Concept
Criminal Cases Only
Admissibility of character
Criminal Cases Only
Rule 404(a)(2) opens with a limit that is easy to read past: its exceptions apply “in a criminal case.”1 The propensity bar itself binds civil and criminal litigants alike, so that clause marks the point where the two kinds of case part ways. Only in a criminal case may a party use character circumstantially, offering a trait to support the inference that a person acted on the occasion in question consistently with it.2 The exceptions cover the accused's own character and the alleged victim's, and each has its own section below. Rule 404(a)(3), which sends a witness's character to the credibility rules, is a separate provision that does reach civil trials.3
Criminal cases differ because the stakes and the resources differ. The Constitution and the courts that apply it take special precautions against convicting an innocent defendant. The prosecution controls the resources for finding and preparing evidence, and some defendants have only a good name to offer in defense.4 The accused's freedom to offer favorable character proof is called the rule of mercy, part of a deep American tradition favoring the accused at trial. A major ground for excluding character evidence is apprehension about its prejudicial effect, and that concern is weakest when the accused is the one offering favorable evidence.5
The prosecution stands elsewhere. By longstanding tradition, the unfair prejudice of portraying the accused as a “bad man” is felt to substantially outweigh any probative value the evidence might have, so the prosecution may not introduce a pertinent trait of the accused's character in its case in chief.6
This order settles many problems before any question about the particular trait arises. A fact pattern in which the prosecution's first witness calls the accused violent tests step one, and the form of the testimony does not change the answer.
Michelson v. United States states the asymmetry. The line of inquiry firmly denied to the prosecution is open to the defendant, because character is relevant in resolving probabilities of guilt. The defendant may introduce affirmative testimony that the general estimate of his character is so favorable that the jury may infer he would not be likely to commit the offense charged.11 The privilege can matter a great deal. The Court noted that such testimony alone may, in some circumstances, be enough to raise a reasonable doubt, and that in the federal courts a jury in a proper case should be so instructed.12
Two further points belong in view now and are developed later. Rule 405(a) fixes the form of the accused's proof: it must come as reputation or opinion testimony, and specific instances of conduct are not allowed.13 The prosecution's response is also broader than simple contradiction. It may cross-examine the defense character witnesses rigorously, or call its own witnesses to portray the accused's character as consistent with the offense charged.14
Lawyers sometimes say that the accused puts character in issue by offering a trait, and the phrase misleads. Character is in issue only when it is an essential element of a claim or defense, and in criminal cases that almost never happens. The Advisory Committee's one example was an archaic statute that made the victim's chastity an element of seduction.15 When the accused offers proof of peacefulness, character does not become an issue in the case. The evidence is used circumstantially, to suggest that the accused acted consistently with the trait.16
Civil cases have no counterpart to any of this. There are no exceptions in civil cases, so character cannot be used to prove conduct on a particular occasion, and neither side may open the subject. Rule 404(b) restates the same exclusionary principle, though specific instances of conduct remain usable to show motive, intent, or plan.17
The reasons that justify the criminal exceptions are missing from a civil trial. The special precautions against an erroneous conviction and the accused's right to make a full defense have no civil analogue. Many civil claims rest on unintentional conduct such as negligence, where character has weak probative value. Circumstantial character evidence in a civil case is also not worth the time it consumes, the distraction of the trier, and its potential prejudice.18 Before a 2006 amendment, courts sometimes admitted character evidence in civil cases where the conduct was criminal in nature. The amendment limited the exceptions to criminal cases, so a civil party gains nothing by calling its claim criminal in character.19
A civil case still has four routes to character-related proof: a witness's character for truthfulness, character as an essential element, habit or an organization's routine practice, and past acts offered for a purpose other than propensity. Congress has also carved out civil cases alleging sexual assault or child molestation, and the character of the victim in civil sex-offense cases, each treated below.20