Concept
Waiver of the Privilege
Attorney-client privilege
Waiver of the Privilege
A client can lose the attorney-client privilege in two ways: by revealing the confidence, or by making a claim or defense that depends on it. Waiver may rest on words or conduct that express an intent to give up a known right. It may also rest on conduct, such as a partial disclosure, that would make it unfair for the client to invoke the privilege afterward, even though the client never meant to forfeit it.1 Some authorities explain the second ground by the privilege's function: it protects a confidence, and once any means has revealed the confidence, the privilege has no legitimate work left to do.2 Most authority nonetheless requires that a disclosure be at least voluntary, since letting theft or fraud overthrow the privilege would be poor policy.3
Voluntary disclosure shows the rule at its simplest, so it comes first. Implied waiver follows, because there the client gives up the privilege without revealing anything.
Voluntary Disclosure
A client waives the privilege by voluntarily disclosing any significant part of the covered matter outside the confidential attorney-client relationship, unless the disclosure is itself privileged.4 The rule follows from the conditions of the privilege. The client must preserve the communication's confidentiality after making it,5 and a client who passes the substance to an outsider has stopped doing so.
Each key word in the rule limits it. Outside the relationship ties waiver to the circle of confidence drawn in the earlier discussion of confidentiality. Significant ties waiver to substance. In In re Kellogg, Brown, & Root, Inc., 796 F.3d 139 (D.C. Cir. 2015) (Kellogg II), a footnote reference to an internal investigation in the factual summary of a summary judgment motion did not waive the privilege, and the court granted mandamus to protect it.6 The court warned that if noticing a deposition about an investigation were enough to defeat the privilege, such end-runs would appear in every lawsuit involving a prior internal investigation.7 Counsel must still handle privileged investigation materials in outside litigation with care.8 Voluntary carries two limits of its own, taken up below.
A waiver that does occur normally reaches beyond the setting where it happened. It holds for all time, for all purposes, in all proceedings, and as to all people who might seek the information, though some authority dissents in limited circumstances.9 Confidentiality is either intact or gone, and the law does not divide a waiver by audience. That premise drives the selective-waiver problem below.
The line between waiver and no waiver falls between the barber and the spouse. A client who repeats a lawyer's advice to a barber waives the privilege. A client who repeats it to a spouse in a confidential conversation does not, because that conversation is itself protected by the spousal confidences privilege.10 Disclosure in a context protected by another privilege does not result in waiver.11 The listener's trustworthiness decides nothing. A barber who is a close friend remains an outsider, and the only question is whether the recipient stands inside the confidential circle or inside a relationship the law protects independently.
Voluntariness supplies the second limit. If an erroneous court order compels the disclosure, the disclosure is involuntary and the privilege is not waived, and the protection is restored if the order is set aside or reversed.12 Compelled disclosure does not result in waiver.13 Waiver rests on the holder's choice to give up secrecy, and a client who answers a court's command has made no such choice. If compliance destroyed the privilege, a client could keep it only by defying the court, and a reversal on appeal would restore nothing.
Had the same client volunteered the same account to a reporter, with no court compelling anything, she would have disclosed a significant part of the communication to an outsider and waived the privilege. The words are identical. Only the client's choice differs.
A lawyer's act can also waive, because the lawyer acts as the client's agent. Although it is commonly said that only the client can waive, an intentional disclosure by the attorney binds the client unless the client expressly forbade it.14 The lawyer's authority may be implied, and a client who fails to stop a disclosure she knows of ratifies it.15 Another source approaches the point from the opposite end: a lawyer who discloses a privileged communication without the client's express or implied consent effects no waiver, and the privilege can still keep the communication out of evidence at trial.16 Both statements turn on whether the lawyer had authority, express or implied, to speak for the client. A mistaken disclosure by the lawyer is a separate category. It can waive even when the client would have opposed it, and Rule 502(b) supplies the governing standard, which the next section takes up.17
A corporation acts through people, so the question of who can waive for it follows management's authority. Management operates as the holder of the privilege, and in placing employees where they can make disclosures that reveal privileged communications, management assumes the risk that their actions will produce a waiver.18 When an officer appears to represent the corporation in giving grand jury testimony, his disclosure of privileged material may be attributed to the corporation.19 The authority question echoes the one the control-group test asked at the privilege stage, a test the earlier discussion rejected: whether the officer is vested with authority both to seek legal advice for the corporation and to participate significantly in its response to counsel's recommendations.20 The layered structure of a large corporation adds a complication, because counsel's advice may be widely shared inside it, which is one reason the confidentiality requirement meshes poorly with corporate clients.21 The earlier discussion of need-to-know confidentiality draws the line between sharing inside the corporation and disclosing outside it.
