Concept
Discovery and Stipulations
Authentication and identification
Discovery and Stipulations
A proponent carries the Rule 901(a) burden by producing evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is.1 In practice that burden is seldom carried in front of a jury, because the parties can settle authenticity before trial begins. Interrogatories, requests for admission, and stipulations are the tools, and one leading treatise says they should be relied upon to dispose of most authentication problems in advance.2 The reason is cost. Formal proof of genuineness can be troublesome, time consuming, and expensive even when no one has a legitimate doubt about the document. The continuing insistence on that proof rests less on common sense than on fairness in allocating the burden between adversaries, and on concern about sharp practices if the burden were lifted.3 Authentication is therefore undisputed in many trials, having been resolved by discovery or stipulation, and some courts have rules requiring the parties to settle such matters in advance.4 Two routes lead there, and they work differently. Production in discovery can supply evidence that satisfies Rule 901, while admissions and stipulations remove the question from the case.
Production in Discovery
A document that comes from an opponent's files does not prove itself. Rule 902 lists the self-authenticating categories, among them a public document bearing a seal of the United States, a state, or one of their agencies or officers, and a document accompanied by a certificate of acknowledgment executed by a notary or another authorized officer.5 A discovery response is on no such list. In Stumpff v. Harris, the court held that a party is not excused from providing evidence of authenticity for items it received in discovery.6 The same opinion also held that production can itself supply that evidence.
The plaintiffs in Stumpff served a request for production on the defendant Harris's counsel and later moved to compel discovery.7 At a hearing they presented evidence that Harris had produced to them the financial records and tax returns of Valley Auto Parts and Harris's own personal tax returns.8 The trial court excluded the documents for lack of proof of authentication. The court of appeals agreed that the documents were not self-authenticating but found the exclusion erroneous, because testimony that the documents had been specifically requested from and provided by Harris was enough to authenticate them.9 Rule 901(b) lists its examples by way of illustration only, the court explained, so testimony about production during discovery may provide sufficient indicia of authenticity.10 Another court accepted the same kind of proof when it upheld authentication of a video by an affidavit from counsel that the opposing party had produced it in discovery.11
The logic is circumstantial. A party that answers a request describing a document by handing one over from its own files is implicitly representing that the document is the one requested. The proponent must still put the fact of production before the court through a witness or an affidavit, and once that proof is in, the judge applies the ordinary Rule 901(a) question. An opponent who then insists the document is not genuine makes that argument to the jury as a matter of weight.
The inference weakens as the producing party's ability to vouch for the item weakens. Stumpff declined to catalog every situation in which production might fail to satisfy Rule 901 and told trial courts to weigh the totality of the circumstances, including the specificity of the discovery request, the nature of the documents, and the party responding.12 The opinion drew on Thrasher v. Durham for the caution that most producers can authenticate what they hand over, but a party may also hold documents from other sources or of unknown origin, and a very broad request for everything on a subject implies nothing about the authenticity of such a document.13
Another court met the weak end of that range and refused to treat production as an admission of authenticity. Given the breadth of the discovery rules, it reasoned, reading production as a concession would undermine their liberal intent, so an admission requires a specific assertion by the producing party about the nature or authorship of the documents.14 Production still counted as circumstantial evidence, however. Following Alexander Dawson, Inc. v. N.L.R.B., the court treated the circumstances of production as one element that tends to authenticate, to be combined with other circumstances.15 Interrogatory answers can serve as testimony in the same way where they directly identify a document's source or author, corroborate its contents, or otherwise establish authenticity, but vague questions and answers do not amount to a concession.16
The tempting error on an exam is to treat bare production as an admission of genuineness. The cases do not support that reading, and the difference lies in the specificity of the request and the producer's ability to vouch. In Stumpff the request named particular records that belonged to the party who produced them, and a witness proved the request and the response. In the second case the production carried no specific assertion about what the documents were.
Admissions and Stipulations
A lawyer who treats authenticity as open until the foundation witness testifies overlooks the devices that close it earlier. The most direct is a stipulation, an agreement between the parties that a document is genuine.18 The second is a request for admission. Under Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 36 and 37(c)(2), a party may serve a written request that the adversary admit the genuineness of a described document. If the adversary unreasonably fails to answer or object within the time allowed, genuineness is admitted.19 If the adversary denies genuineness and the requesting party then proves it at trial, the requesting party may apply for an order requiring the adversary to pay the reasonable costs of making that proof.20
Each feature of the request procedure has its own logic. Admission by silence places the work on the party who knows the most, because the opponent can usually tell at once whether a document is genuine, and a written request pulls that knowledge into the open early, when sharing it is cheap. The cost-shifting remedy answers a different problem. Without it, the proponent's burden could be used as a tactic, with an opponent who knows a document is real demanding a foundation witness anyway. The remedy gives that opponent a reason to concede what cannot honestly be disputed and to save the genuine disputes for trial.
The pretrial conference attacks the same problem through the judge. A skillful judge can create an atmosphere of mutual concession unusually favorable to admissions of documents, and this function has been considered one of the most successful features of pretrial practice.21 Specific interrogatory answers work the same way when they are precise enough to concede the point.22
These devices settle authentication and nothing else. Relevance, the best evidence rule, hearsay, and the balancing of probative value against unfair prejudice are separate requirements that a document must also clear. An admission or stipulation of genuineness leaves those objections to be resolved on their own terms.23 On an exam, a fact pattern showing that the opponent stipulated, admitted by silence, or conceded the point at a pretrial conference means no foundation witness is needed. A fact pattern showing only that the document came from the opponent calls for the production analysis above.