Concept
Pleas and Plea Hearings
Plea negotiations
Pleas and Plea Hearings
Rule 410(a) protects a defendant against four kinds of plea evidence, and the first three attach to the plea itself or to the hearing at which it is entered. In a civil or criminal case, none of the following is admissible against the defendant who made the plea: a guilty plea that was later withdrawn, a nolo contendere plea, or a statement made during a proceeding on either of those pleas.1 Rule 410(a)(1) covers the withdrawn guilty plea, and Rule 410(a)(2) covers the nolo contendere plea with no withdrawal condition at all.2 The difference in wording is deliberate, and the subsections below explain it. The fourth category, statements in discussions with a prosecutor, reaches an earlier stage of the case and carries its own conditions, so it follows in the next section.
Each of the three items marks a moment when the defendant, in open court, committed or tried to commit to a disposition of the charge. A plea entered on the record ranks among the most incriminating things a defendant can say about the case. If the jury could hear of it after the court let the defendant take it back, the right to withdraw would restore the right to trial in name only. The same logic protects the nolo contendere defendant: the plea exists to avoid the admission of guilt inherent in a guilty plea,3 and it would fail that purpose if an opponent could later offer it as an admission. Statements at the hearing stand or fall with the plea they accompany, so they receive the same protection.
Because the protection attaches to the plea or the hearing, the questions that dominate plea discussions, who listened and whether real bargaining took place, rarely arise for these three items. The lead-in’s limits still govern all of them: each item is excluded only against the defendant who made the plea, and the exclusion applies in civil cases as well as criminal ones.
Plea and pleading share a root but not a function. Pleadings state each party’s contentions, define the factual issues, and are consulted as part of the record without being offered in evidence.4 A Rule 410 plea poses a different question: whether a defendant’s statement of guilt, made in one proceeding, may be offered against the defendant in the same case or a later one.
Withdrawn Guilty Pleas
Rule 410(a)(1) makes a guilty plea that was later withdrawn inadmissible against the defendant who entered it.5 The words later withdrawn carry the rule, because a guilty plea that stands fares very differently. An unretracted plea is the defendant’s own statement of guilt. When an opposing party offers it against the pleader, it is non-hearsay under Rule 801(d)(2)(A), and it may be admitted against the pleader in a later action.6 Rule 410 excludes a guilty plea only if the plea was withdrawn before judgment was entered on it, and it does not exclude a plea merely because a bargain produced it.7
The policy case for admitting a plea that stands is strong. Many incentives already push guilty parties toward pleading, especially when the plea is to a lesser charge, so allowing later use of the plea would probably not cut the settlement rate much.8 The plea also carries weight as proof. Before entering judgment on a guilty plea, the court must determine that it has a factual basis,9 and a plea that stands is admissible as the pleader’s own admission. Pleas to minor offenses may sometimes be questionable evidence of actual guilt, but that concern is handled case by case, weighing the probative value of the particular plea against the risk of undue prejudice.10 Many states refuse to allow later use of evidence that a person charged with a traffic infraction paid the fine rather than contest it. Rule 410 draws no such line and treats every unwithdrawn plea alike.11
Criminal Rule 11 decides whether a plea is ever later withdrawn. The fair-and-just-reason standard governs withdrawal until sentencing. Once the judge sentences the defendant on the plea, the district court loses authority to withdraw it, and only the court of appeals or a court considering a collateral attack can invalidate it.12 Rule 410 therefore draws its line at judgment: a plea withdrawn before judgment is protected, and a plea that survives to judgment is not.
A defendant who wants out of a plea may argue that it was not knowing and voluntary, and courts answer by examining the colloquy the trial judge conducted. The opinion in Quagliarello v. Dewees recounts an earlier decision that refused to call a plea involuntary because the trial judge had conducted a “textbook Rule 11 inquiry, taking pains to insure that the defendant’s submissions were knowing and voluntary.” Because the voluntariness finding rested on a credibility determination, the court declined to disturb it absent clear evidence to the contrary.13
The rationale for excluding a withdrawn plea comes from Kercheval v. United States, which held withdrawn guilty pleas inadmissible in federal prosecutions. Admitting one, the Court reasoned, would effectively set at naught the allowance of withdrawal and would place the accused in a dilemma utterly inconsistent with the decision to award a trial.14 The mechanism is easy to trace. Withdrawal is supposed to return the defendant to the position of someone who has admitted nothing and may hold the government to its proof. A jury that learns of the plea hears the most damaging item in the case anyway. The New York Court of Appeals added a second reason in People v. Spitaleri, when it overturned its earlier decisions allowing admission: admitting the plea compels the defendant to take the stand to explain it and opens the way for the prosecution to call the lawyer who represented the defendant when the plea was entered.15
A single pair of facts shows where the line falls.
