose would need a different footing.
Clearing the shield does not decide admission. The exception says the court may admit this evidence, not that it must,8 so the testimony still has to survive the rest of the rules of evidence, including Rule 403. The prosecutor’s remaining points, that this was a single encounter in the previous summer and that Leslie says she refused on this night, go to probative value and weight. An admitted encounter is not a finding of consent; the jury decides what it shows. Of the three items, this is the only one that clearly fits an exception on the facts as given, and it fits because of who the partner was.
Before the judge rules, Fred must make a pretrial motion that gives 14 days’ notice and informs the prosecutor and Leslie or her guardian. The court then holds an in camera hearing at which Leslie and the parties may attend and explain why the evidence should be excluded, and the record is sealed.9
Greg’s Reputation Testimony
Greg’s statements that Leslie is “sexually very active” and “known as an easy mark” describe no occasion on which Leslie did anything. They characterize what kind of person she is, so that the jury will infer that a person like that probably agreed to sex with Fred. That is evidence of sexual predisposition, meaning opinion or reputation testimony, and the bar reaches it just as it reaches evidence of other sexual behavior.10
The two exceptions that look closest do not reach it. Clauses (A) and (B) both speak of “specific instances” of a victim’s sexual behavior, and Greg identifies no instance and no partner.11 A reputation names no event, so it cannot account for a particular bruise or a finding of semen, and it cannot describe an earlier encounter with Fred.
The constitutional clause remains. Rule 412(b)(1)(C) admits “evidence whose exclusion would violate the defendant’s constitutional rights.”12 It creates no right of its own; it points to rights found elsewhere and asks whether excluding this evidence would violate one of them. Fred offers Greg’s testimony to show what kind of person Leslie is and so to prove consent, and the problem gives him no other use for it. He therefore cannot identify a constitutional right that exclusion would violate. Whatever route Fred tries, he must press it through the same motion, notice, and in camera hearing, so the court decides the question out of public view.13
Thomas’s Same-Night Encounter
Thomas’s testimony tempts a quick but wrong answer: semen was found, Thomas had sex with Leslie earlier that night, so the semen-source exception must apply. That clause admits a specific instance of sexual behavior only if it is offered “to prove that someone other than the defendant was the source of semen, injury, or other physical evidence.”14 The purpose arises when the defendant denies intercourse: the prosecutor then offers semen or bruising to show that he had sex with the victim, and the defendant rebuts with evidence that someone else was the source.15 Fred’s defense is consent, and consent concedes the sex. Nobody is asking who produced the semen. The only question left for the jury is whether Leslie agreed, and Thomas’s testimony bears on that question only through the inference that a woman who had sex with one man that night probably agreed to sex with another, which is the character reasoning Rule 412 takes off the table. Clause (B) does not help, because Thomas is not the person accused.
The words Thomas speaks are the same in both versions, and the defense Fred chooses sets the purpose they serve. The exception exists for the denial setting, where the prosecutor offers physical evidence to show contact with the defendant and the defendant may answer that someone else produced it.16 Under a consent defense, the same proof has no physical-evidence work to do. The constitutional clause does not rescue it on these facts either, because the problem shows no use for Thomas’s testimony other than consent and so no constitutional right that excluding it would violate. Procedure follows the same path as for the other items: a motion stating the purpose, an in camera hearing, and a sealed record.17
The three items come out differently because each supports a different inference. Fred’s summer encounter ties Leslie’s conduct to the accused and to consent, and it alone clearly clears the shield. Greg’s testimony ties nothing to any occasion or partner, so it fits no listed exception and reaches the jury only if some constitutional right requires it, which the problem does not show. Thomas’s testimony fits an exception only if Fred denies intercourse, and Fred has not. Any item that does reach the jury arrives only after the motion and the closed hearing, and any item the court excludes stays out of public view, because the record is sealed.