Concept
The Ten-Year Presumption
Convictions more than ten years old under Rule 609(b)
Convictions Over Ten Years Old
The Ten-Year Presumption
Rule 609(b) takes over once a conviction grows old. It applies when "more than 10 years have passed since the witness's conviction or release from confinement for it, whichever is later," and from that point the conviction is "admissible only if" two further conditions are met.1
Those conditions sit on top of Rule 609(a), the general rule for attacking a witness's character for truthfulness with a criminal conviction.2 Rule 609(a) sorts convictions by the seriousness of the crime, by whether the witness is a criminal defendant, and by whether proving the crime required a dishonest act or false statement. Rule 609(b) then adds an age filter to whatever result that sorting produces.3
The age filter makes sense once you trace why a conviction bears on credibility at all. The desired inference is that a person who has been convicted of a crime is more likely to have a character of untruthfulness and disrespect for legal standards, and so is more likely to give false testimony under oath.4 The older the conviction, the weaker that inference plausibly becomes, while a jury's reaction to a witness with a criminal record does not fade in the same way. The rule therefore reverses the usual default: when the question is close, the old conviction stays out.
Inside the ten-year window, Rule 609(a) tilts toward the impeaching party, because convictions in its qualifying categories must be admitted, subject to whatever weighing each category calls for.5 Past ten years, the tilt flips. The conviction is presumptively out, and the proponent must satisfy two conditions together. First, the conviction's probative value, supported by specific facts and circumstances, must substantially outweigh its prejudicial effect.6 Second, the proponent must give the adverse party reasonable written notice of the intent to use it, so that the party has a fair opportunity to contest its use.7 Meeting one condition does not excuse the other. The sections that follow take the balance first and the notice requirement after it.
The presumption is strong, but it is not an absolute bar, because a proponent who meets both conditions can still get the conviction in. What makes the test hard is its direction. Rule 403 lets a court exclude relevant evidence only when its probative value is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, and Rule 609(b) is the reverse: the old conviction comes in only when probative value substantially outweighs prejudice, so a close call goes against the proponent.8 In practice, an old conviction does not come in unless lying or deceit was an element of the offense, the witness's credibility is very important in the case, and the witness cannot be impeached with other evidence, such as a newer conviction, a bad act, or a prior inconsistent statement.9
In United States v. Beahm, the government offered an eleven-year-old sodomy conviction solely to impeach under Rule 609(b), and it made no claim that the conviction was admissible under Rule 404(b). The Fourth Circuit held that admitting it was reversible error.10 Following its earlier decision in United States v. Cavender, the court stressed that a departure from the ten-year prohibition should occur "very rarely and only in exceptional circumstances." It added that the trial court must find that probative value "substantially" outweighs prejudice and must support that finding with "specific facts and circumstances."11
A younger conviction never reaches Rule 609(b). In United States v. Lipscomb, the district court admitted an eight-year-old robbery conviction under Rule 609(a)(1), and the ten-year limit had nothing to say about it.12 The first question in any old-conviction problem is therefore a question about dates.
The first move on an exam is arithmetic. Find the later of the conviction date and the release date, measure the time that has passed since that date, and only then choose the standard. Two errors recur. One is applying Rule 609(b) to a nine-year-old conviction because it feels old. The other is treating a twelve-year-old conviction as automatically barred, which forgets that a proponent with specific facts and reasonable written notice can still win.