Concept
The Felony Threshold
Admissibility of a conviction to impeach under Rule 609(a)
The Felony Threshold
Rule 609(a)(1) starts with the crime, not the witness: was the offense, under the law of the convicting jurisdiction, punishable by death or by imprisonment for more than one year?1 A conviction that involves no dishonesty must pass this test before a court weighs anything about the witness or the trial. One that fails never reaches the balancing tests in the sections that follow. Three phrases carry the test: punishable, convicting jurisdiction, and more than one year.
The threshold exists because the rule treats serious crime as a stand-in for untruthfulness. The inference runs in steps. A convicted person does not respect society's rules of conduct, a person who flouts those rules is prone to lie, and so this witness may have lied on the stand.2 Felony laws express society's serious norms, and anyone who breaks them is deemed likely to break the perjury laws as well.3 Because seriousness only stands in for untruthfulness, the threshold reads a statute and not the facts of the offense. It asks what penalty the law attached to the crime and which jurisdiction attached it.
Punishable refers to the punishment that might have been imposed, not the punishment the court actually imposed.4 The rule measures how seriously the law treats the offense, so a light sentence does not pull a felony-grade conviction below the line.
The jurisdiction that counts is the one that convicted the witness. The law of the place of conviction controls, and the grade of a comparable federal crime does not.5 Exam stems like to bait the wrong comparison by remarking that the conduct would be a federal felony. The question is always what the convicting state's law authorized.
A witness convicted in a state that authorizes two years for the same conduct stands on the other side of the line, even if federal law would grade that conduct as a misdemeanor.
The line of more than one year usually, but not always, divides felonies from misdemeanors, so felony is convenient shorthand for the crimes that clear it.6 The rule's own words control, and those words describe a penalty. When a jurisdiction's felony or misdemeanor label diverges from the maximum term, the maximum term decides. An offense with a maximum of exactly one year falls short, because the rule demands more than one year.
Step five states the fate of the ordinary misdemeanor. Rule 609(a)(1) reaches only serious crimes that do not involve dishonesty, and a conviction qualifies only if the offense was punishable by death or imprisonment for more than one year.7 The only other route into evidence is Rule 609(a)(2), which requires admission of a conviction whose elements required proof or admission of a dishonest act or false statement, whatever the punishment.8 That route bypasses the felony line altogether, and a later section treats it in full.
Clearing the threshold decides little by itself. It makes a felony-grade conviction a candidate for impeachment, and whether the jury hears it depends on who the witness is. An ordinary witness faces one balancing test under Rule 609(a)(1)(A), and a testifying criminal defendant faces a different and more protective test under Rule 609(a)(1)(B).9 The next two sections take up each test.