Concept
Defendant's Own Character
Admissibility of character
Defendant's Own Character
Rule 404(a)(1) bars evidence of a person's character offered to prove that the person acted in accordance with it on a particular occasion.1 A criminal defendant may break that bar on his own behalf: he may offer evidence of a pertinent trait of his own character, and if the court admits it, the prosecutor may offer evidence to rebut it.2 The provision sits among the exceptions that apply in a criminal case, so a civil litigant has no counterpart to it.3
The exception is a bargain that only the defendant may propose. He gains the chance to put a good trait before the jury, which may infer that a person with that trait probably did not commit the charged crime. The price is that his evidence opens a subject the prosecution could not have raised itself, and the prosecutor may answer with the same sort of evidence whether or not the defendant meant to open the door.4 A defendant who stays silent on character keeps the subject closed, so the decision is strategic: it turns on how clean his record is on the trait and how much damaging material the prosecution may hold.
Three questions follow in order. May the defendant offer character evidence at all? Which trait may he offer? How may the prosecution respond? Each answer limits the next, because the scope of the rebuttal follows the trait the defendant chose.
The Mercy Rule
Rule 404(a)(2)(A) lets a criminal defendant make the first move on character, and the evidence he offers is circumstantial.5 The jury is asked to infer something about the charged event from the kind of person the defendant is. A defendant accused of a violent crime who shows a peaceable disposition invites the jury to reason that a peaceable person probably did not do this.6 The rule says nothing about the defendant testifying, so he may call character witnesses and never take the stand himself.7
The inference the defendant invites is the one that Rule 404(a)(1) forbids the prosecution to draw. When the prosecution offers a defendant's earlier robberies to show that he is a criminal type who disrespects property and therefore robbed this liquor store, the chain runs through a middle conclusion about what kind of person he is.8 A defendant who offers his reputation for honesty to show that he is an honest type who therefore did not commit the theft runs the identical chain the other way.9 The logic does not separate the two inferences; control does. The defendant may start the chain, and the prosecution may use its mirror image only after he has opened the subject. Lawyers call the defendant's option the mercy rule.10 The inference itself is familiar, since employers, lenders, sports executives, and bar character committees all lean on character appraisals in their own decisions.11
Three considerations support a privilege the prosecution does not share. The first is prejudice: a major ground for excluding character evidence is apprehension about its prejudicial effect, and that ground weakens when the accused is the one who offers it.12 The second is the burden of proof. In a close case, evidence of general regard may be the weight that turns the scales, and it may sow the reasonable doubt that the prosecution must overcome before a jury may convict.13 The third is the accused's right to make a full defense. Its constitutional contours are not sharply defined, but a right to show that his character is inconsistent with the charges fits comfortably within it.14
Michelson supplies the practical payoff. The Court called the privilege sometimes valuable to a defendant, because character testimony alone may, in some circumstances, be enough to raise a reasonable doubt of guilt, and a jury in a proper case should be so instructed in federal court.15 One opinion framed the asymmetry in two sentences: no one would open the doors initially to the prosecution, and no one would close them to the defense.16
Rule 405(a) governs the method of proof, and two points belong here. The defendant must prove character by reputation or opinion rather than by specific instances of past conduct.17 The Court also accepted a witness who can say only that he has heard nothing against the defendant, on the assumption that if no ill is reported of a person his reputation must be good, so long as the witness knows the defendant's surroundings well enough that his silence means something.18
The same kind of testimony in a civil courtroom produces the opposite ruling.
The prosecution has no matching privilege to lead with a defendant's bad reputation. It may answer only after the defendant's evidence is admitted, a limit the rebuttal section develops below.
The Pertinent Trait Requirement
"Pertinent" is the word that limits the exception, because it decides which of a defendant's good qualities the jury may hear about.20 A trait is pertinent when it would affect the defendant's conduct in a way that makes the charged crime less likely; a trait that is not inconsistent with the crime has no probative value on whether he committed it.21 The test compares trait to offense, so the defendant's most flattering quality is worthless if it does not fit the charge.
The exception exists so that a defendant can argue that a person of a certain disposition would be unlikely to do this. That argument works only when the disposition pulls against the crime. A trait that sits comfortably beside the charged conduct adds nothing to the inference of innocence.
Pairing traits with offenses makes the test concrete. In a prosecution for aggravated assault, the defendant may offer proof that he is peaceable or nonviolent but not proof that he is honest.22 A defendant charged with assault may show that she is peaceful, not that she is generous or enterprising.23 Where the charge is larceny or theft, the pairing reverses and honesty becomes the pertinent trait.24 The same testimony can therefore be admissible in one trial and excluded in another.
The privilege does not reach the defendant's good character in general. A witness who calls a robbery defendant generous or devout describes qualities that do nothing to make a robbery less likely, and the advisory committee's note speaks of limiting the evidence to pertinent traits rather than proving "character generally."25 Where the offense points to a specific trait, the testimony should name it, and a general reputation for being law abiding is not enough when that more specific trait is available.26 Where the nature of the offense offers no more specific trait, as with narcotics possession, being law abiding is permitted.27
Courts do not agree on how finely the trait must be cut. In United States v. Diaz, a drug trial, the court held it error to block the defense from asking a pastor about the defendant's character traits for being prone to criminal activity, because traits need not be specific and may be as general as being law abiding. The same court properly blocked a question framed around being prone to large-scale drug dealing, which it did not treat as a character trait.28 The safe offer names the trait the offense calls into question.
