Concept
Applying the Privilege
Spousal immunity
Applying the Privilege
A spousal-witness problem comes apart cleanly when you ask its questions in a fixed order, because each answer decides whether the next question matters. The earlier sections of this chapter supplied the questions: which forum and proceeding allow the privilege, which privilege the objection invokes, who holds it, whether a marriage exists, what testimony the privilege reaches, and whether an exception removes the witness from it. Asked out of order, they invite the commonest error on this topic: a one-line answer that spousal immunity applies or does not, which merges two privileges that run on different clocks. Asked in order, they let you stop at the first answer that settles the issue.
The sequence starts with the forum because courts draw their privilege law from different sources. In federal court the common law, as interpreted by United States courts in the light of reason and experience, governs a claim of privilege, except that in a civil case state law governs privilege on a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.5 A federal criminal trial therefore applies the federal common law that Trammel shaped, a state criminal trial applies the state's own statute or decisions, and a federal diversity suit on a state-law claim borrows the state's privilege rules. A civil forum ordinarily removes the testimonial privilege and leaves the communications privilege to be analyzed.
The two privileges also work differently at trial. The testimonial privilege, when it applies, keeps the witness-spouse off the stand altogether, while the communications privilege is claimed selectively as the testimony proceeds.6 The testimonial privilege also has no application when a spouse is called to give favorable testimony, and a spouse who testifies for the party on direct is cross-examined like any other witness: any question within the scope of the direct that calls for adverse testimony is allowed.7
The order of the steps follows the reasons behind each requirement. The modern justification for the testimonial privilege is that it fosters the harmony and sanctity of the marriage,8 and the privilege looks forward to the particular marriage at hand, guarding against the impact of the testimony on that marriage.9 That is why the court asks whether a marriage exists on the day testimony is demanded, and it fits that the spouse whose marriage is at stake, not the defendant, decides whether to invoke the privilege. The communications privilege looks the other way. It exists so that spouses, before any involvement in crime or in a trial, feel free to share their deepest feelings without fear of exposure in court,10 which is why the court asks about the marriage on the day of the statement. The exceptions come last because they matter only for a witness who would otherwise hold the privilege.
A marriage that follows an arrest invites the argument that it is a sham. A judge convinced that the marriage is a ruse can declare the privilege inapplicable, but the artificial nature of a marriage is not always easy to discern; in one case the newlyweds had lived together for two years before the proceedings began and they married.13 A scattering of federal decisions avoids the sham problem by denying the privilege when the conduct under questioning predated the marriage. That minority approach erodes the privilege's purpose, because it sets against each other spouses who are lawfully married, perhaps for many years, at the time of trial.14 In a court that follows it, Anne's refusal would fail because Henry's conduct predated the wedding.
Reversing the order of events reverses the result.
Divorce ends the testimonial privilege because no marriage remains for the testimony to strain, yet it leaves the communications privilege in place because the candor that privilege protects was extended while the marriage lasted. The communications privilege has limits of its own, though. A court may deny it to spouses who were still technically married but living separate lives with no reasonable expectation of reconciliation when they spoke, since there was no marital harmony to promote.18 A confidence given after a breakup therefore needs a separate look at the state of the marriage on the day of the statement.
The same reasoning answers the familiar exam question in which a prosecutor asks a willing ex-wife to testify that the defendant confessed to her while they were married. Her willingness resolves only the testimonial privilege, and that privilege ended with the marriage. The confession is inadmissible if the defendant made it in confidence during the marriage, since either spouse may assert that privilege.19 It comes in if a third person was present or likely to overhear,20 or if the spouses had permanently separated.21
Two shorter problems resolve quickly once the sequence is applied. Mickey is on trial in federal court, and the prosecutor calls his wife, Minnie, to repeat a conversation she overheard between Mickey and Donald. The communications privilege covers words and acts intended as a communication, and only confidential ones, meaning those not made in the presence of, or likely to be overheard by, third parties.22 Mickey's words to Donald were not meant for Minnie, and Donald was a third party, so only the testimonial privilege is live, and it is Minnie's. If she chooses to testify, Mickey's objection fails, just as it would if a wife repeated her husband's boast made at a dinner her sister attended.23 If she refuses, she may stay off the stand, and the same facts produce the opposite outcome.
Doug is charged with beating the couple's young daughter, and his wife, validly married to him, refuses to testify. Steps one through four all favor her: a federal criminal trial, adverse testimony, a valid marriage, and a privilege she holds. Step five defeats her. The testimonial privilege is uniformly denied when the accused is charged with a crime against the witness-spouse or their children, so the prosecutor can call even a reluctant spouse and require testimony on pain of contempt.24 Change the charge to tax evasion and the exception drops out; she may then refuse to take the stand.