Concept
Applying the Rule
Ultimate issue rule
Applying the Rule
Rule 704 contains one broad permission and one narrow prohibition, and exam errors come from blurring them. Subsection (a) removes a single objection: an opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue.1 Subsection (b) imposes the only categorical bar. In a criminal case, an expert witness must not state an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense, because those matters are for the trier of fact alone.2 The earlier sections explain what each subsection does and why. This section puts the checks in order, so that you neither treat (a) as a guarantee of admissibility nor stretch (b) to civil cases, lay witnesses, or facts that are not mental states.
Step 1 comes first because it is the only categorical test and takes a single reading of the question to apply. Step 2 removes an objection and nothing else, so an opinion that would not help the jury fails at step 3 whether or not anyone mentions the ultimate issue. In every case that clears step 1, step 3 carries the weight.
Only the type of proceeding changed between those two scenes, which is why step 1 asks about it first. A medical expert's opinion that embraces an ultimate issue draws no objection on that ground alone.7 An expert in a criminal case, by contrast, may not state conclusions about the defendant's mental state in connection with any required element of the charged crime.8 The criminal-case psychiatrist is not shut out of the courtroom. A mental-health expert may testify about definitions of mental states, symptoms, and diagnostic methods, and the testimony becomes improper only where it crosses a vague line into a specific statement about the crucial mental state at issue.9
The other two questions in step 1 sort cases the same way. A lay witness falls outside the bar because its text addresses only an expert witness, though that witness's opinion must still be rationally derived from perceptions and helpful.10 An expert's opinion on cause of death in a murder trial passes the third question, because cause of death is a physical fact and not a mental state. An expert's opinion that the defendant premeditated fails it.
The instinct that costs points on a civil stem runs the other way: ultimate-issue opinions are permitted, so any opinion on the main question must come in.
Both answers bear on the question the jury must decide, so step 2 cannot tell them apart. Step 3 can. The first answer gives the jury nothing to weigh and invites it to defer to a credentialed witness, and an opinion that simply takes sides is unhelpful for that reason.11 The second gives the jury a reasoned inference that cross-examination can test and the jury can accept or reject.
When a stem stacks several features, run the steps in order and stop at the first one that ends the analysis. An expert in a criminal case who states whether the defendant had an element-level mental state stops at step 1, although diagnosis, symptoms, and methods remain available. If any of the three facts is missing, the opinion moves on to steps 2 and 3.