Concept
First-Aggressor Rebuttal in Homicide
Admissibility of character
First-Aggressor Rebuttal in Homicide
In a homicide trial, a defendant who claims the victim started the fight is describing events that the only other participant can no longer dispute. Rule 404(a)(2)(C) answers that problem with a prosecution response found only in homicide cases: when the defense offers evidence that the alleged victim was the first aggressor, the prosecutor may rebut it with evidence of the victim's trait of peacefulness.1
The rule exists because of what the dead cannot do. The victim cannot speak for herself, and the prosecutor's only way to answer the defendant's account may be to call witnesses who will say the victim was a peaceful, nonviolent person.2 Where the central question is who began the violence, a trait such as peacefulness or aggressiveness has real probative force, and fairness favors letting the prosecution counter the defense so the jury can judge that question on evidence about both participants.3
The trigger for this response is broader than the trigger for the other victim-side response. Under Rule 404(a)(2)(B)(i), the prosecution may answer only after the defendant has offered evidence of the victim's pertinent trait, so a defense that never mentions the victim's temperament leaves that door closed.4 Under subparagraph (C), the door opens when the defendant introduces evidence that the victim was the first aggressor, whether or not that evidence takes the form of opinion or reputation testimony.5 The defendant's own testimony that the victim lunged first qualifies, and so does an eyewitness who saw the victim throw the first punch. Neither is character evidence, but each makes the claim that the rule exists to answer. That difference decides exam questions in which the defense talks only about what happened that night.
The response is narrow in two ways, and both limits contain the risk to the defendant. The evidence must concern the alleged victim and not the defendant, and it must concern peacefulness and not other admirable traits.6 A prosecutor who answers a first-aggressor claim by proving that the defendant is violent finds no support in subparagraph (C), which speaks only of the alleged victim's trait. Other provisions, covered above, govern when the prosecution may reach the defendant's own character, and a defendant who merely describes the event has not satisfied them.
The provision applies only when the charge is homicide.7 Its stated justification, a victim who is dead and cannot speak, is absent when the complainant survived and can take the stand to give a competing account of the first blow.
The two triggers can overlap in a single trial. A homicide defendant who calls a witness to say the victim was a violent person has offered victim-trait evidence, which opens the (B)(i) response, and if the testimony is offered to show that the victim started the fight, it also opens subparagraph (C).8 They diverge when the defense offers only an account of the event, because then (C) is the only route. The form of the prosecution's proof is the same either way. Peacefulness comes in through reputation or opinion testimony, and Rule 405(a) binds the prosecution's witnesses as it binds the defense, so a witness may not recite specific earlier occasions on which the victim kept the peace.9