Concept
What the Privilege Protects
Spousal immunity
Spousal Immunity
What the Privilege Protects
A spouse who is called as an adverse witness in a criminal case against the other spouse may refuse to testify, whatever the subject of the testimony.1 Since Trammel v. United States, the right to refuse belongs to the witness-spouse. In the federal system and most states the witness-spouse is the sole holder, free to claim the privilege or waive it.2
The privilege therefore cuts both ways. An unwilling spouse cannot be forced onto the stand: if a wife is accused of bank robbery, her husband may refuse to testify against her, and the prosecutor cannot compel him. If he is willing, he may testify, and she cannot prevent it.3 What she may be able to invoke is a different privilege, the one for confidential communications, which reaches private communications between spouses (and perhaps some behavior in private settings) during the marriage.4 The sections that follow explain how the rule reached this form and why the witness, rather than the accused, holds it.
The privilege travels under several names: the adverse testimonial privilege, the privilege against adverse spousal testimony, and the antimarital-facts privilege.5 The looser labels spousal privilege and husband–wife privilege cover every sense of the term, including a privilege that immunizes statements between husband and wife from a defamation suit, so a reference to the spousal privilege needs context.6 This chapter concerns only the testimonial privilege, and it brings in the communications privilege only for contrast.
Common law and most modern statutes recognize two related but distinct spousal privileges. One bars adverse spousal testimony; the other protects spousal confidences.7 The testimonial privilege is broader in one respect. It blocks all testimony by one spouse against the other, including accounts of premarital acts or events, while the confidences privilege excludes only testimony about private communications between spouses during the marriage.8 In another respect it is narrower. It applies only if the spouses are married when the testimony is sought, whereas the confidences privilege is usually said to protect the interval of the marriage forever, even after the marriage ends.9 The two privileges also have different holders: the witness-spouse holds the testimonial privilege, and at a minimum the communicating spouse holds the communications privilege.10
Courts keep the two apart. In United States v. Picciandra a defendant invoked the confidential marital communications privilege to keep his former wife off the stand, and the First Circuit described that privilege as separate and distinct from the witness-spouse's privilege to refuse to testify against the other spouse.11
The privilege reaches observations as well as conversations because of its purpose. It grew out of considerations of marital harmony and privacy,12 and those concerns arise whenever one spouse must testify against the other, whether or not the spouses ever shared a confidence. The privilege also works differently from a communications privilege. Where it applies, it keeps the witness-spouse off the witness stand altogether, so no one has to sort protected answers from unprotected ones.13 A privilege limited to confidential communications, by contrast, leaves the spouse free to testify about everything else.14
Four conditions must be met before a spouse can claim the testimonial privilege:
All four conditions are met in that scene, and nothing in the analysis asks whether Husband ever confided in Wife. The privilege does not depend on a private conversation, because it blocks all testimony by one spouse against the other, including accounts of acts and events.18
Change one fact, and the result changes with it. The privilege is defined by reference to a criminal case,19 so it ordinarily does not follow the spouse into a civil courtroom.
The marriage, the testimony, and the damage to Husband are exactly as before. Only the third condition has failed. Three questions organize what follows: whether a spouse can be compelled to testify, who controls the privilege, and whether a valid marriage must exist when the testimony is sought.