Concept
Discovery and Mediation Limits
Compromise offers and negotiations
Discovery and Mediation Limits
Rule 408(a) is a rule about admissibility. It makes compromise evidence 'not admissible,' on behalf of any party, either to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim or to impeach by a prior inconsistent statement or a contradiction.1 Admissibility asks one question: may a factfinder consider this item at trial? A rule that answers it says nothing about whether the item can be demanded in discovery, subpoenaed by a stranger to the case, or repeated outside the courtroom. Rule 408 limits what may be proved at trial, and a lawyer who treats it as a shield against disclosure is asking it to do work its text does not assign.
Rule 408 is also not a privilege. A privilege protects a communication, and its holder can refuse to disclose it or block testimony about it, whatever the evidence would be used for. Rule 408 forbids two uses, and subdivision (b) expressly lets the court admit the same evidence for another purpose, such as proving a witness's bias or prejudice, negating a contention of undue delay, or proving an effort to obstruct a criminal investigation or prosecution.2 A privilege is defined by what it protects. Rule 408 is defined by the inference the evidence invites.
The O'Hagan case shows that use-based logic at work. A financial statement connected to an SEC investigation was offered to show that O'Hagan could not repay the 'borrowed' funds at any and all times. It was not offered to prove the validity of any SEC claim, and its relevance did not depend on any inference that the SEC, in an entirely different case, might have a valid civil claim against him. The jury was never told of the investigation, and the court held that admitting the statement was not error.3 The court asked what inference the document required, and who created it or why did not matter.
Discovery asks a wider question than trial admissibility. The text of Rule 408 speaks only to admissibility, so a party who resists a request for settlement material cannot win by reciting that the material would be inadmissible. Courts resolving the dispute weigh the requester's need against the interest in keeping settlements confidential, and they may count the likelihood that discovery will lead to relevant evidence as a reason to allow it.4
Kalinauskas v. Wong shows the weighing. A litigant sought to depose Ms. Thomas and to discover documents created in her own case. The court allowed the discovery. Among its reasons, the deposition was likely to lead to relevant evidence, and preventing it, or preventing discovery of the documents from her case, could lead to wasteful efforts to generate discovery that already existed.5 The confidentiality interest was weighed in the analysis, and it did not end it.
The gap between trial and discovery matters most in mediation. Mediation, like negotiation, is a means of discovery in litigation, so lawyers guard against revealing anything that could come back to haunt them or their clients if the mediation fails and the litigation continues. They are especially guarded with the other side and are often hesitant even with the mediator.6 A rule that operates only at trial does little to ease that caution, because whatever was disclosed can still be sought before trial. Protection therefore has to come from sources outside Rule 408: a contract, a court order, or whatever mediation-confidentiality law the forum supplies, which a lawyer must check separately.
A confidentiality agreement is a contract, and a contract binds only those who signed it. It does not stop a non-party from serving a subpoena in a different case. A protective order is a different instrument because a court issues it. Umbrella protective orders are regularly issued and presumptively cover all material the disclosing party deems confidential. When that material is filed with the court or introduced into evidence, the order typically requires that it be filed under seal, and a party who breaches the order is in contempt of court. Even so, a subpoena in another case can sometimes overcome the order if the party seeking the discovery shows a substantial need or that the order was improvidently granted in the first action.7
The two scenes involve the same dispute and the same documents, and the answers differ because the questions differ. The first asks whether a statement may be used to prove liability at trial, which is Rule 408's question. The second asks whether material must be handed over before any trial, which Rule 408 leaves to the discovery rules and to whatever agreements, orders, and privileges exist. The usual error is to answer a discovery question by reciting that settlement evidence is inadmissible. The reverse error is to assume that because discovery succeeded, the material can be used at trial to prove liability, which subdivision (a) still forbids.