Concept
Rule 414: Child Molestation Cases
Prior sexual misconduct of a defendant
Rule 414: Child Molestation Cases
Rule 414 is Rule 413 with a different charge. In a criminal case in which a defendant is accused of child molestation, the court may admit evidence that the defendant committed any other child molestation, and the evidence may be considered on any matter to which it is relevant.1 The closing phrase lifts the usual restriction on purpose, so a jury may reason from an earlier molestation to the likelihood that the defendant committed the charged one. That breaks with the traditional approach, under which a criminal defendant’s character stayed off-limits unless the defendant chose to make it admissible. In sex offense cases the rules no longer work that way.2
Because the structure is shared, the rest of the rule is easiest to learn by asking what changes when the category changes. The other subdivisions generally track their Rule 413 counterparts. Subdivision (b), for example, provides for the government’s notice and disclosure of other child molestation offenses that it intends to offer. In most respects Rule 414 is the mirror image of Rule 413, and the major difference is that Rule 413 applies to a charge of sexual assault while Rule 414 applies to a charge of child molestation.3 The changes therefore sit in two places: the same-type limit and the definitions.
The same-type limit comes first. In a prosecution for child molestation, the other-act evidence is limited to incidents of child molestation. Any other act of sexual misconduct, an assault on an adult for instance, must be analyzed under the traditional constraints of Rule 404(b).4 That routing costs the prosecutor the propensity inference. Rule 404(b) admits other crimes, wrongs, or acts only for a purpose other than proving character in order to show action in conformity with it, such as motive, opportunity, or intent.5
Subdivision (d) supplies two definitions that fix the edges of the rule.6 The first is an age line: a child is a person below the age of 14.7 The line is numerical, so it does not bend with a victim’s maturity. A thirteen-year-old is a child under the rule, and a fourteen-year-old is not. Reading the term to mean any minor is too broad.
The second definition is child molestation, which means a crime under federal law or under state law (with “state” defined in 18 U.S.C. § 513) involving any of six kinds of conduct.8
- (A) any conduct prohibited by 18 U.S.C. chapter 109A and committed with a child;9
- (B) any conduct prohibited by 18 U.S.C. chapter 110;10
- (C) contact between any part of the defendant’s body, or an object, and a child’s genitals or anus;11
- (D) contact between the defendant’s genitals or anus and any part of a child’s body;12
- (E) deriving sexual pleasure or gratification from inflicting death, bodily injury, or physical pain on a child; and13
- (F) an attempt or conspiracy to engage in conduct described in (A) through (E).14
The child runs through nearly every item. Category (A) reaches chapter 109A conduct only when it is committed with a child, and categories (C), (D), and (E) each name a child as the person touched or harmed. Contact is covered in both directions: an object or any part of the defendant’s body touching a child’s genitals or anus under (C), and the defendant’s own genitals or anus touching any part of a child’s body under (D). Category (F) adds attempts and conspiracies to the other five. The definition asks whether the conduct is a crime, and subdivision (a) asks whether the defendant committed another child molestation. Neither asks whether anyone charged or convicted him, a point a later section takes up.15
Two questions sort every Rule 414 problem. Is the charged offense child molestation? Is the other act child molestation as defined, with a victim below 14 and conduct within one of the six categories? If the answer to either question is no, Rule 414 does not apply, and other sexual misconduct goes to Rule 404(b). The usual exam error is to treat any sexual misconduct, or any victim under eighteen, as enough.