Concept
Privileges and Truth-Seeking
Other privileges
Rule 501 and Other Privileges
Privileges and Truth-Seeking
Nearly every rule of evidence you have studied so far serves one aim: accurate fact-finding. The hearsay rule screens out statements that cross-examination cannot test. The opinion rule keeps out conclusions a witness has no basis to draw. The character rule guards against a verdict built on prejudice, and the original-document rule demands the writing itself when its contents matter. Each excludes evidence that is unreliable or likely to mislead, and each thereby advances the object of the witness’s oath: the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.1
A privilege runs the other way. It permits a person to withhold relevant information for reasons wholly unconnected with the quality of the evidence or the credibility of the witness, because the law wishes to protect an interest or relationship.2 Privileges exist not because of their effect on fact-finding but in spite of it. The usual justification is some goal outside the litigation, most often protection of a relationship thought to be socially beneficial and to require confidentiality.3 The price is paid in the courtroom: probative evidence is suppressed, the trier decides the facts without it, and the probability of an erroneous outcome rises.4
Federal Rule of Evidence 501 governs privilege in federal court, and it does so by pointing outward. The common law, as United States courts interpret it “in the light of reason and experience,” controls a privilege claim unless the Constitution, a federal statute, or rules prescribed by the Supreme Court provide otherwise. In a civil case, state law governs privilege for any claim or defense on which state law supplies the rule of decision.5 The Advisory Committee did draft thirteen privilege rules, and the Court promulgated them, yet privilege remains the most significant area of evidence law not codified in the Rules.6
Why pay that price? The most widely accepted answer is utilitarian: confidential communications are socially desirable, and people would make fewer of them if the law did not protect them. Applied to the lawyer-client relationship, the argument is that society as a whole benefits when people consult lawyers more often.7 The benefit, however, is hard to measure, while the cost shows up in every trial where a privilege applies. Consider the privilege for confidential communications between spouses. Its immediate purpose is to encourage spouses to talk, and whether it does so is uncertain. Privileges generally rest on unproven assumptions, some highly probable and others highly problematic.8
Because the cost is certain and the benefit conjectural, the law confines each privilege to the setting that justifies it. A privilege should be recognized only if the interest or relationship is of outstanding importance and would undoubtedly be harmed by denying protection.9 The policy behind a privilege also marks where it stops. Communications that facilitate a further crime or fraud receive no attorney-client protection, because none of the purposes of the attorney-client relationship supports secrecy when the object is crime or fraud, and the need for that information is correspondingly great.10 Each privilege in the rest of this chapter is best studied with three questions in mind: what relationship it protects, what policy the protection serves, and where that policy runs out.
Privileges also operate before trial. They are not just rules of admissibility; they govern whether disclosure can be compelled at all, and they most often arise as an objection to a grand jury subpoena or a civil discovery request, not as an objection to testimony at trial.11 Federal discovery accordingly reaches only matter that is “not privileged.”12 A party who resists discovery on this ground must say so expressly. Rule 26(b)(5) requires it to describe the withheld documents, communications, or things in a way that lets the other parties assess the claim without revealing the protected information.13 Toyota, for instance, may refuse to produce Document 112 by stating in writing that the document is a confidential communication from its General Counsel to its president, dated October 12, 2020, prepared during and in furtherance of the lawyer-client relationship.14 The right to make such a claim belongs exclusively to the holder, the person for whom the privilege was created. A holder who is a party to the litigation is conveniently placed to assert it.15
The attorney-client privilege shields communications and leaves facts exposed. In Upjohn Co. v. United States the Court drew the line this way: a client cannot be compelled to answer “What did you say or write to the attorney?” but may not refuse to disclose a relevant fact within the client’s knowledge merely because the client put that fact into a communication with counsel.16 The Government there remained free to question the employees who had spoken with the company’s lawyers, and the IRS had already interviewed some 25 of them. Convenience did not entitle it to subpoena the questionnaires and notes that the company’s attorneys had taken instead.17
A simpler example shows both sides of the line. A client tells a lawyer, “I knocked down a telephone pole while I was driving my red car.” At trial, no one may ask the client what the client told the lawyer about the pole and the car. The privilege does not block “Did you knock down a telephone pole?” or “What color is your car?” It protects the private statement to the lawyer, and the facts remain open to any question that does not call for that statement.18
A privilege must also be kept distinct from a professional’s ethical duty of confidentiality. Without a privilege, a professional called as a witness may have to disclose a client’s or patient’s confidences, whatever the ethical standards and whatever assurance the professional gave.19 For that reason practitioners take care not to promise confidentiality in court proceedings beyond what privilege law covers, and ethical codes usually allow disclosure when the law or a court order requires it. See, e.g., ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.6(b)(6); AMA Principles of Medical Ethics IV (2001). A practitioner who insists on confidentiality broader than the privileges protect risks being held in contempt of court.20 A privilege, and not an ethics code, is what excuses a witness from answering.