Concept
Other Rule 901(b) Methods
Real, demonstrative, and experimental evidence
Other Rule 901(b) Methods
The first method on Rule 901(b)'s list is the plainest: a person able to identify the item testifies that it is what the proponent claims it is.1 The other nine illustrations reach the same conclusion by other routes. Rule 901(b) offers all ten as examples only, not as a complete list,2 because any proof that could support the required finding is allowed.3 They serve a single standard: the proponent must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is.4
Because the methods are tools, a proponent may combine them, and digital evidence shows how. A witness who visited a website can authenticate a printout by testifying that it accurately reflects what the witness saw. A chat-room conversation can be tied to a party by details only that party could have known. A computer-generated distance measurement can be authenticated by showing that the computer calculated the real distance at the correct scale.5 Each showing draws on a different example in the rule, and none ends the inquiry, because an authenticated item must still satisfy the rules on hearsay and original writings.6
The nine remaining methods sort into three families by what ties the item to its source. Some let the item point to its source through its appearance, contents, and internal patterns. Some identify a person as the writer of a document, the speaker on a recording, or the party who answered a call. The third group rests on the place or process that produced the item: a public office, twenty years of age, an accurate system, or a statute. The sorting follows the kind of item. A unique item, such as a person's handwriting, can be recognized or compared. A generic item, such as a telephone call to a number, a public record, or an old document, has to be connected to its source through circumstances.7 The unit takes the families in that order.
Distinctive Characteristics
Rule 901(b)(4) authenticates an item by its appearance, contents, substance, internal patterns, or other distinctive characteristics, taken together with all the circumstances.8 The method needs no witness who saw the item made. The item carries its own clues, and a reasonable juror can reason from them to a source: a letter that mentions things only its supposed author would know, an email written in a recognizable manner, a bulb found where only a few people could have left it.
The method works because some features are costly to counterfeit. A detail that few people knew narrows the field of possible authors, each further detail narrows it more, and a forger would have to know every one. A feature that anyone can copy narrows nothing. Most decisions in this area apply that contrast.
United States v. Siddiqui shows the method at full strength. In a trial for submitting fraudulent recommendations for an NSF award, emails from the defendant were authenticated by several facts together: they displayed knowledge of actions only he had, apologized for conduct only he engaged in, came from his email address, were signed with his distinctive nickname, and were referred to by him in phone conversations.9 No single feature carried the showing. The contents counted because outside facts, such as the sending address, the nickname, and his own references to the emails, stood beside them.
Courts reason the same way when they sum up the proof. In United States v. Bagaric, the Second Circuit agreed with Chief Judge Motley that the record amply demonstrated that a letter was what the government claimed, a letter from Miro Baresic to Vinko Logarusic.10 Stylistic habits count as internal patterns. In United States v. Larson, the court admitted evidence that the defendant had misspelled “approach” as “approuch” three times in one ransom note and had done the same in an earlier letter to the Pardon Board.11
The method is not limited to writings. In one accident case, a witness believed, with some reservations, that a bulb found in a cabinet was the bulb in question, because broken bulbs were not kept, so its presence must have had a specific purpose. Only six people had access to the area where the accident occurred and to the cabinet where the bulb was found. The plaintiff stated that two weeks before the accident he had installed General Electric bulbs in the sockets where he was working and that, to the best of his knowledge, no other brand had ever been used in them.12 A generic object took on an identity from where it was found, who could reach it, and its brand, all read together.
A feature that anyone can supply cannot carry the showing alone. A signature or a recital of authorship on the face of a writing is not enough, because the law of evidence does not adopt the everyday assumption that a document is what it says it is. The writing may have been fabricated to create a claim, and a name may be attributed to someone who merely shares it.13 The quantum of proof appears to exceed what a reasonable person would require in daily life, in part because falsification is more likely in connection with trials.14
Letterhead occupies the middle ground. Courts traditionally refused to authenticate a writing from its letterhead, but more modern decisions accept letterhead as at least a partial basis. In United States v. Gordon, the First Circuit admitted documents that appeared on their face to come from the defendant, because the name, title, address, and telephone number on them matched his. In United States v. Hassanshahi, a letter was authenticated in part because it bore the letterhead of the defendant's company and a signature block with his name.15 Letterhead contributes to a showing; it does not complete one.
