Concept
Rejecting the Propensity Ban
Prior sexual misconduct of a defendant
Prior Sexual Misconduct by Defendants
Rejecting the Propensity Ban
Rule 404 sets the baseline, and Rules 413, 414, and 415 break from it on purpose. Under Rule 404(a)(1), evidence of a person’s character or character trait is not admissible to prove that on a particular occasion the person acted in accordance with it.1 Rule 404(b)(1) carries the same ban over to other crimes, wrongs, or acts: the prosecution may not offer them to show a disposition, or propensity, to commit crimes.2
The ban blocks a specific chain of reasoning. Suppose a defendant on trial for robbing a liquor store has robbed gas stations several times and has a reputation as a thief. The rule bars the jury from using the reputation or the earlier robberies to infer that he is a thief and that he therefore robbed the liquor store.3 Two worries support the bar. Character is a vague concept, and its effect on any one act varies, so the gas station robberies may show less than they seem to.4 Character evidence also carries slight probative value and may be very prejudicial: it distracts the factfinder from what happened on the occasion in question and lets it reward the good person and punish the bad one because of their characters.5 The inference that the accused is a bad man deserving of punishment in any event is the one the rule is designed to avoid.6
Rule 413(a) reverses the bar for one kind of case. In a criminal case in which a defendant is accused of a sexual assault, the court may admit evidence that the defendant committed any other sexual assault, and the evidence may be considered on any matter to which it is relevant.7 The last clause carries the weight. Rule 413(a) admits a collateral sexual assault “on any matter to which it is relevant,” including propensity.8 The jury may therefore draw the very inference Rule 404 forbids. Rules 413 through 415 are the provisions that permit evidence of a defendant’s past sex offense to support an inference that the defendant committed another offense of that type.9
The exception reaches only offenses of the same type as the one charged. Rule 413 addresses only sexual assault prosecutions, so it lets in only other sexual assault crimes. It would not admit a prior sexual assault against a defendant on trial for homicide or armed robbery, and it would not admit a dissimilar offense such as a criminal battery against a defendant on trial for sexual assault. Rule 404(b) governs those settings, or Rules 608 and 609 when the evidence is offered to impeach.10 Even under Rule 404(b)(2), other-act evidence may come in for a purpose other than propensity, such as motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, or absence of mistake.11
Rule 414 makes the same move for child molestation. In a criminal case in which the defendant is accused of child molestation, the court may admit evidence that the defendant committed any other child molestation, and the evidence may be considered on any matter to which it is relevant.12 Rule 415 extends the idea to civil litigation. In a civil case involving a claim for relief based on a party’s alleged sexual assault or child molestation, the court may admit evidence that the party committed any other sexual assault or child molestation, to be considered as provided in Rules 413 and 414.13 The extension matters because circumstantial use of character is otherwise barred in civil cases, with narrow exceptions, and Rule 415 is one of them.14
These rules sit beside Rule 412, and the two groups point in opposite directions. Rule 412 is essentially an exclusionary rule for evidence of a victim’s sexual behavior or predisposition; Rules 413 through 415 are essentially inclusionary rules for evidence of a defendant’s sexual behavior or predisposition.15 Rule 412 is a rape shield law. It precludes a criminal defendant from introducing evidence of the victim’s past sexual behavior, which may have some logical relevance to consent.16 The shield guards against two errors: treating a victim of supposedly low moral character as someone who was “asking” for sex, and overvaluing past sexual activity by inferring present consent from past consent.17 When a sexual-misconduct problem arises, ask whose history is being offered. The victim’s history presumptively stays out; the defendant’s history of the same type of offense may come in.