Concept
Why Truthfulness Evidence Is Allowed
Character for truthfulness
Attacking and Supporting Truthfulness
Why Truthfulness Evidence Is Allowed
Two rules seem to pull in opposite directions. Rule 404(a)(1) bars evidence of a person's character or character trait to prove that, on a particular occasion, the person acted in accordance with it.1 Rule 608(a) nonetheless lets a party attack or support a witness's credibility with reputation testimony, or with opinion testimony, about the witness's character for truthfulness or untruthfulness.2 If the first rule rejects reasoning from character to conduct, why does the second invite it?
The answer lies in what a witness's conduct is. When a person testifies, the conduct the jury must evaluate is the testimony itself, and the question is whether to believe it. The fact that a witness has deceived others before is some evidence of a trait of untruthfulness, and that trait at least slightly raises the probability that she lied on the stand.3 Rule 404 gives this reasoning a place. After the general prohibition and the exceptions in subsection (a)(2), it adds subsection (a)(3), which provides that evidence of a witness's character may be admitted under Rules 607, 608, and 609.4 Rule 608 then supplies the terms. By taking the stand, the witness puts her character for truthfulness in issue, and the rule keeps Rule 405's method of proving character along with limits of its own.5
The rules admit this inference but fence it in, because the inference is slight and the attack is costly. Questioning a person's veracity is embarrassing, even humiliating, and Rule 611 lets judges protect witnesses from harassment or undue embarrassment. When the witness is a party, the attack also risks the prejudice that Rule 404 guards against.6 The attacker takes a risk as well. Jurors naturally sympathize with the witness, and an attack that misses its mark or is pressed too far can backfire.7
The sharpest fence is the limit to a single trait. The inquiry is strictly confined to character for veracity, not character generally, which sharpens relevance, reduces surprise, waste of time, and confusion, and makes the witness's lot somewhat less unattractive.8 A defendant who testifies in a murder trial shows the effect. Rules 608 and 609 entitle the prosecutor to try to show that he is dishonest, but Rule 404 continues to bar evidence that he is violent, and the prosecutor cannot use the misdeeds exposed in the attack as proof of the charged crime.9
Rule 608 governs reputation and opinion testimony and specific instances of conduct bearing on a witness's truthfulness, with one carve-out: criminal convictions fall under Rule 609.10 Rule 608(b) draws that line expressly, and a later section returns to it.
Four terms recur through the rest of the chapter. Impeachment is evidence suggesting that a witness's testimony lacks credibility, and rehabilitation is the opposite: evidence suggesting that the testimony is worthy of belief.11 Extrinsic evidence is proof offered through other witnesses or exhibits rather than drawn out of the witness being questioned. A character witness is a second person who testifies about the first witness's truthfulness. The remaining sections build on four propositions:
- Reputation and opinion testimony may attack or support a witness's character for truthfulness.12
- Evidence of truthful character is admissible only after the witness's character for truthfulness has been attacked.13
- Specific instances of conduct that did not produce a conviction may be explored on cross-examination, but they generally cannot be proved by extrinsic evidence.14
- By testifying on another matter, a witness does not waive the privilege against self-incrimination for testimony that relates only to character for truthfulness.15
A second route to character evidence runs alongside this one, and students often confuse the two. Under Rule 404(a)(2)(A), a criminal defendant may offer evidence of a pertinent trait of his own character, and if the court admits it, the prosecutor may offer evidence to rebut it.16 That exception concerns the defendant as the accused, so it applies with or without his testimony. Rule 608 concerns the defendant, or anyone else, as a witness. It operates only when the person testifies, and the trait is always truthfulness.17
Courts hold the line when a testifying defendant tries to merge the two routes. In United States v. Danehy, the accused argued that Rule 404 let him offer evidence of his reputation for truth as a pertinent trait. The court disagreed. He was offering evidence to bolster himself as a witness, not to show a trait pertinent to the crime charged, so Rule 608 governed, and Rule 608 admits evidence of truthful character only after the witness's character for truthfulness has been attacked. The prosecutor had done no more than point out inconsistencies in the testimony and argue that the accused was not credible, and that did not amount to an attack on his reputation for truthfulness.18 The later sections on bolstering develop what does and does not qualify as an attack.