Concept
Order and Form of Proof
Character for truthfulness
Order and Form of Proof
Every item of credibility proof raises two questions: in what form may it come in, and when? Rule 608(a) answers them for character testimony. A party may attack or support a witness's credibility with reputation testimony or opinion testimony about the witness's character for truthfulness or untruthfulness, but evidence of truthful character is admissible only after that character has been attacked.1 Rule 608(b) answers them for specific acts. Except for a criminal conviction under Rule 609, extrinsic evidence of a witness's acts is inadmissible to attack or support character for truthfulness, though the court may allow the acts to be inquired into on cross-examination if they are probative of truthfulness or untruthfulness.2 The last sentence of Rule 608 preserves the witness's privilege against self-incrimination for testimony that relates only to character for truthfulness.3 This section assembles those pieces into one timetable. Courts control the mode and order of questioning, though parties keep wide discretion over what evidence to present and when, so the timetable describes what the rules permit and not what every judge will allow.4
The Timetable
For each kind of credibility proof, the chart asks three things: whether a party may offer it before any other credibility evidence has come in, whether it can be developed on direct examination of a party's own witness, and whether it can be developed on cross-examination. Each entry assumes that the proof also satisfies the rule governing its content, namely Rule 609 for convictions, the truthfulness limit for reputation and opinion, and the safeguards of Rule 608(b) for acts.
| Type of proof | Before other credibility evidence | On direct examination | On cross-examination |
|---|---|---|---|
| Convictions showing untruthfulness (Rule 609) | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Opinion or reputation showing untruthfulness | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Past acts showing untruthfulness | Yes | No | Yes |
| Opinion or reputation showing truthfulness | No | Yes | Yes |
| Past acts showing truthfulness | No | No | Yes |
For the act row that shows untruthfulness, a Yes in the first column means only that the cross-examiner needs no earlier attack before asking.
Reading the Chart
The first dividing line separates attack from support. Every row that shows untruthfulness carries a Yes in the first column, and every row that shows truthfulness carries a No, so support in any form waits for an attack. The Yes entries in the other two columns of the truthfulness rows describe what becomes available once the attack has come.5
The second line separates acts from everything else. Past acts that produced no conviction may be asked about only on cross-examination, which is why both act rows show No under direct examination.6 Whether an act suggests truthfulness or untruthfulness, it reaches the jury only as a question and the witness's answer.7
The chart also fixes form. A party who wants a witness's character for truthfulness before the jury through direct testimony must use reputation or opinion, as Xander does when he testifies about Wendy's bad character for telling the truth.8
Convictions appear in the chart because they work as an attack tool: evidence of a conviction supports the inferences that the witness does not respect society's rules, has a propensity to lie, and may have lied while testifying.9 Rule 608(b) nonetheless sets convictions aside at the outset and leaves them to Rule 609, so the extrinsic-evidence bar does not reach them, and extrinsic proof of a conviction can be admitted subject to the provisions that govern it.10
Why the Pattern Is Lopsided
The imbalance has a reason on each side. Attack is open because a witness who takes the stand puts her own character for truthfulness in issue, and jurors deciding whom to believe may test her with reputation, opinion, or a conviction at any point in the trial.11 Support is gated because evidence of honesty answers no question until someone has contested honesty. Offered early, it lets a clever lawyer vouch for the witness and take the credibility decision out of the jury's hands, since jurors overvalue claims of honesty that they hear before they hear evidence of dishonesty.12 Once an attack has come, the effort to support the witness is called rehabilitation.13 Specific acts stay on cross-examination, where the witness's own answer ends the matter and the court's control over the examination keeps the inquiry in check.14 Even the open tools arrive in limited form, because Rule 608 keeps the mini-trial method that Rule 405 uses to prove character.15
A fact pattern read against the chart therefore comes down to three inquiries: which form of proof is offered, who offers it and when, and whether an attack has already come.
Running the Analysis
One Trial, Start to Finish
The collision trial that runs through this chapter shows the timetable in operation. The plaintiff calls Wendy in her case-in-chief to testify that the light was red when the defendant entered the intersection. If the plaintiff then calls Yasmine to say that Wendy is an honest person, the court sustains the objection, because nothing has yet challenged Wendy's honesty and the testimony would be bolstering.16
The defense can supply the missing challenge in either of two ways. It can confront Wendy on cross-examination with questions about her character for honesty, or it can wait for its own case and call Xander to testify that Wendy has a bad character for telling the truth.17 Rule 608(a) puts no timing condition on that attack, and it allows the testimony in two forms: an opinion that Wendy is untruthful or a report of her reputation for untruthfulness.18 Once the attack has come, the plaintiff may call Yasmine in rebuttal, and she may give her opinion that Wendy is honest or report that Wendy's reputation for honesty is good.19
Specific acts travel a different road. The defense may ask on cross-examination about particular acts that bear on truthfulness, such as whether Wendy failed a lie-detector test or was charged, though never convicted, of perjury, and the court may allow those questions whether they go to Wendy or to Yasmine, who has testified about Wendy's character.20 Each question must bear on truthfulness and must survive the court's discretion.
Wendy denies having failed the test, and there the defense's route ends. It cannot call Xander to say that she failed, because his account is extrinsic evidence of a specific act and not reputation or opinion about her truthfulness, and it cannot offer a printout of the results, which is extrinsic evidence of the same act.21 Xander remains free to give his opinion of Wendy's truthfulness, since opinion is a permitted form, but he may not recount the test result as proof of the act she denied.22 The jury hears the question and the denial and nothing more.
The privilege adds one further protection. Suppose the defense asks whether Wendy lied under oath in an earlier case. An honest answer would describe conduct that could be prosecuted, and Wendy, who testified only about the red light, has not waived her privilege against self-incrimination for testimony that relates only to her character for truthfulness.23
The conviction also opens the gate for support. When a witness is impeached by a conviction for a crime related to truth-telling, reputation or opinion testimony that she has a character consistent with truthful testimony may be offered in response, and the plaintiff needs no Xander to have testified first.24 The same accusation therefore lands on opposite sides of the chart depending on whether a conviction exists.