A stem that says the defendant pleaded guilty therefore begins with one question: was the plea withdrawn? If it was, Rule 410(a)(1) excludes it against the defendant, whatever theory the proponent attaches to it. If it was not, Rule 410 does not reach the plea, and any limit on its use must come from somewhere else. The judgment that follows a plea that sticks is a separate matter. Rule 410(a) lists pleas and statements, not judgments, and a judgment against the defendant may carry preclusive effect in a later civil suit.16
Nolo Contendere Pleas
Rule 410(a)(2) makes a nolo contendere plea inadmissible against the defendant who made it, and unlike the guilty plea in Rule 410(a)(1), it carries no requirement that the plea ever have been withdrawn.18 Nolo contendere literally means “I will not contest it.” Like a guilty plea, the nolo plea amounts to an admission of all the essential elements of the charge, and without Rule 410 it would come in against the pleader as a party’s own statement under Rule 801(d)(2)(A).19 The withdrawn guilty plea is excluded to keep withdrawal meaningful. The nolo plea needs a different explanation, because nothing has been withdrawn, and that explanation lies in what the defendant and the government trade when the plea is entered.
In return for the nolo plea, the government gives up the right to use it against the defendant in any subsequent proceeding, and that concession is what makes the plea attractive. For evidentiary purposes, it is the primary difference between a nolo plea and a guilty plea.20 The Advisory Committee wrote Rule 410 to give effect to this traditional characteristic of the plea, the avoidance of the admission of guilt that every guilty plea contains.21
The trade explains why the rule has no withdrawal condition. The nolo defendant is not trying to undo the plea, and the protection was part of what the plea offered at the outset. If protection required withdrawal, the defendant would have to give up the plea itself to keep it out of later cases, and the bargain the plea exists to offer would be unavailable. The plea is therefore the protected event, and nothing further has to happen to it.
A civil suit over the same events shows the difference most sharply. A guilty plea that was never withdrawn may be admitted against the pleader in a later action,22 while a nolo plea may not. A defendant who fears a victim’s civil claim therefore has a real alternative to a guilty plea, because the nolo plea avoids the effect of a recorded guilty plea on the impending civil case.23
The bar holds whatever theory the proponent offers. The plea cannot come in to prove the defendant’s guilt of the charged offense, and it cannot come in to show bias or for any other purpose either, which makes Rule 410 more restrictive than the parallel provisions on compromises and payments of medical expenses.24
Plea Hearing Statements
Rule 410(a)(3) extends the exclusion from the plea to what the defendant says while entering it. A statement made during a proceeding on a withdrawn guilty plea or on a nolo contendere plea, under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 11 or a comparable state procedure, is inadmissible against the defendant who made it.26 The audience for these statements is the court, not a prosecutor. Rule 410(a)(4), by contrast, protects statements made during discussions with an attorney for the prosecuting authority when those discussions produced no guilty plea or produced one later withdrawn,27 and that difference in audience is what separates the two subdivisions.
The hearing is where the defendant speaks. Before entering judgment on a guilty plea, the court must determine that the plea has a factual basis.28 If the court later permits the defendant to withdraw the plea, giving the defendant a fresh start requires denying the government the use of the statements made at the formal plea hearing as well as the plea itself.29 Excluding the plea under Rule 410(a)(1) would accomplish little if the jury could still hear the account the defendant gave at the hearing, which is the same confession in fuller detail.
The reasoning for a nolo plea is similar, but the protection reaches further. The consequences of a nolo plea are meant to stop at the case in which it is entered, so statements made at the hearing must also stay out of any later case. That holds whether or not the nolo plea was later withdrawn.30 The phrase either of those pleas in the text therefore carries an asymmetry: a hearing on a guilty plea is covered only if the plea was later withdrawn, while a hearing on a nolo plea is covered regardless.
A stem that quotes a defendant’s sworn description of the offense at a plea hearing raises one question: what became of the plea afterward?
If the court had accepted the plea and the defendant had never withdrawn it, the same words would carry no protection. A guilty plea that stands, together with the statements made in offering it to the court and having it accepted, is admissible as an admission.31 A civil plaintiff who later sues the defendant over the same events may therefore offer the hearing statements, because subdivision (a)(3) reaches only hearings on withdrawn guilty pleas and on nolo pleas.
Even the protected statements carry two exceptions, and impeachment is not one of them. A hearing statement is admissible in a prosecution for perjury or false statement if the defendant made it under oath, on the record, and in the presence of counsel, under Rule 410(b)(2).32 Rule 11 itself flags that exposure, listing the government’s right, in a prosecution for perjury or false statement, to use against the defendant any statement the defendant gives under oath.33 Under Rule 410(b)(1), a hearing statement is also admissible in any proceeding in which another statement from the same plea or plea discussions has been introduced and fairness requires that the two be considered together. No “fruit of the poisonous tree” doctrine extends the exclusion to evidence derived from a protected statement.34