The second version of that scene applies the reply doctrine. When testimony shows that a call or other communication went to a particular person or business, a communication that appears to answer it is treated as authenticated as coming from that recipient.16 The doctrine works because a reply speaks to the contents of the first message, which ordinarily only the recipient, or those the recipient told, would know. The reply's own content is the distinctive characteristic, and the proven first message is the circumstance that gives it force.
Electronic items follow the same logic. A social-media post is authenticated by evidence about the log-in and password used, or by something in the post, such as a nickname or an endearment, that links it to the person said to have made it.17
Meeting the rule does not prove that the item is genuine. The judge asks only whether the combined evidence would let a reasonable jury find that the item is what the proponent claims, and the jury then decides whether it is genuine. A jury that decides the letter did not come from its claimed author will disregard the letter, because an item has probative value only if it is what its proponent says it is.18
Handwriting, Voice, and Calls
Four of the remaining examples answer one question about a person: who wrote this, whose voice is on this recording, who answered the call? The name signed at the bottom of a document does not answer it, because the law does not assume that a writing came from the person it names.20 Each method supplies proof that links the person to the item.
Rule 901(b)(2) allows a nonexpert's opinion that handwriting is genuine, if the opinion rests on a familiarity with it that was not acquired for the current litigation.21 The timing limit tracks what makes a lay opinion worth hearing. A witness who absorbed a person's handwriting through ordinary life, before anyone cared whether a particular document was genuine, has a familiarity that is hard to fake; a spouse who recognizes the other spouse's writing is the standard example.22 Familiarity built after the dispute began is different. A lawyer can show a witness chosen specimens until the witness seems to know the writing, and the resulting opinion reflects what counsel chose to display. The limit keeps a party from manufacturing a witness, and cross-examination tests the rest by asking how often, and in what settings, the witness saw the writing.
When no witness has that lay familiarity, Rule 901(b)(3) allows a comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness or the trier of fact.23 The specimen must itself be authenticated, through circumstantial evidence or through a witness who can say it is what it is claimed to be.24 A comparison shows only that two writings look alike, so the resemblance tells the jury something about the questioned writing only if the specimen really came from the claimed author. Proof of the specimen may come from the signer, from someone who watched the signing, or from anyone with some minimal acquaintance with the signature, and jurors may be shown a proven sample to compare for themselves.25 An expert may testify that a writing is by a particular person only if the samples the expert relies on are themselves authenticated.26
The maid and the adjuster differ in when and why each came to know the writing, and that difference decides whether a lay opinion is available at all.
Voice identification, which the rule lists with handwriting among the unique-item methods, works on a looser clock.27 Rule 901(b)(5) allows an opinion identifying a person's voice, whether heard firsthand or through mechanical or electronic transmission or recording, based on hearing the voice at any time under circumstances that connect it with the alleged speaker. The text has no counterpart to the handwriting rule's exclusion of familiarity acquired for litigation; it demands only that the circumstances of hearing connect the voice with the speaker. Recognition is one way to make that connection, and a call can supply others: the caller reveals information the named person would likely know, shares a distinctive trait such as a stutter, or acts afterward as the named person would.28
Telephone calls add a problem of their own, because the speaker is unseen and may be a stranger. Rule 901(b)(6) responds with evidence that a call was made to the number assigned at the time to a particular person or business.29 For a person, the circumstances, including self-identification, must show that the person answering was the one called.30 For a business, the call must have been made to a business and must relate to business reasonably transacted over the telephone.31 The assigned number carries the weight. A witness who dialed a number assigned to a person has reason to think that person answered, and the answerer's self-identification or other circumstances confirm it.32 Incoming calls are harder. The recipient did not choose the number, so the caller's announced name stands alone. Unless something more connects the voice to the named person, such as recognition of the voice or information the named person would likely know, the recipient can say only that an unknown person claimed to be someone.33
Each of these methods needs only evidence from which a reasonable juror could make the finding, so the judge does not decide whether the writer, speaker, or caller really was the named person. If the showing is sufficient, the item comes in and the jury decides whether it is genuine. A jury that concludes it is not will disregard the item, because it has probative value only if it is what its proponent says it is.34
Records, Systems, and Statutes
The methods in this section authenticate an item through the place or process that produced it, not through someone who recognizes it. Rule 901(b)(7) shows the design most plainly. It names two showings: that a document was recorded or filed in a public office as authorized by law, or that a purported public record or statement is from the office where items of this kind are kept.37 A public office takes in, stores, and releases records under legal rules, so a document that surfaces where the law directs such documents to be kept has a source a reasonable juror can trust, though no witness watched it being made.
