Concept
The Rule 609(c) Bar
Pardon, annulment, or certificate of rehabilitation under Rule 609(c)
Pardons, Annulments, and Rehabilitation
The Rule 609(c) Bar
Rule 609(c) opens by declaring that evidence of a conviction "is not admissible if" one of two conditions is met.1 That wording makes the subdivision an exclusionary override. It can remove a conviction from the pool of impeaching evidence, but it can never add one. The admitting work belongs to the rest of Rule 609, which sets out how a criminal conviction may be used to attack a witness's character for truthfulness and, in a separate subdivision, the conditions for juvenile adjudications.2 Subdivision (c) therefore asks one narrow question about a conviction that has already qualified: did some later act of forgiveness take it back out?
The usual answer is no. At common law, a conviction of treason, any felony, or a crimen falsi misdemeanor made the convict incompetent to testify. Modern law has abandoned that absolutism and reduced the conviction to a mere ground for impeaching credibility.3 A conviction that remains usable for impeachment is not displaced by forgiveness alone. The reason lies in the inference that conviction impeachment depends on. A conviction suggests a propensity to violate the law. That propensity suggests the witness is more willing than others to lie, and a tendency to lie bears on whether the witness is lying on the stand.4 Forgiveness matters only if it cuts into one of those links, and most forgiveness does not. The commentary lists forms of relief that, standing alone, leave the conviction usable: a pardon granted solely to restore civil rights lost through the conviction; an expungement or dismissal after the person meets certain conditions, where state law lets the conviction be proved in a later prosecution; a certification that the sentence was satisfactorily served; a pardon that rests on no finding of innocence or rehabilitation; successfully completed parole; and release from a halfway house.5
The two exceptions cover the cases in which the forgiving authority has made a determination that does cut a link. Subparagraph (1) applies when the pardon, annulment, certificate of rehabilitation, or equivalent procedure rested on a finding that the person has been rehabilitated, and the person has not been convicted of a later crime punishable by death or by imprisonment for more than one year.6 A finding of rehabilitation weakens the tie between the old crime and the witness's truthfulness today. The later-crime condition protects the premise of that finding, because a new felony-grade conviction undercuts the claim that the witness has reformed. Subparagraph (2) applies when the procedure rested on a finding of innocence.7 That finding removes the first link of the chain altogether, since the witness is treated as not having committed the crime, and the text attaches no later-crime condition to it. The two subparagraphs are joined by or, so each is an independent gate, and satisfying either one is enough.
Because Rule 609(c) speaks only of what makes a conviction inadmissible, a conviction that fails both gates is not thereby admitted. The matter returns to the rest of Rule 609, where the type of crime, the witness's role in the case, the balancing standards, and the age of the conviction still decide the outcome, exactly as for the second witness above. The commentary reads the rehabilitation gate strictly: the procedure, whatever it is called, must have made a finding of rehabilitation of the person convicted.8 In both subparagraphs the words based on a finding do the work. A procedure that forgives without resting on a finding of rehabilitation or of innocence leaves the conviction usable. The next sections take each gate in turn.