Selective waiver tests the rule that disclosure to anyone waives as to everyone. A corporation under government investigation has a law firm prepare a confidential internal report, then hands the report to the investigating agency to earn credit for cooperating. The corporation chose to disclose, so the disclosure was voluntary. Private plaintiffs then sue the corporation and demand the same report. The question is whether the waiver ran only to the agency.
Under the general rule, it ran to everyone, because a waiver holds for all proceedings and as to all people who might seek the information.22 Selective waiver, the claim that disclosure to one party waives only as to that party, is available, if at all, through a court order under Rule 502(d), taken up later in this chapter.23 Without such an order, the plaintiffs may reach the report. The Eighth Circuit went the other way in Diversified Industries v. Meredith, 572 F.2d 596 (8th Cir. 1977), which held that surrender of privileged documents to the SEC under an agency subpoena did not waive the privilege as to third parties.24 That decision is contrary authority, not the general rule. An exam answer should treat voluntary cooperation with a government agency as a waiver against the world unless a Rule 502(d) order says otherwise.
Implied Waiver
A client can lose the privilege without revealing any part of a confidential communication, by making a claim or defense that puts the content of the communications at issue.28 Waiver occurs when the client engages in conduct inconsistent with confidentiality,29 and conduct that would make it unfair for the client to invoke the privilege afterward is enough.30 Voluntary disclosure waives because the client broke the confidence. Implied waiver waives because the case cannot fairly be tried while the client relies on communications the opponent cannot examine.
The privilege works as a shield, and a client who points to what the lawyer said as a reason to win is using the same communications as a sword. A litigant who could cite the favorable advice and withhold the rest would give the factfinder an account the opponent could never test.
The classic application is the defense that the client relied on the advice of counsel. A client who asserts that defense waives the privilege.31 In Nguyen v. Excel Corp., 197 F.3d 200 (5th Cir. 1999), the Fifth Circuit held that reliance on an advice-of-counsel defense waives the privilege for communications pertinent to the defense.32 A client who takes the stand and testifies about communications with a lawyer “in an attempt to secure some advantage by reason of transactions between himself and his counsel” opens the same door, because the other side may then call the lawyer to give his account of the matter.33 Voluntary disclosure of a privileged communication's contents, at least when offered to the client's advantage in a judicial proceeding, may waive the privilege as to all other communications on the same subject.34
The sword-and-shield idea has a boundary: the client's own claim or defense must put the content of the communications at issue.35 Consulting a lawyer about the subject of a lawsuit does not do that. A litigant who defends on other facts has revealed nothing and relied on nothing, so the advice stays protected. This boundary also fits the privilege's purpose of encouraging laypeople to obtain legal advice.36 If every communication relevant to the subject of a suit became discoverable, a client could not know, when speaking to the lawyer, whether some later claim would expose the conversation.
The company consulted counsel about the same termination in both versions, so the subject matter does not separate them. What separates them is whether the defense leans on the advice. An exam stem that mentions a consultation about the very events in suit is testing that line. How far a waiver reaches communications that were never disclosed is the subject of the later discussion of subject-matter waiver.
Disputes between lawyer and client supply a second recurring setting. A client who files a lawsuit claiming the lawyer was incompetent waives the privilege.37 The privilege is also sometimes waived by the assertion of a claim where the opposing party must use privileged communications to mount a defense, and in Ryers v. Burleson, 100 F.R.D. 436 (D.D.C. 1983), allegations of lawyer malpractice waived confidential communications under the circumstances.38 A client who attacks the lawyer's performance puts the representation in issue. Letting the client do that while silencing the lawyer would leave the lawyer to defend with both hands tied.
The same logic carries over to work product. As with the attorney-client privilege, a court will recognize an implicit waiver where the client seeks to make affirmative testimonial use of work product. In United States v. Nobles, 422 U.S. 225 (1975), a party's investigator testified about his recollection of witness interviews, and the opposing party became entitled to the work-product documents recounting those interviews.39