The two showings fit different documents. The first fits a paper that a private party lodges with an office, such as a deed, and the claim is that this paper is the one that was recorded or filed. The second fits what the office itself creates or keeps, such as an incident report, and the claim is that the item came from the office where such items are kept. Both kinds are generic, in the way chain-of-custody items are generic: a deed looks like thousands of others, so the place where it was kept does the identifying.38
Some items need no sponsor. Rule 902 makes trade inscriptions on commercial products, and newspapers and periodicals, self-authenticating,39 and Rule 902(10) does the same for a signature or document when a federal statute so provides.40 A document that is not self-authenticating is not presumed genuine; its proponent must produce evidence under Rule 901, and that evidence may be direct or circumstantial.41 Authentication settles only one hurdle, because a genuine record may still face the hearsay rule and the rules on original writings when it is offered for the truth of what it says.42
Rule 901(b)(8) lets age do the work that a witness cannot. For a document or data compilation, the proponent shows that it is in a condition that creates no suspicion about its authenticity,43 was in a place where, if authentic, it would likely be,44 and is at least 20 years old when offered.45 The three conditions answer different worries. Condition looks at the face of the item, since erasures or insertions raise the very suspicion this method needs absent. Place supplies circumstantial proof of custody: a will found among a family's papers has a natural explanation, and the same will found in a stranger's attic does not. Age is counted back from the day the document is offered, so a document that old was made long before the present lawsuit and is unlikely to have been prepared for it, and the people who saw it made are often unavailable. Age removes the usual motive to fabricate, and place and condition supply the circumstantial proof that a witness would otherwise have given.
A frequent error is to treat the twenty-year line as a fact the judge must find personally. The proponent carries only the sufficiency burden that governs all of Rule 901. A judge who privately believes that a document is younger than twenty years must still rule it authenticated when the proponent's evidence would support a finding that it is older, and the jury then decides the age dispute.46 The same limit applies to the other two conditions: the judge asks whether a reasonable juror could find no suspicious condition and a likely place, and the opponent remains free to argue the contrary to the jury.
Rule 901(b)(9) applies the same idea to machines. The proponent offers evidence describing a process or system and showing that it produces an accurate result.47 The rule has two parts, a description and a showing of accuracy, and a proponent who supplies only the first has named a source without vouching for it. When a machine produces the item, no person perceived what the machine recorded, so the system's demonstrated accuracy does the work that a witness's memory would otherwise do. A computer-generated distance measurement taken from a digital photograph shows the method: proof that the computer calculated the real distance according to the correct scale authenticates the figure.48
Process proof speaks to the machine's accuracy, not to which sample or item the machine read. When a machine analyzes a physical sample, the proponent may also need the chain of custody that ties the sample to its source, the same device used for any generic physical item.49
A computer simulation raises more questions than a measurement does. It is the work product of many out-of-court actors whose knowledge and beliefs affect its reliability: the sources of the factual basis, the sources of the scientific and technical formulae and the assumptions the programmers made, and the design, testing, selection, and operation of the program. Those sources can be tested through witnesses in court or under the rules on a testifying expert's opinion, Rules 702 and 703.50 A simulation therefore calls for testing of its inputs in addition to proof that the program runs accurately.
Rule 901(b)(10) closes the list by deferring to other law: any method of authentication or identification allowed by a federal statute or a rule prescribed by the Supreme Court.51 The provision supplies no method of its own. It confirms that the ten examples do not exhaust the ways of authenticating an item. A federal statute, for instance, treats the fact that a person's name is signed to a tax return as prima facie evidence that the person actually signed it, 26 U.S.C. § 6064, so a proponent who offers the return may rely on the statute instead of calling a witness to the signing.52 When none of the familiar methods fits, the sound question is whether a statute or court rule supplies one, and an answer should name the provision, because Rule 901(b)(10) is only the door and the statute or rule is the method.