Concept
Character of a Witness
Admissibility of character
Character of a Witness
A witness who takes the stand puts her own honesty in issue. The jury must decide whether to believe her account, and that account is itself conduct: her testimonial conduct at trial.1 Rule 404(a)(3) accordingly supplies a third exception to the propensity bar. Evidence of a witness's character may be admitted under Rules 607, 608, and 609.2 The subdivision does not say how the proof is made. It hands that question to the credibility rules, which control who may attack a witness, in what form, and when the witness may be defended.
This exception is not confined to criminal cases, as the exceptions in subdivision (a)(2) are. The rules of impeachment and rehabilitation apply, with minor variations, in civil and criminal trials alike.3 Nobody has to open the door with character evidence first, because taking the stand is enough to put truthfulness in issue.4
The inference here is the one Rule 404(a) forbids elsewhere. A witness with an untruthful character may be acting in accordance with that character while she testifies.5 Commentators offer three reasons to allow the inference for witnesses. Some see a particularly strong link between past lying and present lying. Others point out that a witness's veracity is a highly important issue and that the data used to prove it are likely to be accurate and quick and clear to establish. And it would be anomalous for a witness with serious past convictions to appear before a jury and benefit from its likely assumption that she has no record.6 The rule has a cost, and defendants bear it: because a jury may learn of past wrongdoing, many defendants are deterred from testifying in their own defense.7
The exception comes with stringent limits. Inquiry into a witness's character carries the familiar dangers of misleading the jury, confusion, unfair prejudice, and wasted time under Rule 403. It adds a danger peculiar to witnesses, because heavy scrutiny may make people reluctant to come forward and testify.8 The credibility rules answer with a single trait, truthfulness, and with controls on the sequence and form of proof. The full mechanics belong to the later treatment of impeachment and rehabilitation, so a preview of each rule's shape is enough here:
- Rule 607 lets any party attack a witness's credibility, including the party who called the witness.9
- Rule 608(a) allows testimony about a witness's reputation for truthfulness or untruthfulness, or an opinion about it. Evidence of truthful character comes in only after the witness's character for truthfulness has been attacked.10
- Rule 608(b) bars extrinsic evidence of specific instances of conduct offered to attack or support truthfulness. The court may allow inquiry into such instances on cross-examination if they are probative of truthfulness or untruthfulness.11
- Rule 609 governs the use of criminal convictions to attack a witness's character for honesty, and Rule 608 governs all other witness character evidence.12
The ordering rule in Rule 608(a) is the part most often tested. Impeachment comes first and rehabilitation second, because evidence that a witness is honest can mislead the jury when it arrives at the wrong moment. A lawyer who vouches for a witness before anyone has questioned her honesty takes the credibility decision out of the jury's hands, and jurors overvalue claims of honesty that they hear before any evidence of dishonesty.13 What counts as an attack is a question for the impeachment materials. For now, it is enough to see that something must challenge the witness's truthfulness before support is allowed.
The exception also limits the trait it reaches. Rule 404(a)(3) sends a witness's character to rules that concern truthfulness. It lets a party show that a witness may be lying. It does not let a party show that a witness is the kind of person who commits the charged act.14 Every other trait stays where the propensity bar put it.
A testifying defendant therefore wears two hats, and keeping them apart resolves most exam stems. As an accused, he may offer evidence of a pertinent trait of his own character under Rule 404(a)(2)(A), and the rules for that route are the defendant's-character rules covered earlier. As a witness, he is subject to attack on his credibility like any other witness, and that attack reaches only truthfulness.15