Concept
Bias as a Credibility Attack
Bias and interest
Impeachment for Bias
Bias as a Credibility Attack
A witness who testifies for a relative, a paymaster, or a fellow gang member leaves the jury wondering how much of the account is memory and how much is loyalty. Impeachment for bias takes that doubt seriously and puts evidence behind it.
As United States v. Abel describes it, bias is the relationship between a party and a witness that might lead the witness to slant testimony, unconsciously or otherwise, in favor of or against that party. The slant may come from the witness's like, dislike, or fear of a party, or from the witness's own self-interest.1 Two features of that definition do the work. First, bias requires a link between this witness and this case: a feeling toward a party or a stake in the result. Second, the link pulls on what the witness says, and the pull can operate without the witness knowing it. An honest person can still be biased.
Because the definition turns on a link rather than a fixed list, bias takes many forms. Impeachment for bias consists of proving that a witness has a reason to lie or to slant testimony. Showing that an expert is being paid to testify qualifies. So does showing that the witness is romantically involved with the party the witness has testified for, or that the witness belongs to the same prison gang as that party.2
Abel shows how a single fact can carry the attack. A witness and the defendant belonged to the same gang, one that embraced secrecy and falsehood, and Justice Rehnquist reasoned that the shared membership supported the inference that the witness's testimony was slanted or perhaps fabricated.3 The limits on such proof come later in this chapter, but the case already hints at them. The trial court used Rule 403 to keep out particularly inflammatory and detailed evidence about the gang, including its name, the Aryan Brotherhood.4
The law treats bias evidence as relevant because of what the jury is asked to do. The jury must decide whom to believe, and it has historically been entitled to assess all evidence that might bear on the accuracy and truth of a witness's testimony. For that reason, proof of bias is almost always relevant.5 Justice Rehnquist reached the same result from first principles. Relevant evidence is admissible unless an exclusionary rule blocks it, and evidence of bias plainly meets the test of relevance because it diminishes the likelihood that the facts the biased witness reported are accurate.6 Bias has no rulebook of its own. It is governed by the general rules of evidence, which is why relevance and Rule 403 shape so much of what follows.7
Bias differs from the other ways of attacking credibility in what it claims about the witness. An attack on capacity says the witness could not perceive or remember reliably. An attack on character for truthfulness says the witness is the sort of person who lies. Bias says neither. It says that however honest the witness is in general and however sharp the witness's senses, this witness has a particular reason in this case to slant the account.8
The modern treatment of bias also reflects a choice about who may take the stand. The common law imposed disabilities that made many potential witnesses incompetent to testify. Federal Rule 601 reverses that approach and makes every person competent to be a witness unless the rules provide otherwise.9 Once the interested witness may testify, the question becomes how the jury learns of the interest. Bias impeachment answers it. The cross-examiner exposes the self-interest, and the jury, which is entitled to consider everything that bears on the truth of the account, decides how much weight the account deserves.10