A defendant who testifies may also want the jury to know he is a truthful person, and that offer follows a different rule. Rule 404 sends evidence of a witness's character to Rules 607, 608, and 609, so pertinence under Rule 404(a)(2)(A) is not the test.29 Rule 608 admits evidence of truthful character only after the witness's character for truthfulness has been attacked by opinion or reputation evidence or otherwise.30
In United States v. Danehy, the accused tried to offer evidence to bolster himself as a witness rather than to show a trait pertinent to the crime charged, so Rule 608, not Rule 404, governed.31 Government counsel's pointing out inconsistencies in testimony and arguing that the accused is not credible is not an attack on his reputation for truthfulness under Rule 608. Because such an attack does not authorize rehabilitation, the court in United States v. Drury found no abuse of discretion in excluding the defendant's proffered reputation-for-truthfulness testimony.32 United States v. Jackson points the same way from the pertinence side: in a drug trial, proof of the defendant's reputation for truth and veracity was inadmissible because truthfulness was "not pertinent to the criminal charges of conspiracy to distribute heroin or possession of heroin."33
A different prosecution tactic would change the result. If the government called a witness to testify that the defendant has a reputation for lying, the attack would reach his character for truthfulness itself, and evidence of truthful character would then be admissible under Rule 608.34 The attack-first requirement keeps the two rules apart. Honesty offered because it matches a theft charge is judged under Rule 404(a)(2)(A), which needs neither the defendant's testimony nor an attack. Truthfulness offered to support a testifying defendant is judged under Rule 608, which needs an attack first.
The fifth step catches the offer that is labeled character evidence but functions as vouching, and it is the one most often skipped. The trait the defendant selects also fixes the ground on which the prosecution may respond, a point the next section develops.
Prosecution Rebuttal
Rule 404(a)(2)(A) conditions the prosecution's response on the admission of the defendant's evidence: if the evidence of a pertinent trait is admitted, the prosecutor may offer evidence to rebut it.36 The condition keeps the prosecution from advancing its own character theory, because the right to answer does not exist until the defense has put its evidence in. It also ties the right to the admission itself, so the prosecutor may respond whether or not defense counsel foresaw the consequence.37 Two attacks are then available to the prosecutor: rigorous cross-examination of the defendant's character witnesses, and character witnesses of the prosecution's own who portray the defendant's character as consistent with the offense charged.38
Rebuttal follows from what the defendant asked the jury to do. Evidence that he is peaceable invites the jury to reason from disposition to conduct, and he chose the witnesses who say so. Without a response, the jury would hear only the favorable half of a picture the defense selected. The cost to the defendant is real, which is why a defendant with a doubtful record on the trait may decide to leave the subject closed.
The first tool is the prosecution's own character witnesses, who may address the same trait the defendant raised. Rule 405(a) applies to them as it does to defense witnesses: they may give reputation or opinion testimony but may not recount specific acts, and character evidence offered in one of those forms is rebutted only in one of those forms.39 If the defense witnesses testified to peaceable character, for example, the prosecution's witnesses could testify to the defendant's violent and bellicose disposition.40
The second tool is cross-examination of the defense character witnesses about specific instances of conduct, and it is the more distinctive and more dangerous of the two. Rule 405(a) lets the cross-examiner ask a reputation witness whether he has heard of a relevant event, or an opinion witness whether he knows of it. The relevant instances include arrests and convictions, and non-criminal conduct may be relevant too.41 The cross-examiner must have a good-faith basis for the inquiry.42
Michelson shows the technique and its safeguard. The defendant's character witnesses were asked about his arrest for receiving stolen goods, and none of them appears to have heard of it. Before the questions reached the jury, the trial court asked the prosecutor, out of the jury's presence, whether the arrest had in fact occurred. The prosecutor said it had and showed a paper record, which defense counsel did not challenge.43
The purpose of the question explains its limits. A witness who tells the jury the defendant is peaceable has vouched for a judgment about the defendant, and a lack of familiarity with a relevant event bears on the basis of that judgment. Familiarity with such matters explores the witness's own standard of "goodness" and "badness."44 The question therefore tests the witness and does not prove that the event happened.
The question was proper because it rested on a good-faith basis and addressed the trait the minister had vouched for. What the prosecutor does next is where trouble arises. If he calls the supermarket cashier to describe the attack, the objection must be sustained. The cross-examiner may not introduce independent evidence to support her question; she must rest satisfied with the witness's answer, even if she knows the witness lied.45 The wall holds in the other direction as well. The witness may not offer specific acts to rehabilitate himself but may only reassert his opinion or his understanding of the person's reputation.46 The prosecution's own rebuttal witnesses face the same restriction, since they may offer reputation or opinion and cannot recite the defendant's past acts.47
The question itself has further limits. The cross-examiner may not ask the witness whether his testimony would change if he assumed that the defendant committed the very act charged. Where the inquiry is allowed, a limiting instruction under Rule 105 should tell the jury to consider the question solely for the weight it gives the character witness's testimony.48
The trait limit completes the picture. The prosecution's right to rebut follows the trait the defendant opened and does not widen to his character generally.49
The fifth step is where an exam stem usually plants its trap: a prosecutor who hears a denial and then reaches for a second witness has stepped outside what the rule allows.