Concept
Enforcement and Appellate Review
Form of questions
Enforcement and Appellate Review
Rule 611(c) says leading questions should not be used on direct examination except as necessary to develop the witness's testimony, and the choice of "should" over "must" governs what follows a form objection.1 A norm phrased as advice sits within the court's reasonable control over the mode and order of examining witnesses. Rule 611(a) directs the court to use that control to make procedures effective for determining the truth, to avoid wasting time, and to protect witnesses from harassment or undue embarrassment.2 The rule is soft at three points. The opponent decides whether to object, the judge decides what a sustained objection can accomplish, and an appellate court decides whether a ruling, right or wrong, justifies a new trial.
A leading question reaches the witness for one of two reasons. The opponent may decline to object, and the judge will not ordinarily intervene on her own. A lawyer can sensibly let a question pass when its damage looks smaller than the cost of objecting, which includes the interruption, the delay, and the impatience a jury may feel toward a lawyer who keeps rising.3 Or the situation may lie outside the general prohibition, as it does with a hostile witness or a witness identified with an adverse party.4 A question admitted on the second ground was never improper. A question admitted on the first may have been improper, but its admission shows only that the opponent judged the objection not worth its price. The calculation turns on the stakes: a lawyer may let a mildly leading question on a trivial point go by and still object when the question reaches the disputed center of the case.
Winning the objection yields less than it appears to. A leading question works when the witness hears it, so a ruling that follows the question arrives after the answer has been communicated, and the examiner can rephrase and collect the same testimony. Sustaining the objection may be more or less an empty gesture. Effective enforcement requires the judge to foreclose all further inquiry into the subject, or to let counsel return to it only after exploring other matters has reduced the effect of the suggestion.5 Those measures are available to the trial judge, but they are seldom invoked, and that rarity may suggest the rule lacks real substance and serves mainly to preserve a false sense of spontaneity.6 The judge's power reaches further where leading is allowed. On objection, or occasionally on her own initiative, she can restrict or terminate a leading inquiry that is being abused.7
Review is where the soft wording does its most visible work. Appellate courts have shown an almost total unwillingness to reverse for infractions of the leading rules. The subject falls within the judge's control over the mode and order of interrogation, and the rule is accordingly phrased in words of suggestion rather than command.8 The permissibility of leading questions is discretionary, and a judge's deviation from the usual practice will not be reversed unless it contributed to an unfair trial.9
A party who loses a leading ruling on a witness identified with an adverse party shows how little a wrong ruling can be worth. The phrase "witness identified with" was drafted to enlarge the category of persons a party may call and lead, because the older federal civil rule reached only an adverse party and its officers, directors, and managing agents, a limit the drafters thought unduly narrow.10 In one federal appeal, plaintiffs complained that the district court would not let them lead two police officers on direct examination. The court of appeals answered on harm. Nowhere in their briefs did the plaintiffs indicate what additional testimony they would have elicited had they been allowed to lead, so any harm from the ruling was purely speculative.11
That result follows from what leading is for. Leading is a way of obtaining testimony, and a party that cannot name testimony it failed to obtain has not shown that the ruling changed what the jury heard. A transcript records only what was asked and answered, so the appellant must supply the missing answers. A litigant who loses a leading ruling and wants appellate relief therefore has to be ready to say what the witness would have said.
The standard still leaves one route to reversal that does not depend on a single lost answer, which is a deviation from usual practice that contributed to an unfair trial.12
The two situations differ in what the appellant can point to. In the police-officer appeal there was one refusal with no identified loss, and the judgment stood. In the contract trial there is a course of one-sided rulings that tilted the presentation, so the appellant has more than an isolated error to show. Two questions therefore resolve most review problems. The first is whether the ruling was wrong at all, given the "should" wording and the situations in which leading is allowed. The second is what the ruling cost. Without identified lost testimony or a pattern that made the trial unfair, the judgment stands.