Concept
Other Statutes and Rules
Proceedings to which evidence rules apply
Other Statutes and Rules
Rule 1101(e) keeps the Federal Rules of Evidence from being the only word on evidence in a federal courtroom: a federal statute or a rule prescribed by the Supreme Court may provide for admitting or excluding evidence independently from the Rules.1 The word independently carries the meaning. Subsections (a) through (d) ask whether the Rules govern a proceeding and which stages they leave out. Subsection (e) takes up a different question: what happens when another source of federal law speaks directly to what evidence may come in. Such a provision operates by its own force. It need not fit inside a Rule 1101(d) exception, and the Rules do not override it.
Subsection (e) names two sources and no others. One is a federal statute. The other is a "rule prescribed by the Supreme Court," which the Rules define as a rule adopted by the Supreme Court under statutory authority.2 The definition has two parts: the body that adopts the rule and the source of its power. The Court acts as rulemaker only because a statute authorizes it to, and the Rules of Evidence themselves reached Congress that way, when the Court accepted the Advisory Committee's draft and transmitted it under the Enabling Act, 28 U.S.C. § 2072.3 A rule adopted by some other court, or by the Supreme Court without statutory authority, falls outside the phrase.
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 5.1 is the standard example. It provides that a finding of probable cause "may be based upon hearsay evidence in whole or in part," and that objections to evidence on the ground that it was acquired by unlawful means "are not properly made at the preliminary examination."4 Its permissive reference to hearsay suggests that the magistrate judge may take the hearsay character of the evidence into account when assessing probable cause. Rule 5.1 is a rule of criminal procedure adopted by the Supreme Court, so it qualifies under Rule 1101(e) and speaks to admission on its own authority. The two provisions work in layers. The Rules' scope provision already treats preliminary examinations among the miscellaneous proceedings it leaves out, and Rule 5.1 tells the magistrate judge affirmatively what the probable-cause finding may rest on.
An exam stem that quotes a provision on admitting or excluding evidence is asking where that provision came from, because the source decides whether it displaces the Rules.
The magistrate judge applying Rule 5.1 and the judge applying the standing order work in the same federal system and may be doing very similar work. What separates them is the source of the provision, the one fact Rule 1101(e) looks to. The classification can be run as a short sequence.
Step three does most of the work in practice, because the word "rule" in a provision's name tempts a student to stop there. A local rule or standing order is adopted by the court that issues it, not by the Supreme Court. Rule 1101(e) is also a separate route from the Rule 1101(d) exceptions: a statute or Supreme Court rule can govern evidence even in a proceeding where the Rules otherwise apply in full.